Tuberculum sellae meningiomas: surgical outcomes in 65 patients, review of the literature and proposal for an anatomical and radiological classification.

Abstract

Tuberculum sellae meningiomas (TSM) are challenging tumors due to their proximity to vital neurovascular structures. We propose a new classification system based on anatomical and radiological parameters. All patients treated for TSM, between January 2003 and December 2016, have been retrospectively reviewed. A systematic research was performed in PubMed database to review all studies comparing the performance of transcranial (TCA) and transphenoidal (ETSA) approaches. Overall, 65 patients were included in the surgical series. Gross total removal (GTR) was achieved in 55 patients (85%) and near total resection in 10 (15%). 54 patients (83%) showed a stability or an improvement of visual functions and 11 (17%) worsened. Postoperative complications were observed in seven patients (11%): CSF leak in one patient (1.5%); diabetes insipidus in two (3%); hypopituitarism in two (3%) third cranial nerve paresis and subdural empyema in one (1.5%). For the literature review, data about 10,833 patients (TCA N.=9159; ETSA N.=1674) were recorded; GTR was achieved in 84.1% (range 68-92%) of TCA and in 79.1% (range 60-92%) of ETSA; visual improvement (VI) occurred in 59.3% of TCA (range 25-84%) and in 79.3% of ETSA (range 46-100%); visual deterioration (VD) was registered in 12.7% of TCA (0-24%) and in 4.1% of ETSA (range 0-17%); a CSF-leak was observed in 3.8% of TCA (range 0-8%) while in ETSA in 18.6% of patients (range 0-62%); vascular injuries was reported in 4% (range 0-15%) of TCA and in 1.5% (range 0-5%) of ETSA. In conclusion, TSMs represent a unique category of midline tumors. The proposed classification system provides an intuitive and reproducible method in the choice of the most suitable approach.