Electrostatic limits on charge selectivity in ultrahigh charge density polymer membranes

Ion-exchange membranes (IEMs) with ultrahigh charge densities offer the promise of enhanced ion transport for electrochemical technologies, yet the fundamental limits of this membrane design strategy are not yet understood. In this work, we present a systematic study of bis(1-vinyl-3-imidazolium) cross-linked polymer membranes with fixed charge contents ranging from 6 to 9 mol/L[dry polymer], synthesized to isolate the effects of charge density at constant membrane water content. While ionic conductivity increases monotonically with increasing charge density, a sharp decline in charge selectivity is observed for the most densely charged membranes, defying conventional expectations. Structural, thermal, and mechanical analyses reveal a critical onset of network disruption and anomalous ion partitioning behavior in these densely charged membranes. With proper consideration of cross-linker geometry, these results are interpreted using Manning's counter-ion condensation theory, which suggests that closely packed charged cross-linkers amplify inter-chain electrostatic interactions and trigger excess counter-ion condensation. Our findings suggest that, beyond a threshold spacing between fixed charges, increased functionalization may harm rather than help charge selectivity of IEMs.