Leen Jabban, Nathan Routledge, Nicos Hadjigeorgiou, Anna Hoyle, Jonathan Graham-Harper-Cater, Dingguo Zhang, Benjamin W Metcalfe
{"title":"The comfort of temporal interference stimulation on the forearm: computational and psychophysical evaluation.","authors":"Leen Jabban, Nathan Routledge, Nicos Hadjigeorgiou, Anna Hoyle, Jonathan Graham-Harper-Cater, Dingguo Zhang, Benjamin W Metcalfe","doi":"10.1088/1741-2552/adc33b","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"<p><p><i>Objective.</i>Transcutaneous electrical stimulation aims to restore sensation and function in individuals with sensory or motor deficits. However, limited selectivity and unintended nerve recruitment often result in discomfort. Temporal interference (TI) stimulation has been proposed as a novel approach to non-invasive nerve stimulation, hypothesising that low-frequency modulation of kilohertz carriers reduces activation thresholds. Prior studies have produced conflicting results regarding comfort in kilohertz-frequency stimulation, and the practical applicability of TI remains unclear. This study addresses these gaps by systematically analysing the role of depth of modulation in activation thresholds and comfort, focusing on peripheral nerves and clinically relevant stimulation levels.<i>Approach.</i>This study uses a dual-method approach combining computational and psychophysical experiments targeting the median nerve. Computational modelling involved nine magnetic resonance imaging-informed finite element models to account for anatomical variability and biophysical neural activation predictions using NEURON., test Psychophysical experiments with 19 participants determined stimulation thresholds and comfort levels. Statistical analysis using the Friedman test and Bonferroni correction assessed the impact of carrier and beat frequencies, and depth of modulation on activation thresholds and comfort.<i>Main results.</i>The results showed that the activation thresholds did not vary with the depth of modulation, challenging the core assumption underlying temporal interference stimulation. Despite that, comfort significantly increased with carrier frequencies as low as 500 Hz, with no further significant changes at higher frequencies. Computational modelling results showed an association between increased comfort and asynchronous nerve activation patterns, providing a possible explanation for the observed improvement in comfort.<i>Significance.</i>By challenging a core assumption of TI stimulation, this study shifts the focus from threshold modulation to optimising comfort in peripheral nerve stimulation. These findings establish a foundation for developing kilohertz-frequency stimulation protocols prioritising user comfort, particularly in applications such as functional electrical stimulation for rehabilitation or sensory feedback for prostheses.</p>","PeriodicalId":94096,"journal":{"name":"Journal of neural engineering","volume":" ","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2025-04-03","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Journal of neural engineering","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.1088/1741-2552/adc33b","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
摘要
目的:经皮电刺激旨在恢复感觉或运动障碍患者的感觉和功能。然而,有限的选择性和非预期的神经募集往往会导致不适。颞叶干扰(TI)刺激被认为是一种非侵入性神经刺激的新方法,它假设千赫兹载流子的低频调制可降低激活阈值。之前的研究在千赫兹频率刺激的舒适度方面得出了相互矛盾的结果,而 TI 的实际应用性仍不明确。本研究通过系统分析调制深度在激活阈值和舒适度方面的作用,重点研究外周神经和临床相关刺激水平,弥补了这些不足:本研究采用计算和心理物理实验相结合的双重方法,以正中神经为目标。计算建模包括九个以核磁共振成像为基础的有限元模型,以考虑解剖变异性和使用 NEURON 进行的生物物理神经激活预测。对 19 名参与者进行的心理物理实验确定了刺激阈值和舒适度。使用弗里德曼检验和邦费罗尼校正进行统计分析,评估了载波和节拍频率以及调制深度对激活阈值和舒适度的影响:结果表明,激活阈值并不随调制深度的变化而变化,这对时间干扰刺激的核心假设提出了质疑。尽管如此,载波频率低至 500 赫兹时,舒适度明显增加,频率越高,舒适度变化越小。计算建模结果表明,舒适度的提高与异步神经激活模式有关,这为观察到的舒适度改善提供了可能的解释:通过挑战 TI 刺激的核心假设,本研究将重点从阈值调节转移到优化周围神经刺激的舒适度上。这些发现为制定千赫兹频率刺激方案奠定了基础,该方案优先考虑用户的舒适度,特别是在康复功能电刺激或假肢感觉反馈等应用中。
The comfort of temporal interference stimulation on the forearm: computational and psychophysical evaluation.
Objective.Transcutaneous electrical stimulation aims to restore sensation and function in individuals with sensory or motor deficits. However, limited selectivity and unintended nerve recruitment often result in discomfort. Temporal interference (TI) stimulation has been proposed as a novel approach to non-invasive nerve stimulation, hypothesising that low-frequency modulation of kilohertz carriers reduces activation thresholds. Prior studies have produced conflicting results regarding comfort in kilohertz-frequency stimulation, and the practical applicability of TI remains unclear. This study addresses these gaps by systematically analysing the role of depth of modulation in activation thresholds and comfort, focusing on peripheral nerves and clinically relevant stimulation levels.Approach.This study uses a dual-method approach combining computational and psychophysical experiments targeting the median nerve. Computational modelling involved nine magnetic resonance imaging-informed finite element models to account for anatomical variability and biophysical neural activation predictions using NEURON., test Psychophysical experiments with 19 participants determined stimulation thresholds and comfort levels. Statistical analysis using the Friedman test and Bonferroni correction assessed the impact of carrier and beat frequencies, and depth of modulation on activation thresholds and comfort.Main results.The results showed that the activation thresholds did not vary with the depth of modulation, challenging the core assumption underlying temporal interference stimulation. Despite that, comfort significantly increased with carrier frequencies as low as 500 Hz, with no further significant changes at higher frequencies. Computational modelling results showed an association between increased comfort and asynchronous nerve activation patterns, providing a possible explanation for the observed improvement in comfort.Significance.By challenging a core assumption of TI stimulation, this study shifts the focus from threshold modulation to optimising comfort in peripheral nerve stimulation. These findings establish a foundation for developing kilohertz-frequency stimulation protocols prioritising user comfort, particularly in applications such as functional electrical stimulation for rehabilitation or sensory feedback for prostheses.