培养医学生对放射学和核医学的兴趣

iRadiology Pub Date : 2023-11-30 DOI:10.1002/ird3.45
Arosh S. Perera Molligoda Arachchige, Francesca Romana Centini, Niccolò Stomeo
{"title":"培养医学生对放射学和核医学的兴趣","authors":"Arosh S. Perera Molligoda Arachchige,&nbsp;Francesca Romana Centini,&nbsp;Niccolò Stomeo","doi":"10.1002/ird3.45","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"<p>In today's rapidly evolving medical landscape, the fields of radiology and nuclear medicine occupy a distinct and indispensable position. These disciplines serve as vanguards of modern healthcare, providing essential tools for disease diagnosis, treatment planning, and cutting-edge research. However, like any medical specialty, the sustained development of these fields relies on cultivating and nurturing the interest of medical students. Ensuring a steady supply of skilled professionals in radiology and nuclear medicine is paramount to meeting the burgeoning demand in these domains. We would like to delve into the profound significance of radiology and nuclear medicine and into the challenges encountered in attracting medical students and present a comprehensive array of strategies designed to effectively ignite their interest.</p><p>Radiology and nuclear medicine have carved out pivotal roles in the realm of modern medicine. Radiology, encompassing modalities such as X-rays, CT scans, MRI, and ultrasound, offers noninvasive imaging techniques that facilitate precise and accurate disease diagnosis. In parallel, nuclear medicine harnesses radioactive tracers to visualize physiological processes, greatly aiding in diagnosing complex ailments like cancer, heart disease, and neurological disorders. These specialties not only excel in diagnosis but also substantially contribute to treatment guidance. Radiological interventions, including image-guided biopsies and minimally invasive procedures, have revolutionized patient care. Similarly, nuclear medicine showcases its therapeutic potential, as seen in treatments like radioactive iodine therapy for thyroid disorders [<span>1</span>].</p><p>Furthermore, radiology and nuclear medicine have become the cornerstone of medical research, propelling innovations in imaging technology and therapeutic modalities. Researchers utilize these disciplines to explore the intricacies of diseases and develop groundbreaking treatments such as the novel [177Lu] Lu-PSMA-617 radioligand therapy for metastatic castration resistant prostate cancer [<span>2</span>]. On a broader scale, the two disciplines play indispensable roles in global health initiatives. They assist in detecting and combating diseases in resource-constrained regions, with mobile X-ray units and portable nuclear medicine devices proving instrumental in disease surveillance and treatment.</p><p>However, despite their irrefutable importance, radiology and nuclear medicine face a series of challenges in attracting medical students. From a personal perspective, there are only about 3–5 in 150 students that say would consider a career in radiology or nuclear medicine. Often, radiology and nuclear medicine occupy the periphery of medical education, with limited exposure during the formative years of medical training. According to the “Your Training Counts” report by the Medical Council of Ireland in 2015, just 53% of first-year postgraduate residents felt adequately prepared by their prior medical education for their roles as residents. Additionally, 64% of these residents considered the lack of preparedness to be a significant or moderately sized issue [<span>3</span>]. Many students only encounter these fields during their clinical rotations done usually in departments other than radiology or nuclear medicine since in Italy these specialties are counted as service sector departments and do not count for the compulsory 300 h of internship (“tirocinio abilitante” in Italian), leaving them unaware of the full spectrum of possibilities. Widespread misconceptions about radiology, such as concerns about automation impacting job prospects (aggravated by the lack of awareness regarding artificial intelligence [AI]) or the perceived lack of patient interaction, can dissuade students from considering these specialties. Dispelling these myths is critical [<span>4, 5</span>]. Residencies in radiology and nuclear medicine tend to be highly competitive in certain countries like the USA, which can be intimidating for aspiring students [<span>6</span>]. The fierce competition may discourage some from pursuing these fields. The rapid advancement of technology within radiology and nuclear medicine can appear daunting to students. The perception of a steep learning curve can act as a deterrent. Thus, it is necessary to introduce a foundation of knowledge regarding AI into medical student curricula. The conversations regarding these themes need to move from the expert to the student, apart from the expert to the expert. Finally, in certain regions, shortages of radiologists and nuclear medicine physicians have led to heavy workloads and concerns about work–life balance, creating apprehension among potential candidates [<span>7</span>]. These regional disparities are further influenced by the income, the length of specialty training, and the number of training posts available in each country (Table 1).