Varying Properties of Extracellular Matrix Grafts Impact Their Durability and Cell Attachment and Proliferation in an In Vitro Chronic Wound Model

While acute wounds typically progress through the phases of wound healing, chronic wounds often stall in the inflammatory phase due to elevated levels of matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs) and proinflammatory cytokines. Dysregulated expression of MMPs can result in the breakdown of extracellular matrix (ECM) formed during the wound healing process, resulting in stalled wounds. Native collagen-based wound dressings offer a potential wound management option to sequester excess MMPs and support cellular interactions that allow wound progression through the natural healing process. Herein, we utilized commercially available ECM matrices, two derived from porcine small intestinal submucosa (PCMP, 2 layers; PCMP-XT, 5 layers) and one derived from propria submucosa (ovine forestomach matrix, OFM, 1 layer), to demonstrate the impact of processing methodologies (e.g., layering and crosslinking) on functional characteristics needed for the management of chronic wounds. Grafts were evaluated for structural composition using scanning electron microscopy and histology, ability to reduce MMPs using fluorometric assays, and durability in an in vitro degradation chronic wound model. Both intact (nondegraded) and partially degraded grafts were assessed for their ability to serve as a functional cell scaffold using primary human fibroblasts. Grafts differed in matrix substructure and composition. While all grafts demonstrated attenuation of MMP activity, PCMP and PCMP-XT showed larger reductions of MMP levels. OFM rapidly degraded in the in vitro degradation model (<3 hours), while PCMP and PCMP-XT were significantly more durable (>7 days). The ability of PCMP and PCMP-XT to serve as scaffolds for cellular attachment was not impacted by degradation in vitro. Three ECM grafts with varying structural and functional characteristics exhibited differential durability when degraded in a simulated chronic wound model. Those that withstood rapid degradation maintained their ability to function as a scaffold to support attachment and proliferation of fibroblasts, a cell type important for wound healing.