Conserved exopodite morphology in three-dimensionally preserved trilobites from the Walcott-Rust Quarry (Mohawkian, Ordovician) of New York, USA

Trilobites were extremely abundant and diverse euarthropods from the Paleozoic Era, but our understanding of their non-biomineralized ventral morphology is restricted to localities with exceptional fossil preservation. The Ordovician-aged Walcott-Rust Quarry in New York State preserves exceptional trilobite fossils as calcite casts in three-dimensions with little to no deformation, providing a valuable view of their ventral morphology. Appendages of the two most abundant trilobites, Ceraurus pleurexanthemus and Flexicalymene senaria, have been known for over 150 years but the original preparation of the specimens as thin sections has led to significant disagreement about their anatomy. Ceraruus pleurexanthemus is more abundant in the thin section collections (157 specimens) and features nearly complete appendages including a subtriangular protopodite with stud-like gnathobases along the medial edge and long endites ventrally. The exopodite consists of a long proximal article bearing dumbbell-shaped lamellae (in cross section) and a shorter distal article, closely resembling that of the cheirurid Anacheirurus adserai from the Lower Ordovician Fezouata Shale biota of Morocco. The appendages of F. senaria (37 specimens) are less well preserved. The exopodite bears up to 40 dumbbell shaped lamellae (in cross section) and is proportionally longer relative to the endopodite of C. pleurexanthemus. The close morphological similarity observed between the exopodites of C. pleurexanthemus and A. adersai, despite originating from paleogeographically distant latitudes and temporally separated by over ca. 20 million years, shows that the proposed “Cambrian type” exopodite persisted through the majority of the Ordovician. The morphology of the endopodites between C. pleurexanthemus and A. adersai is more variable when compared to the organization of the exopodites, may reflect selective pressures from locomotion and feeding between these species.