AlphaFold 3 的诞生:从结构预测到生物大分子全新设计的曙光

Sihui Zhang, Yue Hou, Yongye Huang
{"title":"AlphaFold 3 的诞生:从结构预测到生物大分子全新设计的曙光","authors":"Sihui Zhang,&nbsp;Yue Hou,&nbsp;Yongye Huang","doi":"10.1002/mba2.102","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"<p>Recently, Josh et al. investigate a new structure prediction tool, AlphaFold 3 model, which has successfully predicted the structure and interactions of all living molecules with unprecedented accuracy.<span><sup>1</sup></span> This is a breakthrough in the development of artificial intelligence (AI) tools (Figure 1).</p><p>AlphaFold 3 is able to achieve that scaling up the predictive power of a single deep learning model by an evolution of the AlphaFold 2 Evoformer and Structure Module. This prediction function involves complexes containing a more extensive range of biomolecules, such as proteins, nucleic acids, small molecules, ions, complexes modifying protein residues, and antibody-antigen interactions. It meets the gap of current AI technology for structure and interaction prediction, and its accuracy significantly exceeds that of existing specific interaction types prediction tools.<span><sup>2</sup></span> This proves that high accuracy modelling across biomolecular space is possible, promising to address the core challenge of molecular biology, which is to understand and finally regulate the complex atomic interactions in biological systems.</p><p>AlphaFold 3 introduces Diffusion Model as its core machine learning architecture, a model that has been successful in the field of AI image generation. Compared with the previous version of AlphaFold model, the diffusion model of AlphaFold 3 can directly generate the 3D coordinates of each atom, no longer relying on the structural modules of amino acid framework and side chain dihedral angles. This approach allows the model to be more flexible and intuitive in constructing 3D structures of proteins and their interacting partners. The principle of diffusion model is similar to the process of gradually get rid of the noise. And this model is able to provide confidence scores for its predictions, which helps to improve the predictive accuracy and confidence of the model. The design of the diffusion model considering the calculation efficiency and scalability, making AlphaFold 3 biomolecular systems that can handle the larger and more complex, this is particularly important for drug design and biological engineering, etc.</p><p>We can conclude that the progress of the AlphaFold system: (I) accurate model architecture and more powerful training algorithms, (II) faster and more efficient, and (III) expanded utility and universality.</p><p>AlphaFold 3 is, after all, a prediction tool, and there will still be some model limitations in terms of accuracy. In particular, those proteins with complex structural or dynamic properties may challenge the predictive power of AlphaFold 3. These prediction errors may be manifested in chiral violation rate, the case of atomic collisions, and spurious structural order during the prediction. The prediction results of AlphaFold 3 are highly dependent on the quality and quantity of the training data, which may influence the accuracy of predictions due to limitations or incompleteness of the data set. The prediction results are usually the static structure of the molecule, which makes it impossible to obtain a dynamic process of structural transformation between molecular interactions. Therefore, this may lead to uninterpretable results in AlphaFold 3 prediction, that is, the principle and mechanism behind the prediction result cannot be provided. This may cause errors in the exploration of the interaction of some newly discovered molecules, which is not a negligible existence in determining the experimental direction, and also a problem about applicability and credibility that needs to be solved in the future AlphaFold systems. It is necessary for us to ensure scientific research through both the experiment and calculation method.</p><p>Scientific research on using AlphaFold 3 production needs to be verified by experiments. Designing small molecules/ligands/ions based on targets that are difficult to target in diseases by AlphaFold 3, then researchers can predict their binding efficiency and then perform experimental proof, which may obtain a breakthrough in the treatment of malignant diseases.<span><sup>3</sup></span> It also enables more precise risk assessments and targeted treatment recommendations for disease diagnosis. We look forward to using AlphaFold 3 or an array of tools to predict nucleic acid molecules that are directed to the target. A clip editor for gene editing has been demonstrated in AlphaFold 2 system.<span><sup>4</sup></span> Meanwhile, great mysteries remain about noncoding RNAs. Researchers can also try to input RNA sequence references into AlphaFold 3, to explore the relationship between RNA sequences and secondary/tertiary structures, and even de novo design RNA vaccine sequences and predict efficiency through AI.<span><sup>5</sup></span> This may be a way to save time and effort costs, and to get a reasonable simulation of the conjecture. RNA vaccine design and interaction prediction, including the relationship between sequence position and off-target side effects, to optimize the efficiency of RNA therapies. This may open up some new research directions, such as exploring new associations between protein structure and function and developing new drug/vaccine design strategies.</p><p>Taken together, AlphaFold 3 has more significant advantages over existing AI models in the de novo design area. AlphaFold 3 can more accurately predict the binding mode of antibodies/vaccine to their target proteins and the 3D structure, because they often contain specific proteins or their fragments that can trigger immune responses. Further, it helps scientists to find potential drug targets quickly and design new (unknown structure protein) vaccine, to shorten the drug research and development cycle, reduce costs. They may have better immunogenicity and collaborative drugs to improve treatment effect. During research, AlphaFold 3 could help researchers select or design more stable protein variants, these variations in the process of storage and transportation are less likely to degeneration, in the human body can keep active at the same time, thus improve the overall effect and safety of the functional biomolecules.