</p><p>To effectively harness the interest of medical students in radiology and nuclear medicine, a multifaceted approach is essential. Initiating exposure to radiology and nuclear medicine concepts within the preclinical curriculum is foundational. Lectures, case-based learning, and hands-on workshops can provide students with an early understanding of the relevance and possibilities in these fields. Similarly, establishing mentorship programs connecting medical students with experienced radiologists and nuclear medicine specialists is invaluable. A study conducted at Newcastle University (UK) clearly demonstrates that medical students have a strong preference for interactive case-based discussions as their primary mode of learning, as opposed to other methods such as traditional topic presentations or exam-style questioning [<span>10</span>]. This preference is supported by findings from other authors as well. Zou et al. discovered that a significant majority of students favored teaching through interactive dialogs, particularly in small group settings where students actively participate in answering questions [<span>11</span>]. Furthermore, in 1993, the American College of Radiology (ACR) introduced the ACR Appropriateness Criteria. This resource has been regularly updated and serves as a valuable online tool for both physicians and medical students. It aids in the identification of appropriate imaging requirements by providing evidence-based, peer-reviewed guidelines that encompass diagnostic imaging selection, radiotherapy protocols, and image-guided interventional procedures [<span>12</span>]. Indeed, joining radiological societies such as the ACR or Royal College of Radiologists have proved invaluable as they offer a vast exposure to radiology-related content, symposia, courses, etc. Additionally, personalized guidance can debunk misconceptions, provide career advice, and foster a sense of belonging within these specialties.</p><p>In addition, offering comprehensive and engaging clinical rotations in radiology and nuclear medicine during the clinical years is pivotal. Encouraging active participation enables students to witness firsthand the real-world impact of these specialties. Promoting research opportunities within radiology and nuclear medicine deepens students' understanding and appreciation. Medical students could interact with radiology research published in several journals through letters to the editors, commentaries, etc., and this should be encouraged by experts in the field by giving them the necessary guidance or supervision [<span>13</span>]. Engaging in research projects opens doors to academic careers and underscores the importance of these fields.</p><p>Moreover, developing interactive learning tools, such as virtual radiology labs and online platforms simulating real-world scenarios, can enhance students' confidence in interpreting imaging studies and make learning more engaging. Also, establishing a diverse and inclusive environment within radiology and nuclear medicine departments is essential. A diverse workforce serves as an inspiration to students from underrepresented backgrounds. Providing accurate information about job market conditions, including demand and opportunities for subspecialization, helps allay concerns and showcase the potential for fulfilling careers in these fields. Offering ongoing educational opportunities to medical students and residents ensures they stay abreast of the latest advancements in imaging technology and clinical practice.</p><p>Advocating for the significance of radiology and nuclear medicine in healthcare and society is imperative. Raising awareness about their contributions to patient care and research can generate greater interest among students and change how the specialty is viewed in the eyes of the general public. Collaborating closely with medical schools to align curricula with the evolving needs of healthcare is vital. Dialog and adaptation of educational approaches are necessary to cater to the interests and aspirations of students.</p><p>In conclusion, radiology and nuclear medicine represent essential pillars of modern healthcare. Nurturing the interest of medical students in these fields is critical for the continued advancement of diagnostic excellence. Addressing challenges, providing early exposure, fostering mentorship, promoting research and diversity, dispelling misconceptions, and advocating for these fields all contribute to ensuring a continuous influx of passionate and skilled professionals. Together, we can empower the next generation of radiologists and nuclear medicine specialists who will push the boundaries of medical imaging and enhance patient care worldwide.</p><p>Arosh S. Perera Molligoda Arachchige analyzed the data and prepared the first draft of the manuscript, participated in the conception, and design of the study; Francesca Romana Centini constructively revised the manuscript; Arosh S. Perera Molligoda Arachchige and Francesca Romana Centini participated in data collection and organization; Niccolò Stomeo participated in and supervised the study throughout, and they share corresponding authorship. All authors commented on previous versions of the manuscript and approved the final version.</p><p>The authors declare no conflict of interest.</p><p>Not applicable.</p><p>Not applicable.