Investigating a Force-Based Selection Method for Smartwatches in a 1D Fitts’ Law Study and Two New Character-Level Keyboards

Abstract

Selecting small targets is difficult on tiny displays due to the “fat-finger problem”. In this paper, we explore the possibility of using a force-based approach to target selection on smartwatches. First, we identify the most comfortable range of force on smartwatches. We then conduct a 1D Fitts’ law study to compare the performance of tap and force-tap. Results revealed that force-tap is significantly better in selecting smaller targets, while tap outperforms force-tap for bigger targets. We then developed two new force-based keyboards to demonstrate the feasibility of force input in practical scenarios. These single-row alphabetical keyboards enable character-level text entry by performing slides and variating contact force. In a user study, these keyboards yielded about 4 wpm with about 2% error rate, demonstrating the viability of force input on smaller screens.