Marina A. Ivanova, Svetlana N. Teplyakova, Cyril A. Lorenz, Shuying Yang, Munir Humayun
{"title":"戈达山013 СBa-like球粒陨石球粒岩和球粒岩岩性中金属的起源","authors":"Marina A. Ivanova, Svetlana N. Teplyakova, Cyril A. Lorenz, Shuying Yang, Munir Humayun","doi":"10.1111/maps.70005","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"<p>Sierra Gorda 013 (SG 013) is an unusual CBa-like chondrite containing two texturally different, isotopically identical lithologies—chondritic (L1) and achondritic (L2), which should have a common origin. The metal globules of the L1 metal preserved the magmatic pattern of the siderophile element distribution that indicates they had a fractionated precursor. In this work, the trace element metal composition of lithology 2 was studied, and the revisited LA-ICP-MS data on the L1 metal was presented. Lithologies 1 and 2 have Ni and Co in the range of CB chondrites. The Ni-Co distribution in L1 and depletion in Cr of both lithologies with a negative Cr-Ni correlation are similar to that of the magmatic irons. Highly refractory siderophile element (HRSE) (W, Re, Os, Ir, Pt, Ru, Rh, and Mo) compositions of the L1 metal are highly fractionated relative to CI, but the L2 metal has a nearly uniform HRSE distribution similar to the depleted patterns of some HRSE-poor L1 metal compositions. Metal from both lithologies is depleted in volatile siderophile elements. In the L1 metal globules, the metal composition shows definite linear correlations of the HRSE elements versus Ni similar to those observed in many magmatic iron meteorites, distinct from those of the CH/CBb-zoned metal. Meanwhile, the L2 metal compositions are systematically plotted as limited clusters in the middle of the L1 trends. Based on a fractional crystallization (FC) model of the CR-like metal composition, it was shown that the distribution of siderophile elements in the metal globules of L1 can cover the full range of the fractional crystallization products of a metallic (Fe-Ni-S) liquid from the core of a differentiated body at S content 13 wt%. In contrast, the metal from L2 corresponds to a more limited range of fractional crystallization products and indicates a mixture of the fractionated metal with the primitive metal from the chondritic colliding body. Our results suggest that during a catastrophic impact event when the metallic core of a differentiated body was disrupted, the L1 lithology was quickly cooled in the impact plume, more reduced than that of CB chondrites and avoided equilibration with plume gas and preserved its fractionated HRSE patterns. The distribution of siderophile volatile elements and Au was likely overprinted by high-temperature processes of volatilization and recondensation to different degrees in the impact plume under disequilibrium conditions. The L2 metal probably avoided equilibration with the plume gas and was affected by thermal metamorphism up to 900°C in the SG 013 parent body, which possibly resulted in the higher W abundance compared to the L1 metal with a magmatic Ir-W trend due to the redox reactions with silicates under reducing conditions.</p>","PeriodicalId":18555,"journal":{"name":"Meteoritics & Planetary Science","volume":"60 8","pages":"1762-1784"},"PeriodicalIF":2.4000,"publicationDate":"2025-06-27","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":"{\"title\":\"Origin of the metal in chondritic and achondritic lithologies of the Sierra Gorda 013 СBa-like chondrite\",\"authors\":\"Marina A. Ivanova, Svetlana N. Teplyakova, Cyril A. Lorenz, Shuying Yang, Munir Humayun\",\"doi\":\"10.1111/maps.70005\",\"DOIUrl\":null,\"url\":null,\"abstract\":\"<p>Sierra Gorda 013 (SG 013) is an unusual CBa-like chondrite containing two texturally different, isotopically identical lithologies—chondritic (L1) and achondritic (L2), which should have a common origin. The metal globules of the L1 metal preserved the magmatic pattern of the siderophile element distribution that indicates they had a fractionated precursor. In this work, the trace element metal composition of lithology 2 was studied, and