Proton vs Electron: The Dual Role of Redox-Inactive Metal Ions in Permanganate Oxidation Kinetics

Redox-inactive metal-ion-driven modulation of the oxidation behavior of high-valent metal–oxo complex has garnered significant interest in biological and chemical synthesis; however, their role in permanganate (Mn(VII)) oxidation for the removal of organic pollutants has been largely neglected. Here, we uncover the impact of six metal ions (i.e., Ca²⁺, Mg²⁺, Ni²⁺, Zn²⁺, Al³⁺, and Sc³⁺) presenting in water environments on Mn(VII) activity. These ions uniformly boost the electron and oxygen transfer capabilities of Mn(VII) while impeding proton transfer, as evidenced by electrochemical tests, thioanisole probe analysis, and the kinetic isotope effect. The observed effects are intricately linked to the Lewis acidity of the metal ions. Further mechanistic insights reveal that Mn(VII) can interact with metal ions without direct reduction. Such interactions modify the electronic configuration of Mn(VII) and create an acidic microenvironment, thus increasing its electrophilicity and the energy barrier for the abstraction of proton from organic substrates. More importantly, the efficacy of Mn(VII) in removing phenolic pollutants is regulated by these ions through changing the driving force for proton and electron transfer, i.e., facilitated at pH > 4.5 and inhibited at lower pH. The contribution of active Mn intermediates is also discussed to reveal the oxidative mechanism of the metal ion/Mn(VII) system. These findings not only facilitate the rational design of Mn(VII) oxidation conditions in the presence of metal ions for water decontamination but also offer an alternative paradigm for enhancing electrophilic oxidation.