Rosana Muniz de Medeiros, R. M. Vieira, Francislê Neri de Sousa
{"title":"促进批判性思维的策略:它是教学和教学实践的一部分吗?策略促进批判性思维:它的一部分Didactic -Pedagogical实践?","authors":"Rosana Muniz de Medeiros, R. M. Vieira, Francislê Neri de Sousa","doi":"10.17346/se.vol26.340","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Nos ultimos anos, em muitos paises, como o Brasil e Portugal, tem havido frequentes discursos educacionais sobre a relevância de levar o aluno a pensar criticamente. Com base neste objetivo, a questao de pesquisa do presente estudo e perceber o conhecimento que os professores possuem sobre as habilidades e disposicoes do Pensamento Critico (PC) e, qual o nivel de PC desses. Para tal, adotamos dois procedimentos metodologicos: aplicacao de um questionario, onde interpolamos provisoes do Ennis PC e outras acoes que nao promovem o PC - e a aplicacao do Teste Cornell PC (Nivel X). A ligacao entre esses dois procedimentos foi compartilhada como uma mensagem, no grupo fechado, de amigos professores do Facebook que atuam nos tres niveis de ensino, na rede publica e privada do Estado de Alagoas-Brasil. Adotamos uma metodologia qualitativa para analise do questionario e estatistica inferencial para o teste PC de Cornell. O resultado permitiu identificar que um numero substancial de professores nao tem consciencia do que seriam as disposicoes do pensamento critico; em relacao ao nivel de PC, o estudo demonstrou que os professores apresentavam um nivel ligeiramente abaixo da media obtida em outros dois estudos desenvolvidos em Portugal. Strategies Promoting Critical Thinking: Is It Part of Didactic-Pedagogical Practices? In recent years, in many countries such as Brazil and Portugal, there has been frequent educational discourse about the relevance of leading the student to think critically. Based on this objective, the research question of the present study is to perceive the knowledge that the teachers hold about the skills and dispositions of Critical Thinking (PC) and, what their PC level. For this, we adopted two methodological procedures: application of a questionnaire, where we interpolated provisions of Ennis PC and other actions not promoting the PC - and the application of the Cornell PC Test (Level X). The link between these two procedures was shared as a message, in the closed group, of Facebook teacher’s friends who work in the three levels of education, in the public and private network of the State of Alagoas-Brazil. We adopted a qualitative methodology for the analysis of the questionnaire and inferential statistics for the Cornell PC test. The result made it possible to identify that a substantial number of teachers are unaware of what would be the disposition of critical thinking; in relation to their CP level, the study showed that teachers presented a level slightly below the average obtained in 2 other studies developed in Portugal. Keywords: Critical Thinking; Critical Attitude; Didactic-Pedagogical Practices Data de rececao: 15/05/2019 Decisao Final: 14/10/2019","PeriodicalId":30495,"journal":{"name":"Saber Educar","volume":" ","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2019-07-11","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":"{\"title\":\"Estratégias Promotoras do Pensamento Crítico:Faz parte das Práticas didático-pedagógicas?Strategies Promoting Critical Thinking: Is It Part of Didactic-Pedagogical Practices?\",\"authors\":\"Rosana Muniz de Medeiros, R. M. Vieira, Francislê Neri de Sousa\",\"doi\":\"10.17346/se.vol26.340\",\"DOIUrl\":null,\"url\":null,\"abstract\":\"Nos ultimos anos, em muitos paises, como o Brasil e Portugal, tem havido frequentes discursos educacionais sobre a relevância de levar o aluno a pensar criticamente. Com base neste objetivo, a questao de pesquisa do presente estudo e perceber o conhecimento que os professores possuem sobre as habilidades e disposicoes do Pensamento Critico (PC) e, qual o nivel de PC desses. Para tal, adotamos dois procedimentos metodologicos: aplicacao de um questionario, onde interpolamos provisoes do Ennis PC e outras acoes que nao promovem o PC - e a aplicacao do Teste Cornell PC (Nivel X). A ligacao entre esses dois procedimentos foi compartilhada como uma mensagem, no grupo fechado, de amigos professores do Facebook que atuam nos tres niveis de ensino, na rede publica e privada do Estado de Alagoas-Brasil. Adotamos uma metodologia qualitativa para analise do questionario e estatistica inferencial para o teste PC de Cornell. O resultado permitiu identificar que um numero substancial de professores nao tem consciencia do que seriam as disposicoes do pensamento critico; em relacao ao nivel de PC, o estudo demonstrou que os professores apresentavam um nivel ligeiramente abaixo da media obtida em outros dois estudos desenvolvidos em Portugal. Strategies Promoting Critical Thinking: Is It Part of Didactic-Pedagogical Practices? In recent years, in many countries such as Brazil and Portugal, there has been frequent educational discourse about the relevance of leading the student to think critically. Based on this objective, the research question of the present study is to perceive the knowledge that the teachers hold about the skills and dispositions of Critical Thinking (PC) and, what their PC level. For this, we adopted two methodological procedures: application of a questionnaire, where we interpolated provisions of Ennis PC and other actions