The Relation Between Carotenoids Measured in the Skin and Eye

Background

Carotenoid amounts measured in the skin and retina are increasingly being used as biomarkers of general health, function, and disease. However, whether they are directly interchangeable is not clear. Several previous studies comparing the measures in adults and children have found inconsistent results.

Objectives

The objective of this observational study is to assess the relation between carotenoid amounts measured in the skin and retina.

Methods

We assessed the relation between the 2 measurements over an extended period and multiple testing sessions; 21 healthy participants were assessed (mean age, 27.0 y; SD, 9.8 y). Macular carotenoids were measured using a standard method based on customized heterochromatic flicker photometry. Skin carotenoids were measured using pressure-mediated reflection spectroscopy.

Results

Both retinal and skin measures showed high reliability (intraclass correlations > 0.90) and stability over time. The 2 measures, when averaged over 5 testing sessions, were moderately but significantly correlated (r = 0.55; P = 0.01).

Conclusions

Skin carotenoid amounts accounted for approximately a third of the variance in retinal carotenoid density. Carotenoids in both skin and retina likely share many factors that both promote and interfere with accumulation. Each, however, also likely has some unique predictive characteristics as a biomarker. Therefore, when using physiologic carotenoids as a biomarker, the outcome of interest should determine whether to measure carotenoids dermally or in the retina.