</p>","PeriodicalId":73508,"journal":{"name":"iRadiology","volume":"1 4","pages":"381-384"},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2023-11-30","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1002/ird3.45","citationCount":"0","resultStr":"{\"title\":\"Fostering medical student interest in radiology and nuclear medicine\",\"authors\":\"Arosh S. Perera Molligoda Arachchige,&nbsp;Francesca Romana Centini,&nbsp;Niccolò Stomeo\",\"doi\":\"10.1002/ird3.45\",\"DOIUrl\":null,\"url\":null,\"abstract\":\"<p>In today's rapidly evolving medical landscape, the fields of radiology and nuclear medicine occupy a distinct and indispensable position. These disciplines serve as vanguards of modern healthcare, providing essential tools for disease diagnosis, treatment planning, and cutting-edge research. However, like any medical specialty, the sustained development of these fields relies on cultivating and nurturing the interest of medical students. Ensuring a steady supply of skilled professionals in radiology and nuclear medicine is paramount to meeting the burgeoning demand in these domains. We would like to delve into the profound significance of radiology and nuclear medicine and into the challenges encountered in attracting medical students and present a comprehensive array of strategies designed to effectively ignite their interest.</p><p>Radiology and nuclear medicine have carved out pivotal roles in the realm of modern medicine. Radiology, encompassing modalities such as X-rays, CT scans, MRI, and ultrasound, offers noninvasive imaging techniques that facilitate precise and accurate disease diagnosis. In parallel, nuclear medicine harnesses radioactive tracers to visualize physiological processes, greatly aiding in diagnosing complex ailments like cancer, heart disease, and neurological disorders. These specialties not only excel in diagnosis but also substantially contribute to treatment guidance. Radiological interventions, including image-guided biopsies and minimally invasive procedures, have revolutionized patient care. Similarly, nuclear medicine showcases its therapeutic potential, as seen in treatments like radioactive iodine therapy for thyroid disorders [<span>1</span>].</p><p>Furthermore, radiology and nuclear medicine have become the cornerstone of medical research, propelling innovations in imaging technology and therapeutic modalities. Researchers utilize these disciplines to explore the intricacies of diseases and develop groundbreaking treatments such as the novel [177Lu] Lu-PSMA-617 radioligand therapy for metastatic castration resistant prostate cancer [<span>2</span>]. On a broader scale, the two disciplines play indispensable roles in global health initiatives. They assist in detecting and combating diseases in resource-constrained regions, with mobile X-ray units and portable nuclear medicine devices proving instrumental in disease surveillance and treatment.</p><p>However, despite their irrefutable importance, radiology and nuclear medicine face a series of challenges in attracting medical students. From a personal perspective, there are only about 3–5 in 150 students that say would consider a career in radiology or nuclear medicine. Often, radiology and nuclear medicine occupy the periphery of medical education, with limited exposure during the formative years of medical training. According to the “Your Training Counts” report by the Medical Council of Ireland in 2015, just 53% of first-year postgraduate residents felt adequately prepared by their prior medical education for their roles as residents. Additionally, 64% of these residents considered the lack of preparedness to be a significant or moderately sized issue [<span>3</span>]. Many students only encounter these fields during their clinical rotations done usually in departments other than radiology or nuclear medicine since in Italy these specialties are counted as service sector departments and do not count for the compulsory 300 h of internship (“tirocinio abilitante” in Italian), leaving them unaware of the full spectrum of possibilities. Widespread misconceptions about radiology, such as concerns about automation impacting job prospects (aggravated by the lack of awareness regarding artificial intelligence [AI]) or the perceived lack of patient interaction, can dissuade students from considering these specialties. Dispelling these myths is critical [<span>4, 5</span>]. Residencies in radiology and nuclear medicine tend to be highly competitive in certain countries like the USA, which can be intimidating for aspiring students [<span>6</span>]. The fierce competition may discourage some from pursuing these fields. The rapid advancement of technology within radiology and nuclear medicine can appear daunting to students. The perception of a steep learning curve can act as a deterrent. Thus, it is necessary to introduce a foundation of knowledge regarding AI into medical student curricula. The conversations regarding these themes need to move from the expert to the student, apart from the expert to the expert. Finally, in certain regions, shortages of radiologists and nuclear medicine physicians have led to heavy workloads and concerns about work–life balance, creating apprehension among potential candidates [<span>7</span>]. These regional disparities are further influenced by the income, the length of specialty training, and the number of training posts available in each country (Table 1).