A Prospective Randomized Controlled Study of Stratafix versus Standard-of-Care for Deep Tissue Closure in Orthopedic Surgery.

Background: Orthopedic deep surgical incisions require the approximation of 1 or multiple tissue layers. This prospective randomized controlled study aimed to assess the usefulness and effectiveness of a barbed suture technique (Stratafix symmetric PDS plus) versus the conventional interrupted knotted suture technique for deep tissue closure in orthopedic surgery by comparing deep fascia suture time, relative cost, and wound-related complications.

Methods: A total of 254 patients with deep surgical incisions who underwent orthopedic surgery between October 1, 2020, and June 30, 2021, were recruited. Their general characteristics (age, sex, weight, height, body mass index, American Society of Anesthesiologists physical status score, total operation time, and length of deep incision) and factors related to deep incision wounds (suture type and number, wound closure time, and operation site outcomes) were collected.

Results: The general characteristics did not differ between the Stratafix and conventional groups. There were no between-group differences observed in total operation time or total anesthesia time. The wound suture times differed significantly. In the conventional group, the suture time per unit length was lower in the group with the length of deep incision under 20 cm but did not differ significantly for each wound size. In the Stratafix group, the suture time per unit length was lower in the group under 15 cm, with the shortest time observed for 10-14.9 cm, followed by 5.0-9.9 cm and the group under 5 cm. The conventional group developed 4 cases of superficial wound infection or surgical wound necrosis. One case of protruded suture tap occurred in the Stratafix group.

Conclusions: The average suture time per unit length increased for lengths under 5 cm as barbed sutures required more time from the start of the first suture to finish of the last suture. There was no significant benefit for very short suture length. One barbed suture material allows a suture of approximately 10-12 cm; sutures beyond that require more time because the surgeon has to start again. The Stratafix group used less suture material than the conventional group.