On the absence of a secondary vortex street in three-dimensional and turbulent cylinder wakes

Bluff-body wakes generally become three-dimensional (3-D) and then turbulent when the Reynolds number exceeds a few hundred. Other than an alternate shedding of the spanwise vortices behind the body and a gradual decay and annihilation of the vortices with distance downstream, whether a secondary vortex street would develop in the relatively far wake has been a long-standing argument in the literature. This argument is addressed in the present study. Specifically, direct numerical simulations and transient growth analysis are performed to examine the two-dimensional and 3-D wakes of different bluff bodies, including circular cylinder, square cylinder, diamond cylinder and rectangular cylinders with different cross-sectional aspect ratios. We found that a secondary vortex street is absent for most 3-D and turbulent wakes. The root cause is the weakening of spanwise vortices by 3-D wake instability modes and streamwise circulation/vorticity. The weakened spanwise vortices induce reduced mean shear in the intermediate wake, which then induces much smaller perturbation energy growth that is below the threshold for the emergence of a secondary vortex street. This finding suggests that the 3-D and turbulence characteristics, and the momentum, mass and heat transport in the relatively far wake of bluff bodies, would not be influenced by extra anisotropy or inhomogeneity caused by a secondary vortex street.