</p><p>For the following application development of AlphaFold 3, this is an exciting and worth exploring topic. For proteins with known functions, researchers can design and customize protein structures with effective specific function by AlphaFold system. It promotes research in life sciences including protein interaction and cell signaling processes, and also provides novel ideas and targets for disease treatment. The de novo design of peptide/enzyme facilitates researchers to explore the influence of protein sequence differences on amino acid characteristics and protein conformation, and obtain customized peptide/enzyme design or even improve the efficacy of existing drugs. These directions have great potential in the fields of biomedicine and biomaterials.</p><p>AI technological breakthroughs following by AlphaFold 3 may stimulate more research and technological innovation in similar areas, to promote the progress of life science, development science, medicine, drug research and other fields. This will have a profound impact on public health and the pharmaceutical research industry in basic and clinical research, and promote the development of precision medicine. However, for the emergence of new intelligent tools, we still need to maintain a rational attitude, neither deny the progress of science and technology, but also discuss the shortcomings. AlphaFold 3 still has a certain degree of lag, including not dynamic simulation, not completely accurate and comprehensive, and not innovative prediction. It indeed helps us to greatly reduce the trial and error cost during the experiment, which is indeed a non-negligible advantage. We are delighted to accept this state-of-the-art AI tool, AlphaFold 3, and still looking forward to using it to for joint innovation with human intelligence.</p><p>Yue Hou and Yongye Huang provided the conception, funding support, revision and supervision. Sihui Zhang conducted the literature research and wrote the initial manuscript and drew the figure. Sihui Zhang and Yongye Huang are responsible for revision and proofreading of the manuscript. All authors have read and approved to publish the article.</p><p>The authors declare no conflict of interest.</p><p>Not applicable.</p>","PeriodicalId":100901,"journal":{"name":"MedComm – Biomaterials and Applications","volume":"3 4","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2024-09-19","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1002/mba2.102","citationCount":"0","resultStr":"{\"title\":\"Inception of AlphaFold 3: Shining light from structure prediction to de novo design of biomolecules\",\"authors\":\"Sihui Zhang,&nbsp;Yue Hou,&nbsp;Yongye Huang\",\"doi\":\"10.1002/mba2.102\",\"DOIUrl\":null,\"url\":null,\"abstract\":\"<p>Recently, Josh et al. investigate a new structure prediction tool, AlphaFold 3 model, which has successfully predicted the structure and interactions of all living molecules with unprecedented accuracy.<span><sup>1</sup></span> This is a breakthrough in the development of artificial intelligence (AI) tools (Figure 1).</p><p>AlphaFold 3 is able to achieve that scaling up the predictive power of a single deep learning model by an evolution of the AlphaFold 2 Evoformer and Structure Module. This prediction function involves complexes containing a more extensive range of biomolecules, such as proteins, nucleic acids, small molecules, ions, complexes modifying protein residues, and antibody-antigen interactions. It meets the gap of current AI technology for structure and interaction prediction, and its accuracy significantly exceeds that of existing specific interaction types prediction tools.<span><sup>2</sup></span> This proves that high accuracy modelling across biomolecular space is possible, promising to address the core challenge of molecular biology, which is to understand and finally regulate the complex atomic interactions in biological systems.</p><p>AlphaFold 3 introduces Diffusion Model as its core machine learning architecture, a model that has been successful in the field of AI image generation. Compared with the previous version of AlphaFold model, the diffusion model of AlphaFold 3 can directly generate the 3D coordinates of each atom, no longer relying on the structural modules of amino acid framework and side chain dihedral angles. This approach allows the model to be more flexible and intuitive in constructing 3D structures of proteins and their interacting partners. The principle of diffusion model is similar to the process of gradually get rid of the noise. And this model is able to provide confidence scores for its predictions, which helps to improve the predictive accuracy and confidence of the model. The design of the diffusion model considering the calculation efficiency and scalability, making AlphaFold 3 biomolecular systems that can handle the larger and more complex, this is particularly important for drug design and biological engineering, etc.</p><p>We can conclude that the progress of the AlphaFold system: (I) accurate model architecture and more powerful training algorithms, (II) faster and more efficient, and (III) expanded utility and universality.</p><p>AlphaFold 3 is, after all, a prediction tool, and there will still be some model limitations in terms of accuracy. In particular, those proteins with complex structural or dynamic properties may challenge the predictive power of AlphaFold 3. These prediction errors may be manifested in chiral violation rate, the case of atomic collisions, and spurious structural order during the prediction. The prediction results of AlphaFold 3 are highly dependent on the quality and quantity of the training data, which may influence the accuracy of predictions due to limitations or incompleteness of the data set. The prediction results are usually the static structure of the molecule, which makes it impossible to obtain a dynamic process of structural transformation between molecular interactions. Therefore, this may lead to uninterpretable results in AlphaFold 3 prediction, that is, the principle and mechanism behind the prediction result cannot be provided. This may cause errors in the exploration of the interaction of some newly discovered molecules, which is not a negligible existence in determining the experimental direction, and also a problem about applicability and credibility that needs to be solved in the future AlphaFold systems. It is necessary for us to ensure scientific research through both the experiment and calculation method.