</p><p>To effectively harness the interest of medical students in radiology and nuclear medicine, a multifaceted approach is essential. Initiating exposure to radiology and nuclear medicine concepts within the preclinical curriculum is foundational. Lectures, case-based learning, and hands-on workshops can provide students with an early understanding of the relevance and possibilities in these fields. Similarly, establishing mentorship programs connecting medical students with experienced radiologists and nuclear medicine specialists is invaluable. A study conducted at Newcastle University (UK) clearly demonstrates that medical students have a strong preference for interactive case-based discussions as their primary mode of learning, as opposed to other methods such as traditional topic presentations or exam-style questioning [<span>10</span>]. This preference is supported by findings from other authors as well. Zou et al. discovered that a significant majority of students favored teaching through interactive dialogs, particularly in small group settings where students actively participate in answering questions [<span>11</span>]. Furthermore, in 1993, the American College of Radiology (ACR) introduced the ACR Appropriateness Criteria. This resource has been regularly updated and serves as a valuable online tool for both physicians and medical students. It aids in the identification of appropriate imaging requirements by providing evidence-based, peer-reviewed guidelines that encompass diagnostic imaging selection, radiotherapy protocols, and image-guided interventional procedures [<span>12</span>]. Indeed, joining radiological societies such as the ACR or Royal College of Radiologists have proved invaluable as they offer a vast exposure to radiology-related content, symposia, courses, etc. Additionally, personalized guidance can debunk misconceptions, provide career advice, and foster a sense of belonging within these specialties.</p><p>In addition, offering comprehensive and engaging clinical rotations in radiology and nuclear medicine during the clinical years is pivotal. Encouraging active participation enables students to witness firsthand the real-world impact of these specialties. Promoting research opportunities within radiology and nuclear medicine deepens students' understanding and appreciation. Medical students could interact with radiology research published in several journals through letters to the editors, commentaries, etc., and this should be encouraged by experts in the field by giving them the necessary guidance or supervision [<span>13</span>]. Engaging in research projects opens doors to academic careers and underscores the importance of these fields.</p><p>Moreover, developing interactive learning tools, such as virtual radiology labs and online platforms simulating real-world scenarios, can enhance students' confidence in interpreting imaging studies and make learning more engaging. Also, establishing a diverse and inclusive environment within radiology and nuclear medicine departments is essential. A diverse workforce serves as an inspiration to students from underrepresented backgrounds. Providing accurate information about job market conditions, including demand and opportunities for subspecialization, helps allay concerns and showcase the potential for fulfilling careers in these fields. Offering ongoing educational opportunities to medical students and residents ensures they stay abreast of the latest advancements in imaging technology and clinical practice.</p><p>Advocating for the significance of radiology and nuclear medicine in healthcare and society is imperative. Raising awareness about their contributions to patient care and research can generate greater interest among students and change how the specialty is viewed in the eyes of the general public. Collaborating closely with medical schools to align curricula with the evolving needs of healthcare is vital. Dialog and adaptation of educational approaches are necessary to cater to the interests and aspirations of students.</p><p>In conclusion, radiology and nuclear medicine represent essential pillars of modern healthcare. Nurturing the interest of medical students in these fields is critical for the continued advancement of diagnostic excellence. Addressing challenges, providing early exposure, fostering mentorship, promoting research and diversity, dispelling misconceptions, and advocating for these fields all contribute to ensuring a continuous influx of passionate and skilled professionals. Together, we can empower the next generation of radiologists and nuclear medicine specialists who will push the boundaries of medical imaging and enhance patient care worldwide.</p><p>Arosh S. Perera Molligoda Arachchige analyzed the data and prepared the first draft of the manuscript, participated in the conception, and design of the study; Francesca Romana Centini constructively revised the manuscript; Arosh S. Perera Molligoda Arachchige and Francesca Romana Centini participated in data collection and organization; Niccolò Stomeo participated in and supervised the study throughout, and they share corresponding authorship. All authors commented on previous versions of the manuscript and approved the final version.</p><p>The authors declare no conflict of interest.</p><p>Not applicable.</p><p>Not applicable.</p>\",\"PeriodicalId\":73508,\"journal\":{\"name\":\"iRadiology\",\"volume\":\"1 4\",\"pages\":\"381-384\"},\"PeriodicalIF\":0.0000,\"publicationDate\":\"2023-11-30\",\"publicationTypes\":\"Journal Article\",\"fieldsOfStudy\":null,\"isOpenAccess\":false,\"openAccessPdf\":\"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1002/ird3.45\",\"citationCount\":\"0\",\"resultStr\":null,\"platform\":\"Semanticscholar\",\"paperid\":null,\"PeriodicalName\":\"iRadiology\",\"FirstCategoryId\":\"1085\",\"ListUrlMain\":\"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/ird3.45\",\"RegionNum\":0,\"RegionCategory\":null,\"ArticlePicture\":[],\"TitleCN\":null,\"AbstractTextCN\":null,\"PMCID\":null,\"EPubDate\":\"\",\"PubModel\":\"\",\"JCR\":\"\",\"JCRName\":\"\",\"Score\":null,\"Total\":0}","platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"iRadiology","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/ird3.45","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0

