{"title":"GAZİLER OVACIĞINDAN ÇAĞDAŞ BİR DERVİŞ: CUMA ZEYTÜNLÜ (DERTLİ GARİP)","authors":"Caner Işık, Ezgi Aydin Onar","doi":"10.34189/hbv.95.003","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"There are only a few studies concerning the tradition of Alawi saints in the literature. Cuma Zeytunlu, the subject of this paper, is from a region known as “Gaziler Ovacigi” where the tradition of saintship has been observed in Turkey. He is a minstrel who writes folk poetry by using pseudonym called “Dertli Garip” (Garip the Heavyhearted). In recent years, there have been a significant transformation in the tradition of saintship, revealed by the way in which some saints call themselves as “contemporary dervishes”. In this article, the so called transformation of “contemporary dervishes” is exemplified through the case of Cuma Zeytunlu who lives in Amasya, Gumushacikoy.\nThe methodological framework of this study is based on an analysis of the world of meaning by using participant observation, interviews, and recording non-written folk poetry examples between 2005-2018. In this analysis, which focuses on tackling the theme of “contemporary dervishes”, the major methodological grounds of this article also rests on his biography, eleven poems written by minstrel Zeytunlu, his interpretations on his own poetry. For this reason, the basic subjects of meaning world of Cuma Zeytunlu, namely dervish identity, musahiplik (companionship), reincarnation, love, spiritual wisdom, dede identity, death and nafs, have been analyzed in this article. In the mean time, the ways in which newly emerging tradition of saintship de-emphasizes the notion of spirituality is another theme in the process of gaining new talents.\nThe theme of contemporary and traditional divide in understanding the tradition of saintship is another important issue in this article. While the traditional saintship emphasized spirituality through their poetry as well as their counselling on practical problems, in contemporary saintship the importance of rational argumentation and narratives is revealed more clearly. The more he distanced himself from the spiritual tradition of saintship the more he associated himself with the sphere of rationality and science, which has been coded as the major values of the contemporary saintship.\nCuma Zeytunlu, who disassociates himself from the spiritual interpretations, is a good example of some Alawi people who also distance themselves from mystical orientations in Alawi culture. Although he was not educated in the modern sense, the folk poet covered in this paper, has been trying to adapt change caused by modernization into his own tradition. This article has analyzed these processes.\nKeywords: Dertli Garip, the Plains of Gaziler, Bektashi people, contemporary dervishes, minstrels.","PeriodicalId":39168,"journal":{"name":"Turk Kulturu ve Haci Bektas Veli - Arastirma Dergisi","volume":"117 1","pages":"71-99"},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2020-09-12","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Turk Kulturu ve Haci Bektas Veli - Arastirma Dergisi","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.34189/hbv.95.003","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q3","JCRName":"Arts and Humanities","Score":null,"Total":0}
GAZİLER OVACIĞINDAN ÇAĞDAŞ BİR DERVİŞ: CUMA ZEYTÜNLÜ (DERTLİ GARİP)
There are only a few studies concerning the tradition of Alawi saints in the literature. Cuma Zeytunlu, the subject of this paper, is from a region known as “Gaziler Ovacigi” where the tradition of saintship has been observed in Turkey. He is a minstrel who writes folk poetry by using pseudonym called “Dertli Garip” (Garip the Heavyhearted). In recent years, there have been a significant transformation in the tradition of saintship, revealed by the way in which some saints call themselves as “contemporary dervishes”. In this article, the so called transformation of “contemporary dervishes” is exemplified through the case of Cuma Zeytunlu who lives in Amasya, Gumushacikoy.
The methodological framework of this study is based on an analysis of the world of meaning by using participant observation, interviews, and recording non-written folk poetry examples between 2005-2018. In this analysis, which focuses on tackling the theme of “contemporary dervishes”, the major methodological grounds of this article also rests on his biography, eleven poems written by minstrel Zeytunlu, his interpretations on his own poetry. For this reason, the basic subjects of meaning world of Cuma Zeytunlu, namely dervish identity, musahiplik (companionship), reincarnation, love, spiritual wisdom, dede identity, death and nafs, have been analyzed in this article. In the mean time, the ways in which newly emerging tradition of saintship de-emphasizes the notion of spirituality is another theme in the process of gaining new talents.
The theme of contemporary and traditional divide in understanding the tradition of saintship is another important issue in this article. While the traditional saintship emphasized spirituality through their poetry as well as their counselling on practical problems, in contemporary saintship the importance of rational argumentation and narratives is revealed more clearly. The more he distanced himself from the spiritual tradition of saintship the more he associated himself with the sphere of rationality and science, which has been coded as the major values of the contemporary saintship.
Cuma Zeytunlu, who disassociates himself from the spiritual interpretations, is a good example of some Alawi people who also distance themselves from mystical orientations in Alawi culture. Although he was not educated in the modern sense, the folk poet covered in this paper, has been trying to adapt change caused by modernization into his own tradition. This article has analyzed these processes.
Keywords: Dertli Garip, the Plains of Gaziler, Bektashi people, contemporary dervishes, minstrels.
期刊介绍:
Turkish Culture and Hacı Bektas Veli Research Quarterly is an international refereed journal, which fills the gap in its field, sets forth the most contemporary and striking opinions about the related issues, and gives place to unique scientific studies. Articles that will be sent to our journal should not be previously published and they should not be under consideration for publication elsewhere. If a study was presented before in a scientific conference or workshop, name, place, and date of that conference or workshop have to be specified. If a study is supported by a research center or fund, name of the supporting institution and project ID have to be specified.