Long-term prognosis of elderly patients undergoing atrial septal defect closure: are we acting too late?

Background: Atrial septal defects (ASD) often go unrecognized until very late in life. The impact of ASD closure on life expectancy in elderly patients remains unclear. This study compares the survival of patients≥65-years who underwent ASD closure with their average life expectancy (ALE).

Methods: Single-centre retrospective study including all patients ≥65-years who underwent ostium secundum (OS) ASD closure (surgical/percutaneous) between 1998-2020. Baseline characteristics and the predicted peri-procedural ALE (as determined per pre-defined national ALE tables) for every given patient were assessed.

Results: 706 patients underwent OS ASD closure, 37 (5%) had ≥65 years-mean age 69±5 years, 62% presented with heart failure. Mean ASD size=21±9mm, 22% patients had severe tricuspid regurgitation, mean systolic pulmonary artery pressure (SPAP)=50±11mmHg. Five patients were treated surgically. At a mean follow-up of 9±5 years, mortality rate was 46%, occurring 8.8±5.3 years after the procedure. 25 (68%) outlived their predicted ALE. Overall, the mean age of death did not differ from the predicted ALE (79±6 vs. 84±1 years, p=0.304), however there was a 10-year absolute difference between patients who died prematurely vs. those who surpassed ALE (77±4 vs. 87±3 years, p<0.001). Patients who failed to reach ALE had higher SPAP (58±10 vs. 46±8mmHg, p=0.001) and a higher incidence of severe tricuspid regurgitation (42 vs. 12%, p=0.040).

Conclusion: Survival after late ASD closure was comparable to the expected ALE, though one-third of the patients died prematurely. Higher SPAP and severe tricuspid regurgitation were associated with premature death. ASD closure in elderly requires a thorough evaluation to ensure maximum benefit.