{"title":"Schools that heal: design with mental health in mind","authors":"Majid Amani Beni, Mohammad Reza Khalilnezhad","doi":"10.1080/23748834.2022.2136611","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"those who use it. Indeed, a unique facet of the book is how conversational and personal it reads. Each chapter is a ‘practice story’—a product of an interview with the author whereby their strategies and observations about a particular project, its processes, challenges and outcomes are described and reflected on. This way of setting up the book affords a sense of honesty and education that will undoubtedly be valuable for anyone seeking to embark in a participatory planning endeavour for the first time, or hone these skills for those who are seasoned at engaging with communities. The book is structured around three distinct parts that frame the place makers’ stories. Part I is titled ‘Design, Collaboration, and Ownership’ and includes four chapters that tackle broad but timely topics such as affordable housing and ethnicity, public space use, and group dynamics among stakeholders. The authors in this section recall actions taken, and lessons learned, related to the projects that they are describing for the book – many of which are both relatable and repeatable for those who live and work in cities with analogous demographics and economics. Many authors note the benefits of finding more accessible ways to inform (but also to learn with) members of the public so that everyone has a confident voice in municipal decisionmaking. Part II is titled ‘Engagement and Difference in Placemaking’ and includes four chapters concerning dispute resolution and racial violence, the development of a justice centre, community belonging, and the art of listening and being accountable in a community. These authors discuss some of the strategies used to form partnerships with community members and organizations, including working in alignment with the idiosyncratic aspects of a place in order to make participatory methods work smoothly. The authors also make sure that readers understand how important the local context is, whether the issue at hand is food security, social justice, public health – and beyond. Authors’ insights formed from the ground up seem transposable to research and activism related to mental health: When planners and administrators concern themselves with the culture and the nuanced ways of living in a place, it often results in stronger trust-building and a level of openness among stakeholders and community members, affording greater democracy and cogent policy-making. Last, Part III is called ‘Art, Imagination, and Value Creation.’ Its five chapters discuss links between public art and economic development, place identity, sustainable design, and cultivating the arts in communities in general. This collection of chapters expresses a common worry among the authors that decision-makers may not thoroughly or consistently listen to, or act on, what artists, activists, entrepreneurs, gardeners, and other community players suggest for a setting. This section of the book may be particularly helpful for those looking to make a difference at the individual-level, as well as work within teams with varied interests, to form an impactful voice and attain meaningful goals. The book includes an engaging introduction and conclusion by the editor to frame his motivations for writing the work and to justify the timeline toward its development. These portions are important because the book has been published in the wake of a number of global crises, such as the COVID-19 pandemic, the continued effects of climate change, and numerous public uprisings addressing social and racial injustice. The editor offers an ‘afterword’ section to explain the relevance of the book’s storylines in a pandemic era, as well as in the context of the recent Black Lives Matter movement. The book also includes three appendices to augment some of the information given in particular chapters (along with details about the interviews conducted with each chapter author, such as dates and approval documentation) to further mark the book as an ethical and formal undertaking. Overall, ‘How Spaces Become Places: Place Makers Tell Their Stories’ is an inspiring volume for those studying or working in the social sciences, public health, planning and design disciplines, and other fields that rely on humane, organic communication methods to bring many kinds of people together in support of a public purpose. Anyone who wishes to learn from others’ accounts of their trials and success stories on the job – whether they are artists, community members, government administrators, city managers, or academics alike – can find much satisfaction and instruction in this well-curated book. Lindsay J. McCunn Department of Psychology, Vancouver Island University, Nanaimo, BC, Canada lindsay.mccunn@viu.ca","PeriodicalId":72596,"journal":{"name":"Cities & health","volume":"1 1","pages":"1050 - 1052"},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2022-10-25","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"1","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Cities & health","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.1080/23748834.2022.2136611","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 1
Abstract