</p><p>Scientific research on using AlphaFold 3 production needs to be verified by experiments. Designing small molecules/ligands/ions based on targets that are difficult to target in diseases by AlphaFold 3, then researchers can predict their binding efficiency and then perform experimental proof, which may obtain a breakthrough in the treatment of malignant diseases.<span><sup>3</sup></span> It also enables more precise risk assessments and targeted treatment recommendations for disease diagnosis. We look forward to using AlphaFold 3 or an array of tools to predict nucleic acid molecules that are directed to the target. A clip editor for gene editing has been demonstrated in AlphaFold 2 system.<span><sup>4</sup></span> Meanwhile, great mysteries remain about noncoding RNAs. Researchers can also try to input RNA sequence references into AlphaFold 3, to explore the relationship between RNA sequences and secondary/tertiary structures, and even de novo design RNA vaccine sequences and predict efficiency through AI.<span><sup>5</sup></span> This may be a way to save time and effort costs, and to get a reasonable simulation of the conjecture. RNA vaccine design and interaction prediction, including the relationship between sequence position and off-target side effects, to optimize the efficiency of RNA therapies. This may open up some new research directions, such as exploring new associations between protein structure and function and developing new drug/vaccine design strategies.</p><p>Taken together, AlphaFold 3 has more significant advantages over existing AI models in the de novo design area. AlphaFold 3 can more accurately predict the binding mode of antibodies/vaccine to their target proteins and the 3D structure, because they often contain specific proteins or their fragments that can trigger immune responses. Further, it helps scientists to find potential drug targets quickly and design new (unknown structure protein) vaccine, to shorten the drug research and development cycle, reduce costs. They may have better immunogenicity and collaborative drugs to improve treatment effect. During research, AlphaFold 3 could help researchers select or design more stable protein variants, these variations in the process of storage and transportation are less likely to degeneration, in the human body can keep active at the same time, thus improve the overall effect and safety of the functional biomolecules.</p><p>For the following application development of AlphaFold 3, this is an exciting and worth exploring topic. For proteins with known functions, researchers can design and customize protein structures with effective specific function by AlphaFold system. It promotes research in life sciences including protein interaction and cell signaling processes, and also provides novel ideas and targets for disease treatment. The de novo design of peptide/enzyme facilitates researchers to explore the influence of protein sequence differences on amino acid characteristics and protein conformation, and obtain customized peptide/enzyme design or even improve the efficacy of existing drugs. These directions have great potential in the fields of biomedicine and biomaterials.</p><p>AI technological breakthroughs following by AlphaFold 3 may stimulate more research and technological innovation in similar areas, to promote the progress of life science, development science, medicine, drug research and other fields. This will have a profound impact on public health and the pharmaceutical research industry in basic and clinical research, and promote the development of precision medicine. However, for the emergence of new intelligent tools, we still need to maintain a rational attitude, neither deny the progress of science and technology, but also discuss the shortcomings. AlphaFold 3 still has a certain degree of lag, including not dynamic simulation, not completely accurate and comprehensive, and not innovative prediction. It indeed helps us to greatly reduce the trial and error cost during the experiment, which is indeed a non-negligible advantage. We are delighted to accept this state-of-the-art AI tool, AlphaFold 3, and still looking forward to using it to for joint innovation with human intelligence.</p><p>Yue Hou and Yongye Huang provided the conception, funding support, revision and supervision. Sihui Zhang conducted the literature research and wrote the initial manuscript and drew the figure. Sihui Zhang and Yongye Huang are responsible for revision and proofreading of the manuscript. All authors have read and approved to publish the article.</p><p>The authors declare no conflict of interest.</p><p>Not applicable.</p>\",\"PeriodicalId\":100901,\"journal\":{\"name\":\"MedComm – Biomaterials and Applications\",\"volume\":\"3 4\",\"pages\":\"\"},\"PeriodicalIF\":0.0000,\"publicationDate\":\"2024-09-19\",\"publicationTypes\":\"Journal Article\",\"fieldsOfStudy\":null,\"isOpenAccess\":false,\"openAccessPdf\":\"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1002/mba2.102\",\"citationCount\":\"0\",\"resultStr\":null,\"platform\":\"Semanticscholar\",\"paperid\":null,\"PeriodicalName\":\"MedComm – Biomaterials and Applications\",\"FirstCategoryId\":\"1085\",\"ListUrlMain\":\"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/mba2.102\",\"RegionNum\":0,\"RegionCategory\":null,\"ArticlePicture\":[],\"TitleCN\":null,\"AbstractTextCN\":null,\"PMCID\":null,\"EPubDate\":\"\",\"PubModel\":\"\",\"JCR\":\"\",\"JCRName\":\"\",\"Score\":null,\"Total\":0}","platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"MedComm – Biomaterials and Applications","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/mba2.102","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0

