Benchtop Flow Stasis Quantification: In Vitro Methods and In Vivo Possibilities

Purpose

Neo-sinus flow stasis has ben correlated with transcatheter heart valve (THV) thrombosis severity and occurrence. Standard benchtop flow field quantification techniques require optical access or modified prosthesis models that may not reflect the true nature of the original valve. En face and fluoroscopic videodensitometry enable visualization of washout in regions otherwise unviewable.

Methods

This study compares two in vitro methods of assessing flow stasis in scenarios with insufficient optical access for traditional techniques such as particle image velocimetry (PIV). A series of seven paired experiments were conducted using a previously described laser-enhanced video densitometry (LEVD) and fluoroscopic video densitometry (FVD). Both sets of experiments were analyzed to calculate washout time as a measure of flow stasis. A novel flow stasis measure termed contrast attenuation ratio (CAR) is proposed as a viable single measure of flow stasis obtainable from only a small number of cardiac cycles of in vitro or in vivo fluoroscopic data. Retrospective fluoroscopic datasets (n = 72) were analyzed to assess the feasibility of obtaining this metric from routine clinical practice and its ability to stratify results.

Results

Neo-sinus flow stasis calculated from in vitro fluoroscopy was well correlated with LEVD (r² = 0.77, p = 0.009). The newly proposed CAR metric showed good agreement with the commonly used “washout time” measure of flow stasis (r² = 0.91, p < 0.001) while allowing for assessment with incomplete or truncated data. As a proof of concept, CAR was measured in 72 consecutive retrospective fluoroscopic datasets. CAR averaged 10.6 ± 4.6% with a range of 1.5–20.3% in these patients.

Conclusions

This study demonstrates two in vitro methods that can be used to assess relative flow stasis in otherwise optically inaccessible regions surrounding cardiac or vascular implants. In addition, the fluoroscopic benchtop technique was used to validate a metric that allows for extension to routine clinical fluoroscopy. This contrast attenuation ratio (CAR) metric was found to be both accurate and clinically obtainable, and potentially offers a new method for valve thrombosis risk stratification.