Mentoring across differences: Introducing hidden curriculum competencies for scientific mentors.

Background: The hidden curriculum refers to the implicit norms and behaviors in academic environments that can particularly disadvantage scholars from backgrounds underrepresented in the scientific workforce (URSW). Critically, scientific mentors can support URSW mentees by making the hidden curriculum explicit to help these scholars navigate academia more effectively. However, mentors often lack the lived experience or training necessary to understand and fully address relevant hidden curriculum challenges.

Methods: We developed a set of 16 hidden curriculum competencies specifically for scientific mentors working with URSW mentees. A survey was conducted among diversity, equity, inclusion, and accessibility experts in translational science to assess the perceived importance of each competency. Their feedback was used to refine the final competencies, from which a conceptual framework was developed.

Results: Survey results (n = 62) showed broad agreement on the competencies' critical importance for mentoring across diversity, with several competencies, including identifying unconscious biases, acting as allies, and demystifying career pathways, receiving over 90% agreement for their importance for mentoring URSW mentees. Respondents from URSW backgrounds placed greater emphasis (p < 0.05) on several competencies, including understanding mentee perspectives, expanding professional networks, and allyship.

Conclusion: The 16 competencies, grouped into four domains (Foundation, Career, Science, and Overcoming Bias), collectively offer a comprehensive approach for mentors to build trust, support mentee career development, overcome practical barriers to mentee engagement in research, and actively combat bias. Our conceptual framework offers structured guidance for mentors and mentor training programs, identifying the skills needed to foster inclusive academic environments and enhance URSW retention and success.