摘要

最近,Josh等人研究了一种新的结构预测工具--AlphaFold 3模型,它以前所未有的准确度成功预测了所有生命分子的结构和相互作用1,这是人工智能(AI)工具发展的一个突破(图1)。AlphaFold 3通过对AlphaFold 2 Evoformer和结构模块的进化,实现了对单一深度学习模型预测能力的扩展。该预测功能涉及包含更多生物大分子的复合物,如蛋白质、核酸、小分子、离子、修饰蛋白质残基的复合物以及抗体-抗原相互作用。AlphaFold 3 引入了扩散模型(Diffusion Model)作为其核心机器学习架构,该模型已在人工智能图像生成领域取得成功。与前一版本的 AlphaFold 模型相比,AlphaFold 3 的扩散模型可以直接生成每个原子的三维坐标,不再依赖氨基酸框架和侧链二面角等结构模块。这种方法使得该模型在构建蛋白质及其相互作用伙伴的三维结构时更加灵活和直观。扩散模型的原理类似于逐渐去除噪音的过程。而且该模型能够为其预测提供置信度分数,有助于提高模型的预测准确性和置信度。考虑到计算效率和可扩展性的扩散模型设计,使得 AlphaFold 3 能够处理更大、更复杂的生物分子系统,这对于药物设计和生物工程等方面尤为重要。我们可以总结出 AlphaFold 系统的进步:(一)精确的模型架构和更强大的训练算法;(二)更快更高效;(三)实用性和普适性得到了扩展。AlphaFold 3 毕竟是一个预测工具,在准确性方面仍会存在一些模型局限性。AlphaFold 3 毕竟是一种预测工具,在准确性方面仍会存在一些模型限制,尤其是那些结构或动态特性复杂的蛋白质,可能会对 AlphaFold 3 的预测能力提出挑战。这些预测误差可能表现在手性违反率、原子碰撞情况以及预测过程中的虚假结构顺序等方面。AlphaFold 3 的预测结果高度依赖于训练数据的质量和数量,由于数据集的局限性或不完整性,可能会影响预测的准确性。预测结果通常是分子的静态结构,无法获得分子间相互作用的动态结构转变过程。因此,这可能导致 AlphaFold 3 预测结果无法解读,即无法提供预测结果背后的原理和机制。这可能会对一些新发现分子的相互作用探索造成误差,这在确定实验方向上是不可忽视的存在,也是未来 AlphaFold 系统需要解决的适用性和可信度问题。使用 AlphaFold 3 生产的科学研究需要通过实验来验证。利用 AlphaFold 3 根据疾病中难以靶向的靶点设计小分子/配体/离子,然后研究人员可以预测其结合效率,再进行实验证明,这可能会在恶性疾病的治疗上获得突破3 ,也能为疾病诊断提供更精确的风险评估和有针对性的治疗建议。我们期待着使用 AlphaFold 3 或一系列工具来预测指向靶点的核酸分子。AlphaFold 2 系统已经展示了用于基因编辑的剪辑编辑器。研究人员还可以尝试将 RNA 序列参考文献输入 AlphaFold 3,探索 RNA 序列与二级/三级结构之间的关系,甚至通过人工智能从头设计 RNA 疫苗序列并预测其效率。RNA 疫苗设计与相互作用预测,包括序列位置与脱靶副作用之间的关系,以优化 RNA 疗法的效率。
本文章由计算机程序翻译,如有差异,请以英文原文为准。