摘要

在当今飞速发展的医疗领域,放射学和核医学占据着独特而不可或缺的地位。这些学科是现代医疗保健的先锋,为疾病诊断、治疗计划和前沿研究提供了重要工具。然而,与其他医学专业一样,这些领域的持续发展有赖于培养医学生的兴趣。确保放射学和核医学专业技术人才的稳定供应,对于满足这些领域日益增长的需求至关重要。我们希望深入探讨放射学和核医学的深远意义,以及在吸引医学生方面遇到的挑战,并提出一系列旨在有效点燃医学生兴趣的综合策略。放射学包括 X 射线、CT 扫描、核磁共振成像和超声波等模式,提供无创成像技术,有助于精确诊断疾病。与此同时,核医学利用放射性示踪剂将生理过程可视化,大大有助于诊断癌症、心脏病和神经系统疾病等复杂疾病。这些专业不仅在诊断方面表现出色,在治疗指导方面也做出了巨大贡献。放射介入,包括图像引导活检和微创手术,为病人护理带来了革命性的变化。此外,放射学和核医学已成为医学研究的基石,推动了成像技术和治疗模式的创新。研究人员利用这些学科探索疾病的复杂性,并开发出突破性的治疗方法,如治疗转移性阉割抗性前列腺癌的新型[177Lu] Lu-PSMA-617 放射性配体疗法[2]。在更广泛的范围内,这两个学科在全球健康计划中发挥着不可或缺的作用。它们在资源有限的地区协助检测和防治疾病,移动式 X 射线装置和便携式核医学设备在疾病监测和治疗中发挥了重要作用。然而,尽管放射学和核医学的重要性无可辩驳,但它们在吸引医科学生方面却面临着一系列挑战。从个人角度来看,大约每 150 名学生中只有 3-5 人表示会考虑从事放射学或核医学专业。通常情况下,放射学和核医学在医学教育中处于边缘地位,在医学培训的成长期接触有限。根据爱尔兰医学委员会 2015 年发布的 "你的培训很重要"(Your Training Counts)报告,仅有 53% 的一年级研究生住院医师认为他们之前的医学教育为他们担任住院医师做好了充分准备。此外,64%的住院医师认为准备不足是一个重大或中等程度的问题[3]。许多学生只有在临床轮转时才会接触到这些领域,通常是在放射科或核医学以外的科室,因为在意大利,这些专科被算作服务部门,不计入强制性的 300 小时实习(意大利语为 "tirocinio abilitante"),这使他们不了解全部的可能性。对放射学普遍存在的误解,如担心自动化会影响就业前景(对人工智能缺乏认识又加剧了这种担忧),或认为放射学缺乏与患者的互动,都会使学生不愿考虑这些专业。消除这些误解至关重要[4, 5]。在某些国家(如美国),放射学和核医学的住院医师往往竞争激烈,这可能会让有抱负的学生望而生畏[6]。激烈的竞争可能会让一些人对这些领域望而却步。放射学和核医学技术的飞速发展可能会让学生望而生畏。陡峭的学习曲线会让学生望而却步。因此,有必要在医学生课程中引入有关人工智能的基础知识。有关这些主题的对话需要从专家转向学生,而不是从专家转向专家。最后,在某些地区,放射科医生和核医学医生的短缺导致了繁重的工作量和对工作与生活平衡的担忧,使潜在的候选人产生了忧虑[7]。这些地区差异还受到各国收入、专科培训时间长短和培训岗位数量的影响(表 1)。 在临床前课程中开始接触放射学和核医学概念是非常重要的。讲座、病例学习和实践研讨会可以让学生尽早了解这些领域的相关性和可能性。同样,建立医学生与经验丰富的放射科医生和核医学专家之间的导师计划也非常有价值。英国纽卡斯尔大学(Newcastle University)进行的一项研究清楚地表明,相对于传统的专题报告或考试式提问等其他方法,医学生更倾向于将互动式病例讨论作为主要的学习方式[10]。其他学者的研究结果也支持这种偏好。Zou 等人发现,绝大多数学生都喜欢通过互动对话进行教学,尤其是在学生积极参与回答问题的小组环境中[11]。此外,1993 年,美国放射学会(ACR)推出了《ACR 适宜性标准》。该资源定期更新,是医生和医学生的重要在线工具。它通过提供以证据为基础、经同行评审的指南,包括诊断成像选择、放射治疗方案和图像引导的介入治疗程序,帮助确定适当的成像要求[12]。事实上,加入 ACR 或皇家放射医师学院等放射学会已被证明是非常有价值的,因为它们提供了大量与放射学相关的内容、研讨会、课程等。此外,个性化指导可以消除误解,提供职业建议,培养学生对这些专业的归属感。鼓励学生积极参与,可以让他们亲眼目睹这些专业在现实世界中的影响。促进放射学和核医学的研究机会可加深学生的理解和认识。