those who use it. Indeed, a unique facet of the book is how conversational and personal it reads. Each chapter is a ‘practice story’—a product of an interview with the author whereby their strategies and observations about a particular project, its processes, challenges and outcomes are described and reflected on. This way of setting up the book affords a sense of honesty and education that will undoubtedly be valuable for anyone seeking to embark in a participatory planning endeavour for the first time, or hone these skills for those who are seasoned at engaging with communities. The book is structured around three distinct parts that frame the place makers’ stories. Part I is titled ‘Design, Collaboration, and Ownership’ and includes four chapters that tackle broad but timely topics such as affordable housing and ethnicity, public space use, and group dynamics among stakeholders. The authors in this section recall actions taken, and lessons learned, related to the projects that they are describing for the book – many of which are both relatable and repeatable for those who live and work in cities with analogous demographics and economics. Many authors note the benefits of finding more accessible ways to inform (but also to learn with) members of the public so that everyone has a confident voice in municipal decisionmaking. Part II is titled ‘Engagement and Difference in Placemaking’ and includes four chapters concerning dispute resolution and racial violence, the development of a justice centre, community belonging, and the art of listening and being accountable in a community. These authors discuss some of the strategies used to form partnerships with community members and organizations, including working in alignment with the idiosyncratic aspects of a place in order to make participatory methods work smoothly. The authors also make sure that readers understand how important the local context is, whether the issue at hand is food security, social justice, public health – and beyond. Authors’ insights formed from the ground up seem transposable to research and activism related to mental health: When planners and administrators concern themselves with the culture and the nuanced ways of living in a place, it often results in stronger trust-building and a level of openness among stakeholders and community members, affording greater democracy and cogent policy-making. Last, Part III is called ‘Art, Imagination, and Value Creation.’ Its five chapters discuss links between public art and economic development, place identity, sustainable design, and cultivating the arts in communities in general. This collection of chapters expresses a common worry among the authors that decision-makers may not thoroughly or consistently listen to, or act on, what artists, activists, entrepreneurs, gardeners, and other community players suggest for a setting. This section of the book may be particularly helpful for those looking to make a difference at the individual-level, as well as work within teams with varied interests, to form an impactful voice and attain meaningful goals. The book includes an engaging introduction and conclusion by the editor to frame his motivations for writing the work and to justify the timeline toward its development. These portions are important because the book has been published in the wake of a number of global crises, such as the COVID-19 pandemic, the continued effects of climate change, and numerous public uprisings addressing social and racial injustice. The editor offers an ‘afterword’ section to explain the relevance of the book’s storylines in a pandemic era, as well as in the context of the recent Black Lives Matter movement. The book also includes three appendices to augment some of the information given in particular chapters (along with details about the interviews conducted with each chapter author, such as dates and approval documentation) to further mark the book as an ethical and formal undertaking. Overall, ‘How Spaces Become Places: Place Makers Tell Their Stories’ is an inspiring volume for those studying or working in the social sciences, public health, planning and design disciplines, and other fields that rely on humane, organic communication methods to bring many kinds of people together in support of a public purpose. Anyone who wishes to learn from others’ accounts of their trials and success stories on the job – whether they are artists, community members, government administrators, city managers, or academics alike – can find much satisfaction and instruction in this well-curated book. Lindsay J. McCunn Department of Psychology, Vancouver Island University, Nanaimo, BC, Canada lindsay.mccunn@viu.ca
那些使用它的人。事实上,这本书的独特之处在于它的对话和个人化。每一章都是一个“实践故事”——这是对作者的一次采访的产物,作者在采访中描述和反思了他们对一个特定项目的策略和观察、过程、挑战和结果。这种设置本书的方式提供了一种诚实和教育的感觉,这无疑对任何第一次寻求参与规划工作的人来说都是有价值的,或者对那些在与社区接触方面经验丰富的人来说,磨练这些技能是有价值的。这本书由三个不同的部分构成,这些部分构成了地方创造者的故事。第一部分的标题是“设计、合作和所有权”,包括四个章节,涉及广泛而及时的主题,如经济适用房和种族、公共空间使用和利益相关者之间的群体动态。这一部分的作者回顾了他们在书中描述的项目所采取的行动和吸取的教训,其中许多对那些在人口和经济状况类似的城市生活和工作的人来说都是相关的和可重复的。许多作者指出,找到更容易获得的方式来告知(同时也与之学习)公众成员的好处,这样每个人都能在市政决策中有自信的发言权。第二部分的标题是“参与和不同的地方”,包括四个章节,涉及解决争端和种族暴力,司法中心的发展,社区归属感,以及在社区中倾听和负责的艺术。这些作者讨论了一些用于与社区成员和组织建立伙伴关系的策略,包括与一个地方的特殊方面保持一致,以使参与式方法顺利工作。作者还确保读者理解当地背景的重要性,以及手头的问题是食品安全、社会正义、公共卫生还是其他。作者从底层形成的见解似乎可以适用于与心理健康相关的研究和行动主义:当规划者和管理者关注一个地方的文化和细微的生活方式时,往往会在利益相关者和社区成员之间建立更强的信任和一定程度的开放,从而提供更大的民主和更有说服力的决策。最后,第三部分是“艺术、想象和价值创造”。它的五个章节讨论了公共艺术与经济发展、地方认同、可持续设计以及在社区中培养艺术之间的联系。这些章节的集合表达了作者们普遍的担忧,即决策者可能不会彻底或始终如一地听取艺术家、活动家、企业家、园丁和其他社区参与者对环境的建议,或者采取行动。对于那些希望在个人层面有所作为的人,以及那些希望在不同兴趣的团队中工作的人,形成有影响力的声音并实现有意义的目标,这本书的这一部分可能特别有帮助。这本书包括一个引人入胜的介绍和结论,由编辑框架他的动机写作的工作,并证明时间轴的发展。这些部分很重要,因为这本书是在一系列全球危机之后出版的,比如COVID-19大流行,气候变化的持续影响,以及许多针对社会和种族不公正的公众起义。编辑提供了一个“后记”部分来解释这本书的故事情节在流行病时代的相关性,以及在最近的黑人生命也是运动的背景下。本书还包括三个附录,以补充特定章节中给出的一些信息(以及与每章作者进行的访谈的详细信息,如日期和批准文件),以进一步标志本书是一个道德和正式的承诺。总的来说,《空间如何成为场所:场所制造者讲述他们的故事》是一本鼓舞人心的书,适合那些在社会科学、公共卫生、规划和设计学科以及其他领域学习或工作的人,这些领域依赖于人性化、有机的沟通方法,将各种各样的人聚集在一起,以支持公共目的。无论是艺术家、社区成员、政府管理人员、城市管理者还是学者,任何希望从别人的工作经历和成功故事中学习的人,都能在这本精心策划的书中找到很多满足感和指导。Lindsay J. McCunn温哥华岛大学心理学系,加拿大BC省纳奈莫lindsay.mccunn@viu.ca