Individual and social heterosis act independently in honey bee (Apis mellifera) colonies.

Heterosis occurs in individuals when genetic diversity, i.e., heterozygosity, increases fitness. Many advanced eusocial insects evolved mating behaviors, including polyandry and polygyny, which increase inter-individual genetic diversity within colonies. The possibility of this structure of diversity to improve group fitness has been termed social heterosis. Neither the independence of individual and social heterosis nor their relative effect sizes have been explicitly measured. Through controlled breeding between pairs of Western honey bee queens (Apis mellifera L.; n=3 pairs) from two distinct populations, we created inbred colonies with low genetic diversity, hybrid colonies with high heterozygosity, and mixed colonies (combining inbred workers from each population) with low heterozygosity and high social diversity. We then quantified two independent traits in colonies: survival against bacterial challenge and maintenance of brood nest temperature. For both traits, we found hybrid and mixed colonies outperformed inbred colonies but did not perform differently from each other. During immune challenge assays, hybrid and mixed colonies experienced hazard ratios of 0.49 (95% CI [0.37, 0.65]) and 0.69 (95% CI [0.50, 0.96]) compared to inbred colonies. For nest temperatures, hybrid and mixed colonies experienced 1.94±0.97°C and 2.82±2.46°C less thermal error and 0.14±0.11°C2 and 0.16±0.06°C2 less thermal variance per hour than inbred lines. This suggests social and individual heterosis operate independently and may have similar effect sizes. These results highlight the importance of both inter- and intra-individual diversity to fitness, which may help explain the emergence of polyandry/polygyny in eusocial insects and inform breeding efforts in these systems.