医学生可以通过给编辑写信、发表评论等方式与一些期刊上发表的放射学研究进行互动,该领域的专家应鼓励学生这样做,并给予必要的指导或监督[13]。此外,开发互动学习工具,如虚拟放射学实验室和模拟真实世界场景的在线平台,可以增强学生解读影像研究的信心,使学习更有吸引力。此外,在放射科和核医学科建立一个多元化和包容性的环境也至关重要。多元化的员工队伍可以激励来自弱势背景的学生。提供有关就业市场状况的准确信息,包括亚专业的需求和机会,有助于打消顾虑,并展示在这些领域从事充实职业的潜力。为医科学生和住院医师提供持续的教育机会,确保他们了解成像技术和临床实践的最新进展。宣传放射学和核医学在医疗保健和社会中的重要意义势在必行。提高人们对其在患者护理和研究方面所作贡献的认识,可以激发学生的兴趣,改变公众对该专业的看法。与医学院密切合作,使课程设置与不断变化的医疗保健需求保持一致至关重要。总之,放射学和核医学是现代医疗保健的重要支柱。培养医学生对这些领域的兴趣对于继续推进卓越诊断至关重要。应对挑战、提供早期接触机会、培养良师益友、促进研究和多样性、消除误解以及宣传这些领域,所有这些都有助于确保不断涌入充满热情和技能娴熟的专业人员。Arosh S. Perera Molligoda Arachchige分析了数据并准备了手稿初稿,参与了研究的构思和设计;Francesca Romana Centini对手稿进行了建设性的修改;Arosh S. Perera Molligoda Arachchige分析了数据并准备了手稿初稿,参与了研究的构思和设计;Francesca Romana Centini对手稿进行了建设性的修改;Arosh S. Perera Molligoda Arachchige分析了数据并准备了手稿初稿,参与了研究的构思和设计;Francesca Romana Centini对手稿进行了建设性的修改。Perera Molligoda Arachchige和Francesca Romana Centini参与了数据收集和整理工作;Niccolò Stomeo全程参与并指导了研究,两人共同担任通讯作者。
本文章由计算机程序翻译,如有差异,请以英文原文为准。
Fostering medical student interest in radiology and nuclear medicine

In today's rapidly evolving medical landscape, the fields of radiology and nuclear medicine occupy a distinct and indispensable position. These disciplines serve as vanguards of modern healthcare, providing essential tools for disease diagnosis, treatment planning, and cutting-edge research. However, like any medical specialty, the sustained development of these fields relies on cultivating and nurturing the interest of medical students. Ensuring a steady supply of skilled professionals in radiology and nuclear medicine is paramount to meeting the burgeoning demand in these domains. We would like to delve into the profound significance of radiology and nuclear medicine and into the challenges encountered in attracting medical students and present a comprehensive array of strategies designed to effectively ignite their interest.

