A comparison of clinical and radiographic outcomes between isolated total talus replacement and combined total talus replacement with total ankle arthroplasty or hindfoot arthrodesis.

Total talus replacement (TTR) is a viable surgical option in the setting of talar avascular necrosis and collapse, as well as a revision option for failed total ankle arthroplasty with talar implant subsidence. The purpose of the present study was to compare the clinical and radiographic outcomes following isolated TTR and TTR combined with total ankle arthroplasty or hindfoot arthrodesis. Patients who underwent TTR were retrospectively reviewed, as a multicenter consecutive case series. Basic demographic data, comorbidities and surgical date were collected. Medical records were reviewed to obtain postoperative and preoperative visual analog scale (VAS) scores, American Orthopedic Foot and Ankle society (AOFAS) outcome scores, postoperative complications and radiographic measurements. Statistical analysis was conducted to compare radiographic and patient-reported outcomes pre- and postoperatively. Thirty-six patients underwent TTR with mean follow-up of 25.39 months. VAS pain scores improved postoperatively from 8.43 to 2.67 (P <0.001). AOFAS improved postoperatively from 36.33 to 81.78 (P < 0.001). There was an overall improvement in talar arc length (P = 0.035), talar width (P = 0.0037), talar height (P < 0.001), Bohler's (P < 0.001) and Gissane's angle (P = 0.004). The overall complication and subsequent surgery rate were each 16.7 %. The TTR implant survivorship rate was found to be 94.5 %. When comparing outcome scores between Isolated TTR and Combined TTR, no significant differences were detected in the degree of improvement. Both isolated and combined TTR provide a suitable and safe option for the treatment of advanced talar AVN or associated tibiotalar and hindfoot arthritis.