Improved stand structure characterization from nested plot designs in the Spanish National Forest Inventory

Abstract

National forest inventories, in which trees are often mapped within the plots, provide a tool for the quantification of large-scale forest structure since they cover all forest areas. Many National Forest Inventories follow a nested design in order to reduce the sampling effort for smaller trees. We propose and test a methodology that allows the spatial pattern of trees, species mingling and size differentiation to be characterized using the nearest neighbour indices and second-order moment functions from nested plot data. The nearest neighbour indices and second-order moment functions for the actual distribution are compared with simulations of the appropriate null model: spatial randomness for spatial pattern characterization or spatial independence for species mingling and size differentiation. The proposed method consists of constraining the null model to fit the nested plot design. For the purposes of the study, we simulated 120 plots and used 26 real plots located in pure and mixed stands in Central Spain, for which a complete census with detailed information about trees was available. The nested design used in the Spanish National Forest Inventory (SNFI) plots was simulated to test the performance, taking the complete census as reference. Despite of the limited accuracy for some structural measures, the proposed method based on nested design data performed better for most of the nearest neighbour indices and second-order moment functions than the strategy currently used in the SNFI for structure assessment in a subsample of SNFI plots, consisting of mapping the 20 trees closest to the plot centre. Nearest neighbour indices provided greater accuracy for species mingling assessment than second-order moment functions, whereas the opposite occurred when describing spatial pattern and size differentiation. The methodology proposed provides the first insight into the characterization of forest structure in nested designs although more evaluations are required for different forest types.