Cell differentiation and matrix organization are differentially affected during bone formation in osteogenesis imperfecta zebrafish models with different genetic defects impacting collagen type I structure

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is a family of rare heritable skeletal disorders associated with dominant mutations in the collagen type I encoding genes and recessive defects in proteins involved in collagen type I synthesis and processing and in osteoblast differentiation and activity. Historically, it was believed that the OI bone phenotype was only caused by abnormal collagen type I fibrils in the extracellular matrix, but more recently it became clear that the altered bone cell homeostasis, due to mutant collagen retention, plays a relevant role in modulating disease severity in most of the OI forms and it is correlated to impaired bone cell differentiation. Despite in vitro evidence, in vivo data are missing. To better understand the physiopathology of OI, we used two zebrafish models: Chihuahua (Chi/+), carrying a dominant p.G736D substitution in the α1 chain of collagen type I, and the recessive p3h1^−/−, lacking prolyl 3-hydroxylase (P3h1) enzyme. Both models share the delay of collagen type I folding, resulting in its overmodification and partial intracellular retention. The regeneration of the bony caudal fin of Chi/+ and p3h1^−/− was employed to investigate the impact of abnormal collagen synthesis on bone cell differentiation. Reduced regenerative ability was evident in both models, but it was associated to impaired osteoblast differentiation and osteoblastogenesis/adipogenesis switch only in Chi/+. On the contrary, reduced osteoclast number and activity were found in both models during regeneration. The dominant OI model showed a more detrimental effect in the extracellular matrix organization. Interestingly, the chemical chaperone 4-phenylbutyrate (4-PBA), known to reduce cellular stress and increase collagen secretion, improved bone formation only in p3h1^−/− by favoring caudal fin growth without affecting bone cell markers expression. Taken together, our in vivo data proved the negative impact of structurally abnormal collagen type I on bone formation but revealed a gene mutation-specific effect on bone cell differentiation and matrix organization in OI. These, together with the distinct ability to respond to the chaperone treatment, underline the need for precision medicine approaches to properly treat the disease.