Radiology and nuclear medicine have carved out pivotal roles in the realm of modern medicine. Radiology, encompassing modalities such as X-rays, CT scans, MRI, and ultrasound, offers noninvasive imaging techniques that facilitate precise and accurate disease diagnosis. In parallel, nuclear medicine harnesses radioactive tracers to visualize physiological processes, greatly aiding in diagnosing complex ailments like cancer, heart disease, and neurological disorders. These specialties not only excel in diagnosis but also substantially contribute to treatment guidance. Radiological interventions, including image-guided biopsies and minimally invasive procedures, have revolutionized patient care. Similarly, nuclear medicine showcases its therapeutic potential, as seen in treatments like radioactive iodine therapy for thyroid disorders [1].

Furthermore, radiology and nuclear medicine have become the cornerstone of medical research, propelling innovations in imaging technology and therapeutic modalities. Researchers utilize these disciplines to explore the intricacies of diseases and develop groundbreaking treatments such as the novel [177Lu] Lu-PSMA-617 radioligand therapy for metastatic castration resistant prostate cancer [2]. On a broader scale, the two disciplines play indispensable roles in global health initiatives. They assist in detecting and combating diseases in resource-constrained regions, with mobile X-ray units and portable nuclear medicine devices proving instrumental in disease surveillance and treatment.

However, despite their irrefutable importance, radiology and nuclear medicine face a series of challenges in attracting medical students. From a personal perspective, there are only about 3–5 in 150 students that say would consider a career in radiology or nuclear medicine. Often, radiology and nuclear medicine occupy the periphery of medical education, with limited exposure during the formative years of medical training. According to the “Your Training Counts” report by the Medical Council of Ireland in 2015, just 53% of first-year postgraduate residents felt adequately prepared by their prior medical education for their roles as residents. Additionally, 64% of these residents considered the lack of preparedness to be a significant or moderately sized issue [3]. Many students only encounter these fields during their clinical rotations done usually in departments other than radiology or nuclear medicine since in Italy these specialties are counted as service sector departments and do not count for the compulsory 300 h of internship (“tirocinio abilitante” in Italian), leaving them unaware of the full spectrum of possibilities. Widespread misconceptions about radiology, such as concerns about automation impacting job prospects (aggravated by the lack of awareness regarding artificial intelligence [AI]) or the perceived lack of patient interaction, can dissuade students from considering these specialties. Dispelling these myths is critical [4, 5]. Residencies in radiology and nuclear medicine tend to be highly competitive in certain countries like the USA, which can be intimidating for aspiring students [6]. The fierce competition may discourage some from pursuing these fields. The rapid advancement of technology within radiology and nuclear medicine can appear daunting to students. The perception of a steep learning curve can act as a deterrent. Thus, it is necessary to introduce a foundation of knowledge regarding AI into medical student curricula. The conversations regarding these themes need to move from the expert to the student, apart from the expert to the expert. Finally, in certain regions, shortages of radiologists and nuclear medicine physicians have led to heavy workloads and concerns about work–life balance, creating apprehension among potential candidates [7]. These regional disparities are further influenced by the income, the length of specialty training, and the number of training posts available in each country (Table 1).