not promoting the PC - and the application of the Cornell PC Test (Level X). The link between these two procedures was shared as a message, in the closed group, of Facebook teacher’s friends who work in the three levels of education, in the public and private network of the State of Alagoas-Brazil. We adopted a qualitative methodology for the analysis of the questionnaire and inferential statistics for the Cornell PC test. The result made it possible to identify that a substantial number of teachers are unaware of what would be the disposition of critical thinking; in relation to their CP level, the study showed that teachers presented a level slightly below the average obtained in 2 other studies developed in Portugal. Keywords: Critical Thinking; Critical Attitude; Didactic-Pedagogical Practices Data de rececao: 15/05/2019 Decisao Final: 14/10/2019\",\"PeriodicalId\":30495,\"journal\":{\"name\":\"Saber Educar\",\"volume\":\" \",\"pages\":\"\"},\"PeriodicalIF\":0.0000,\"publicationDate\":\"2019-07-11\",\"publicationTypes\":\"Journal Article\",\"fieldsOfStudy\":null,\"isOpenAccess\":false,\"openAccessPdf\":\"\",\"citationCount\":\"0\",\"resultStr\":null,\"platform\":\"Semanticscholar\",\"paperid\":null,\"PeriodicalName\":\"Saber Educar\",\"FirstCategoryId\":\"1085\",\"ListUrlMain\":\"https://doi.org/10.17346/se.vol26.340\",\"RegionNum\":0,\"RegionCategory\":null,\"ArticlePicture\":[],\"TitleCN\":null,\"AbstractTextCN\":null,\"PMCID\":null,\"EPubDate\":\"\",\"PubModel\":\"\",\"JCR\":\"\",\"JCRName\":\"\",\"Score\":null,\"Total\":0}","platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Saber Educar","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.17346/se.vol26.340","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
摘要
近年来,在许多国家,如巴西和葡萄牙,经常有关于引导学生批判性思考的重要性的教育演讲。基于这一目标,本研究的研究问题是了解教师对批判性思维技能和性格的知识,以及这些技能和性格的水平。来信奉,方法论的两个过程:实现一个问卷,埃尼斯interpolamos规定等行为不同时的PC -测试和实现大学生个人电脑(X)的水平。这两个过程之间的联系和闭群里信息,分享在Facebook的朋友老师(我们三个教育水平,在私人和公共网络的状态阿拉戈斯坚果。我们采用定性的方法对问卷进行分析,并对康奈尔PC测试进行推理统计。结果表明,相当多的教师没有意识到批判性思维的倾向是什么;在PC水平方面,研究表明,教师的水平略低于葡萄牙其他两项研究的平均水平。策略促进批判性思维:它的一部分Didactic -Pedagogical实践?近年来,在许多国家,如巴西和葡萄牙,关于引导学生批判性思考的相关性的教育论述十分普遍。基于这一目标,本研究的研究问题是了解教师掌握的关于批判性思维技能和性格的知识,以及他们的批判性思维水平。", " adopted一家两种方法论的应用程序:在问卷我们interpolated埃尼斯的电脑和其他规定的行为不是促进大学生电脑的应用PC - and the Test (X)。这两个程序之间的链接是联合的Facebook的消息,在封闭组,老师’的朋友,在这三个层次的教育工作,在公共和私人网络阿拉戈斯州的联合赞助。我们采用定性方法对问卷进行分析,并对康奈尔PC测试进行推理统计。这一结果使我们有可能确定大量教师不知道批判性思维的倾向是什么;关于他们的CP水平,研究表明,教师的CP水平略低于葡萄牙其他两项研究的平均水平。关键词:批判性思维;关键的态度;教学-教学实践截止日期:15/05/2019最终决定:14/10/2019
Estratégias Promotoras do Pensamento Crítico:Faz parte das Práticas didático-pedagógicas?Strategies Promoting Critical Thinking: Is It Part of Didactic-Pedagogical Practices?
Nos ultimos anos, em muitos paises, como o Brasil e Portugal, tem havido frequentes discursos educacionais sobre a relevância de levar o aluno a pensar criticamente. Com base neste objetivo, a questao de pesquisa do presente estudo e perceber o conhecimento que os professores possuem sobre as habilidades e disposicoes do Pensamento Critico (PC) e, qual o nivel de PC desses. Para tal, adotamos dois procedimentos metodologicos: aplicacao de um questionario, onde interpolamos provisoes do Ennis PC e outras acoes que nao promovem o PC - e a aplicacao do Teste Cornell PC (Nivel X). A ligacao entre esses dois procedimentos foi compartilhada como uma mensagem, no grupo fechado, de amigos professores do Facebook que atuam nos tres niveis de ensino, na rede publica e privada do Estado de Alagoas-Brasil. Adotamos uma metodologia qualitativa para analise do questionario e estatistica inferencial para o teste PC de Cornell. O resultado permitiu identificar que um numero substancial de professores nao tem consciencia do que seriam as disposicoes do pensamento critico; em relacao ao nivel de PC, o estudo demonstrou que os professores apresentavam um nivel ligeiramente abaixo da media obtida em outros dois estudos desenvolvidos em Portugal. Strategies Promoting Critical Thinking: Is It Part of Didactic-Pedagogical Practices? In recent years, in many countries such as Brazil and Portugal, there has been frequent educational discourse about the relevance of leading the student to think critically. Based on this objective, the research question of the present study is to perceive the knowledge that the teachers hold about the skills and dispositions of Critical Thinking (PC) and, what their PC level. For this, we adopted two methodological procedures: application of a questionnaire, where we interpolated provisions of Ennis PC and other actions not promoting the PC - and the application of the Cornell PC Test (Level X). The link between these two procedures was shared as a message, in the closed group, of Facebook teacher’s friends who work in the three levels of education, in the public and private network of the State of Alagoas-Brazil. We adopted a qualitative methodology for the analysis of the questionnaire and inferential statistics for the Cornell PC test. The result made it possible to identify that a substantial number of teachers are unaware of what would be the disposition of critical thinking; in relation to their CP level, the study showed that teachers presented a level slightly below the average obtained in 2 other studies developed in Portugal. Keywords: Critical Thinking; Critical Attitude; Didactic-Pedagogical Practices Data de rececao: 15/05/2019 Decisao Final: 14/10/2019