Evaluating the sensitivity of EQ-5D-5L in patients with brain metastases: a secondary analysis of NRG CC001

BACKGROUND EuroQoL EQ-5D is a commonly used measure of health-related quality of life (HRQOL) in clinical trials given the use of its index score as a measure of health utilities. It is unclear whether EQ-5D is sensitive to changes in neurocognitive function and progression that occur following brain radiation. This study sought to evaluate the sensitivity of EQ-5D-5L in reflecting these changes. PATIENTS and METHODS A secondary analysis of NRG Oncology CC001 was performed. Mean EQ-5D-5L index and visual analog scale (VAS) score changes from baseline between groups of patients stratified by neurocognitive function and intracranial progression status were assessed. MD Anderson Symptom Inventory for brain tumor (MDASI-BT) symptom and interference items were also analyzed between groups. RESULTS EQ-5D-5L index and VAS score changes between patients who had cognitive failure and those that had preserved cognition showed no significant differences at any time point. In contrast, VAS changes at 4 (1.61 vs -5.13, P = .05) and 6 months (8.17 vs -0.14, P = .04) were significantly improved in the patients who survived without intracranial progression. MDASI-BT cognitive factor scores were significantly improved in the cohort of patients with preserved neurocognitive function at 2 (1.68 vs 2.08, P = .05) and 4 months (1.35 vs 1.83, P = .04). MDASI-BT symptom interference was significantly associated with intracranial progression at 4 months, but not with neurocognitive status. CONCLUSION EQ-5D-5L index and VAS scores were not sensitive to neurocognitive changes that patients experienced, but VAS scores were sensitive to progression. This study challenges the routine use of EQ-5D as a QoL metric in brain metastases clinical trials that are focused on preventing neurocognitive dysfunction. Trial Registration NCT# 02360215