Inception of AlphaFold 3: Shining light from structure prediction to de novo design of biomolecules

Inception of AlphaFold 3: Shining light from structure prediction to de novo design of biomolecules

Recently, Josh et al. investigate a new structure prediction tool, AlphaFold 3 model, which has successfully predicted the structure and interactions of all living molecules with unprecedented accuracy.1 This is a breakthrough in the development of artificial intelligence (AI) tools (Figure 1).

AlphaFold 3 is able to achieve that scaling up the predictive power of a single deep learning model by an evolution of the AlphaFold 2 Evoformer and Structure Module. This prediction function involves complexes containing a more extensive range of biomolecules, such as proteins, nucleic acids, small molecules, ions, complexes modifying protein residues, and antibody-antigen interactions. It meets the gap of current AI technology for structure and interaction prediction, and its accuracy significantly exceeds that of existing specific interaction types prediction tools.2 This proves that high accuracy modelling across biomolecular space is possible, promising to address the core challenge of molecular biology, which is to understand and finally regulate the complex atomic interactions in biological systems.

AlphaFold 3 introduces Diffusion Model as its core machine learning architecture, a model that has been successful in the field of AI image generation. Compared with the previous version of AlphaFold model, the diffusion model of AlphaFold 3 can directly generate the 3D coordinates of each atom, no longer relying on the structural modules of amino acid framework and side chain dihedral angles. This approach allows the model to be more flexible and intuitive in constructing 3D structures of proteins and their interacting partners. The principle of diffusion model is similar to the process of gradually get rid of the noise. And this model is able to provide confidence scores for its predictions, which helps to improve the predictive accuracy and confidence of the model. The design of the diffusion model considering the calculation efficiency and scalability, making AlphaFold 3 biomolecular systems that can handle the larger and more complex, this is particularly important for drug design and biological engineering, etc.

We can conclude that the progress of the AlphaFold system: (I) accurate model architecture and more powerful training algorithms, (II) faster and more efficient, and (III) expanded utility and universality.

AlphaFold 3 is, after all, a prediction tool, and there will still be some model limitations in terms of accuracy. In particular, those proteins with complex structural or dynamic properties may challenge the predictive power of AlphaFold 3. These prediction errors may be manifested in chiral violation rate, the case of atomic collisions, and spurious structural order during the prediction. The prediction results of AlphaFold 3 are highly dependent on the quality and quantity of the training data, which may influence the accuracy of predictions due to limitations or incompleteness of the data set. The prediction results are usually the static structure of the molecule, which makes it impossible to obtain a dynamic process of structural transformation between molecular interactions. Therefore, this may lead to uninterpretable results in AlphaFold 3 prediction, that is, the principle and mechanism behind the prediction result cannot be provided. This may cause errors in the exploration of the interaction of some newly discovered molecules, which is not a negligible existence in determining the experimental direction, and also a problem about applicability and credibility that needs to be solved in the future AlphaFold systems. It is necessary for us to ensure scientific research through both the experiment and calculation method.