the revisited LA-ICP-MS data on the L1 metal was presented. Lithologies 1 and 2 have Ni and Co in the range of CB chondrites. The Ni-Co distribution in L1 and depletion in Cr of both lithologies with a negative Cr-Ni correlation are similar to that of the magmatic irons. Highly refractory siderophile element (HRSE) (W, Re, Os, Ir, Pt, Ru, Rh, and Mo) compositions of the L1 metal are highly fractionated relative to CI, but the L2 metal has a nearly uniform HRSE distribution similar to the depleted patterns of some HRSE-poor L1 metal compositions. Metal from both lithologies is depleted in volatile siderophile elements. In the L1 metal globules, the metal composition shows definite linear correlations of the HRSE elements versus Ni similar to those observed in many magmatic iron meteorites, distinct from those of the CH/CBb-zoned metal. Meanwhile, the L2 metal compositions are systematically plotted as limited clusters in the middle of the L1 trends. Based on a fractional crystallization (FC) model of the CR-like metal composition, it was shown that the distribution of siderophile elements in the metal globules of L1 can cover the full range of the fractional crystallization products of a metallic (Fe-Ni-S) liquid from the core of a differentiated body at S content 13 wt%. In contrast, the metal from L2 corresponds to a more limited range of fractional crystallization products and indicates a mixture of the fractionated metal with the primitive metal from the chondritic colliding body. Our results suggest that during a catastrophic impact event when the metallic core of a differentiated body was disrupted, the L1 lithology was quickly cooled in the impact plume, more reduced than that of CB chondrites and avoided equilibration with plume gas and preserved its fractionated HRSE patterns. The distribution of siderophile volatile elements and Au was likely overprinted by high-temperature processes of volatilization and recondensation to different degrees in the impact plume under disequilibrium conditions. The L2 metal probably avoided equilibration with the plume gas and was affected by thermal metamorphism up to 900°C in the SG 013 parent body, which possibly resulted in the higher W abundance compared to the L1 metal with a magmatic Ir-W trend due to the redox reactions with silicates under reducing conditions.</p>\",\"PeriodicalId\":18555,\"journal\":{\"name\":\"Meteoritics & Planetary Science\",\"volume\":\"60 8\",\"pages\":\"1762-1784\"},\"PeriodicalIF\":2.4000,\"publicationDate\":\"2025-06-27\",\"publicationTypes\":\"Journal Article\",\"fieldsOfStudy\":null,\"isOpenAccess\":false,\"openAccessPdf\":\"\",\"citationCount\":\"0\",\"resultStr\":null,\"platform\":\"Semanticscholar\",\"paperid\":null,\"PeriodicalName\":\"Meteoritics & Planetary Science\",\"FirstCategoryId\":\"89\",\"ListUrlMain\":\"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/maps.70005\",\"RegionNum\":4,\"RegionCategory\":\"地球科学\",\"ArticlePicture\":[],\"TitleCN\":null,\"AbstractTextCN\":null,\"PMCID\":null,\"EPubDate\":\"\",\"PubModel\":\"\",\"JCR\":\"Q2\",\"JCRName\":\"GEOCHEMISTRY & GEOPHYSICS\",\"Score\":null,\"Total\":0}","platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Meteoritics & Planetary Science","FirstCategoryId":"89","ListUrlMain":"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/maps.70005","RegionNum":4,"RegionCategory":"地球科学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q2","JCRName":"GEOCHEMISTRY & GEOPHYSICS","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
摘要
Sierra Gorda 013 (SG 013)是一种罕见的cba样球粒陨石,含有两种结构不同、同位素相同的岩性——球粒岩(L1)和球粒岩(L2),它们应该有共同的起源。L1金属的金属球保留了亲铁元素分布的岩浆模式,表明它们具有分馏前驱体。本文对岩性2的微量元素金属组成进行了研究,并对L1金属的LA-ICP-MS数据进行了重访。岩性1和2在CB球粒陨石范围内含有Ni和Co。两种岩性的L1中Ni-Co分布与Cr- ni负相关特征与岩浆铁相似。相对于CI, L1金属的高难熔亲铁元素(W、Re、Os、Ir、Pt、Ru、Rh和Mo)组成具有高度分异,但L2金属的HRSE分布几乎均匀,类似于一些HRSE较差的L1金属组成的耗尽模式。两种岩性的金属在挥发性亲铁元素中被耗尽。在L1金属球中,HRSE元素与Ni的线性关系与许多岩浆铁陨石中观察到的相似,与CH/ cbb带金属的线性关系不同。同时,L2金属成分被系统地绘制为L1趋势中间的有限簇。基于cr类金属组成的分数结晶(FC)模型,结果表明,在S含量为13 wt%时,L1金属球中亲铁元素的分布可以覆盖从分化体核心产生的金属(Fe-Ni-S)液体的全部分数结晶产物。相比之下,L2中的金属对应于更有限范围的分馏结晶产物,表明分馏金属与球粒状碰撞体中的原始金属的混合物。我们的研究结果表明,在灾难性的撞击事件中,当分化体的金属核被破坏时,L1岩性在撞击羽流中迅速冷却,比CB球粒陨石更少,避免了与羽流气体的平衡,并保留了其分异的HRSE模式。在不平衡条件下,撞击羽流中亲铁挥发元素和Au的分布可能不同程度地叠加了高温挥发和再冷凝过程。在SG 013母体中,L2金属可能由于与硅酸盐在还原条件下发生氧化还原反应,避免了与烟羽气体的平衡,并受到高达900℃的热变质作用的影响,导致其W丰度高于L1金属,并呈现岩浆Ir-W趋势。
