Comparison of next generation sequencing (NGS) - (SNPs) and capillary electrophoresis (CE) - (STRs) in the genetic analysis of human remains

A pilot study was performed using two different DNA technology platforms conducted by two laboratories to analyze DNA extracted from 83-year-old, human male skeletal remains from 16 individuals, of which there are no other viable means to identify these war victims. The workflow of the more recent developed ForenSeq Kintelligence Kit and next generation sequencing was compared to that of the standard capillary electrophoresis – short tandem repeat (STR) method (Power Plex ESX17 and Y23 Systems). The findings indicate that greater amount of useful genetic data can be gained with the Kintelligence system across the range of samples under study and particularly for samples in which partial or no STR profiles are obtained. SNP data are more likely to be obtained from degraded samples, like the ones analyzed in this study. Moreover, high volume SNP data are suitable for long distance kinship associations and genetic genealogy databases to develop more investigative leads for future kinship and missing persons cases, a process not feasible by STR typing.