Scientific research on using AlphaFold 3 production needs to be verified by experiments. Designing small molecules/ligands/ions based on targets that are difficult to target in diseases by AlphaFold 3, then researchers can predict their binding efficiency and then perform experimental proof, which may obtain a breakthrough in the treatment of malignant diseases.3 It also enables more precise risk assessments and targeted treatment recommendations for disease diagnosis. We look forward to using AlphaFold 3 or an array of tools to predict nucleic acid molecules that are directed to the target. A clip editor for gene editing has been demonstrated in AlphaFold 2 system.4 Meanwhile, great mysteries remain about noncoding RNAs. Researchers can also try to input RNA sequence references into AlphaFold 3, to explore the relationship between RNA sequences and secondary/tertiary structures, and even de novo design RNA vaccine sequences and predict efficiency through AI.5 This may be a way to save time and effort costs, and to get a reasonable simulation of the conjecture. RNA vaccine design and interaction prediction, including the relationship between sequence position and off-target side effects, to optimize the efficiency of RNA therapies. This may open up some new research directions, such as exploring new associations between protein structure and function and developing new drug/vaccine design strategies.

Taken together, AlphaFold 3 has more significant advantages over existing AI models in the de novo design area. AlphaFold 3 can more accurately predict the binding mode of antibodies/vaccine to their target proteins and the 3D structure, because they often contain specific proteins or their fragments that can trigger immune responses. Further, it helps scientists to find potential drug targets quickly and design new (unknown structure protein) vaccine, to shorten the drug research and development cycle, reduce costs. They may have better immunogenicity and collaborative drugs to improve treatment effect. During research, AlphaFold 3 could help researchers select or design more stable protein variants, these variations in the process of storage and transportation are less likely to degeneration, in the human body can keep active at the same time, thus improve the overall effect and safety of the functional biomolecules.

For the following application development of AlphaFold 3, this is an exciting and worth exploring topic. For proteins with known functions, researchers can design and customize protein structures with effective specific function by AlphaFold system. It promotes research in life sciences including protein interaction and cell signaling processes, and also provides novel ideas and targets for disease treatment. The de novo design of peptide/enzyme facilitates researchers to explore the influence of protein sequence differences on amino acid characteristics and protein conformation, and obtain customized peptide/enzyme design or even improve the efficacy of existing drugs. These directions have great potential in the fields of biomedicine and biomaterials.

AI technological breakthroughs following by AlphaFold 3 may stimulate more research and technological innovation in similar areas, to promote the progress of life science, development science, medicine, drug research and other fields. This will have a profound impact on public health and the pharmaceutical research industry in basic and clinical research, and promote the development of precision medicine. However, for the emergence of new intelligent tools, we still need to maintain a rational attitude, neither deny the progress of science and technology, but also discuss the shortcomings. AlphaFold 3 still has a certain degree of lag, including not dynamic simulation, not completely accurate and comprehensive, and not innovative prediction. It indeed helps us to greatly reduce the trial and error cost during the experiment, which is indeed a non-negligible advantage. We are delighted to accept this state-of-the-art AI tool, AlphaFold 3, and still looking forward to using it to for joint innovation with human intelligence.

Yue Hou and Yongye Huang provided the conception, funding support, revision and supervision. Sihui Zhang conducted the literature research and wrote the initial manuscript and drew the figure. Sihui Zhang and Yongye Huang are responsible for revision and proofreading of the manuscript. All authors have read and approved to publish the article.

The authors declare no conflict of interest.

Not applicable.

求助全文
通过发布文献求助,成功后即可免费获取论文全文。 去求助
来源期刊
CiteScore
1.10
自引率
0.00%
发文量
0
×
引用
GB/T 7714-2015
复制
MLA
复制
APA
复制
导出至
BibTeX EndNote RefMan NoteFirst NoteExpress
×
提示
您的信息不完整,为了账户安全,请先补充。
现在去补充
×
提示
您因"违规操作"
具体请查看互助需知
我知道了
×
提示
确定
请完成安全验证×
copy
已复制链接
快去分享给好友吧!
我知道了
右上角分享
点击右上角分享
0
联系我们:info@booksci.cn Book学术提供免费学术资源搜索服务,方便国内外学者检索中英文文献。致力于提供最便捷和优质的服务体验。 Copyright © 2023 布克学术 All rights reserved.
京ICP备2023020795号-1
ghs 京公网安备 11010802042870号
Book学术文献互助
Book学术文献互助群
群 号:481959085
Book学术官方微信