Origin of the metal in chondritic and achondritic lithologies of the Sierra Gorda 013 СBa-like chondrite
Sierra Gorda 013 (SG 013) is an unusual CBa-like chondrite containing two texturally different, isotopically identical lithologies—chondritic (L1) and achondritic (L2), which should have a common origin. The metal globules of the L1 metal preserved the magmatic pattern of the siderophile element distribution that indicates they had a fractionated precursor. In this work, the trace element metal composition of lithology 2 was studied, and the revisited LA-ICP-MS data on the L1 metal was presented. Lithologies 1 and 2 have Ni and Co in the range of CB chondrites. The Ni-Co distribution in L1 and depletion in Cr of both lithologies with a negative Cr-Ni correlation are similar to that of the magmatic irons. Highly refractory siderophile element (HRSE) (W, Re, Os, Ir, Pt, Ru, Rh, and Mo) compositions of the L1 metal are highly fractionated relative to CI, but the L2 metal has a nearly uniform HRSE distribution similar to the depleted patterns of some HRSE-poor L1 metal compositions. Metal from both lithologies is depleted in volatile siderophile elements. In the L1 metal globules, the metal composition shows definite linear correlations of the HRSE elements versus Ni similar to those observed in many magmatic iron meteorites, distinct from those of the CH/CBb-zoned metal. Meanwhile, the L2 metal compositions are systematically plotted as limited clusters in the middle of the L1 trends. Based on a fractional crystallization (FC) model of the CR-like metal composition, it was shown that the distribution of siderophile elements in the metal globules of L1 can cover the full range of the fractional crystallization products of a metallic (Fe-Ni-S) liquid from the core of a differentiated body at S content 13 wt%. In contrast, the metal from L2 corresponds to a more limited range of fractional crystallization products and indicates a mixture of the fractionated metal with the primitive metal from the chondritic colliding body. Our results suggest that during a catastrophic impact event when the metallic core of a differentiated body was disrupted, the L1 lithology was quickly cooled in the impact plume, more reduced than that of CB chondrites and avoided equilibration with plume gas and preserved its fractionated HRSE patterns. The distribution of siderophile volatile elements and Au was likely overprinted by high-temperature processes of volatilization and recondensation to different degrees in the impact plume under disequilibrium conditions. The L2 metal probably avoided equilibration with the plume gas and was affected by thermal metamorphism up to 900°C in the SG 013 parent body, which possibly resulted in the higher W abundance compared to the L1 metal with a magmatic Ir-W trend due to the redox reactions with silicates under reducing conditions.
期刊介绍:
First issued in 1953, the journal publishes research articles describing the latest results of new studies, invited reviews of major topics in planetary science, editorials on issues of current interest in the field, and book reviews. The publications are original, not considered for publication elsewhere, and undergo peer-review. The topics include the origin and history of the solar system, planets and natural satellites, interplanetary dust and interstellar medium, lunar samples, meteors, and meteorites, asteroids, comets, craters, and tektites. Our authors and editors are professional scientists representing numerous disciplines, including astronomy, astrophysics, physics, geophysics, chemistry, isotope geochemistry, mineralogy, earth science, geology, and biology. MAPS has subscribers in over 40 countries. Fifty percent of MAPS'' readers are based outside the USA. The journal is available in hard copy and online.