To effectively harness the interest of medical students in radiology and nuclear medicine, a multifaceted approach is essential. Initiating exposure to radiology and nuclear medicine concepts within the preclinical curriculum is foundational. Lectures, case-based learning, and hands-on workshops can provide students with an early understanding of the relevance and possibilities in these fields. Similarly, establishing mentorship programs connecting medical students with experienced radiologists and nuclear medicine specialists is invaluable. A study conducted at Newcastle University (UK) clearly demonstrates that medical students have a strong preference for interactive case-based discussions as their primary mode of learning, as opposed to other methods such as traditional topic presentations or exam-style questioning [10]. This preference is supported by findings from other authors as well. Zou et al. discovered that a significant majority of students favored teaching through interactive dialogs, particularly in small group settings where students actively participate in answering questions [11]. Furthermore, in 1993, the American College of Radiology (ACR) introduced the ACR Appropriateness Criteria. This resource has been regularly updated and serves as a valuable online tool for both physicians and medical students. It aids in the identification of appropriate imaging requirements by providing evidence-based, peer-reviewed guidelines that encompass diagnostic imaging selection, radiotherapy protocols, and image-guided interventional procedures [12]. Indeed, joining radiological societies such as the ACR or Royal College of Radiologists have proved invaluable as they offer a vast exposure to radiology-related content, symposia, courses, etc. Additionally, personalized guidance can debunk misconceptions, provide career advice, and foster a sense of belonging within these specialties.

In addition, offering comprehensive and engaging clinical rotations in radiology and nuclear medicine during the clinical years is pivotal. Encouraging active participation enables students to witness firsthand the real-world impact of these specialties. Promoting research opportunities within radiology and nuclear medicine deepens students' understanding and appreciation. Medical students could interact with radiology research published in several journals through letters to the editors, commentaries, etc., and this should be encouraged by experts in the field by giving them the necessary guidance or supervision [13]. Engaging in research projects opens doors to academic careers and underscores the importance of these fields.

Moreover, developing interactive learning tools, such as virtual radiology labs and online platforms simulating real-world scenarios, can enhance students' confidence in interpreting imaging studies and make learning more engaging. Also, establishing a diverse and inclusive environment within radiology and nuclear medicine departments is essential. A diverse workforce serves as an inspiration to students from underrepresented backgrounds. Providing accurate information about job market conditions, including demand and opportunities for subspecialization, helps allay concerns and showcase the potential for fulfilling careers in these fields. Offering ongoing educational opportunities to medical students and residents ensures they stay abreast of the latest advancements in imaging technology and clinical practice.

Advocating for the significance of radiology and nuclear medicine in healthcare and society is imperative. Raising awareness about their contributions to patient care and research can generate greater interest among students and change how the specialty is viewed in the eyes of the general public. Collaborating closely with medical schools to align curricula with the evolving needs of healthcare is vital. Dialog and adaptation of educational approaches are necessary to cater to the interests and aspirations of students.

In conclusion, radiology and nuclear medicine represent essential pillars of modern healthcare. Nurturing the interest of medical students in these fields is critical for the continued advancement of diagnostic excellence. Addressing challenges, providing early exposure, fostering mentorship, promoting research and diversity, dispelling misconceptions, and advocating for these fields all contribute to ensuring a continuous influx of passionate and skilled professionals. Together, we can empower the next generation of radiologists and nuclear medicine specialists who will push the boundaries of medical imaging and enhance patient care worldwide.

Arosh S. Perera Molligoda Arachchige analyzed the data and prepared the first draft of the manuscript, participated in the conception, and design of the study; Francesca Romana Centini constructively revised the manuscript; Arosh S. Perera Molligoda Arachchige and Francesca Romana Centini participated in data collection and organization; Niccolò Stomeo participated in and supervised the study throughout, and they share corresponding authorship. All authors commented on previous versions of the manuscript and approved the final version.

The authors declare no conflict of interest.

Not applicable.

Not applicable.

求助全文
通过发布文献求助,成功后即可免费获取论文全文。 去求助
来源期刊
自引率
0.00%
发文量
0
×
引用
GB/T 7714-2015
复制
MLA
复制
APA
复制
导出至
BibTeX EndNote RefMan NoteFirst NoteExpress
×
提示
您的信息不完整,为了账户安全,请先补充。
现在去补充
×
提示
您因"违规操作"
具体请查看互助需知
我知道了
×
提示
确定
请完成安全验证×
copy
已复制链接
快去分享给好友吧!
我知道了
右上角分享
点击右上角分享
0
联系我们:info@booksci.cn Book学术提供免费学术资源搜索服务,方便国内外学者检索中英文文献。致力于提供最便捷和优质的服务体验。 Copyright © 2023 布克学术 All rights reserved.
京ICP备2023020795号-1
ghs 京公网安备 11010802042870号
Book学术文献互助
Book学术文献互助群
群 号:481959085
Book学术官方微信