Acquisition of the Long Jump Skill Using Varying Feedback / Usvajanje tehnike skoka u dalj korištenjem povratnih informacija različitih vrsta i frekvencija
Aleksandar Puklavec, Ljubomir Antekolović, P. Mikulic
{"title":"Acquisition of the Long Jump Skill Using Varying Feedback / Usvajanje tehnike skoka u dalj korištenjem povratnih informacija različitih vrsta i frekvencija","authors":"Aleksandar Puklavec, Ljubomir Antekolović, P. Mikulic","doi":"10.15516/CJE.V23I1.3994","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"The aim of this study was to examine the acquisition of the long jump skill in elementary school children using augmented feedback of varying type and frequency. Eighty-eight boys and girls aged (mean ± SD) 11 ± 0.5 years, without any prior experience in the long jump skill acquisition, were assigned to one of the four study groups: (1) the group receiving only verbal feedback on key errors, (2) the group receiving both verbal and video feedback on key errors, (3) the group receiving both verbal and video feedback on all errors, and (4) the group receiving no feedback. Before and after an 8-week training intervention, long jump distance and relevant kinematic variables were recorded. The results indicated that the group receiving both verbal and video feedback on all errors improved the most in terms of the long jump distance. Varying feedback influenced kinematic parameters differently, as there was no consistent change in the monitored kinematic variables across groups. It was concluded that, when learning a complex motor skill in a typical Physical Education setting, elementary school children are likely to benefit the most when receiving frequent feedback (both verbal and using video analysis, focusing on all errors) in comparison with the situation in which they receive feedback reduced in the type (only verbal) and the frequency (focusing only on key errors). Keywords: bandwidth feedback; kinematics; knowledge of performance; motor learning. --- Cilj ovoga rada bio je ispitati utjecaj razlicitih kolicina i vrsta povratnih informacija (PI) u procesu usvajanja tehnike skoka u dalj kod ucenika osnovne skole. Osamdeset i osam ucenika i ucenica, starosti 11 (±0,5) godina, bez prethodnoga iskustva u treningu skoka u dalj, raspodijeljeno je u jednu od cetiriju skupina ispitanika koje su dobivale PI: (1) verbalno samo na kljucne greske, (2) verbalno i vizualno samo na kljucne greske, (3) verbalno i vizualno na sve greske ili (4) nisu primale PI. Duljina skoka i relevantni kinematicki parametri skoka u dalj izmjereni su prije i nakon 8-tjednog eksperimentalnoga tretmana. Rezultati istraživanja pokazali su kako je grupa koja je primala PI, na svaku gresku verbalnim i vizualnim putem najvise napredovala u smislu duljine skoka u dalj. Razlicite kolicine i vrste PI razlicito djelovale su na promatrane kinematicke parametre te nisu uocene konzistentne promjene između grupa. Zakljuceno je kako djeca osnovnoskolske dobi prilikom usvajanja kompleksne motoricke vjestine imaju vise koristi od vecih frekvencija PI (verbalnih i vizualnih na sve greske) u usporedbi s reduciranim PI prema vrsti (samo verbalne) ili frekvenciji (samo na kljucne greske). Kljucne rijeci: kinematika; motoricko ucenje; poznavanje izvedbe; reducirane povratne informacije.","PeriodicalId":44438,"journal":{"name":"Croatian Journal of Education-Hrvatski Casopis Za Odgoj I Obrazovanje","volume":"48 1","pages":"107-132"},"PeriodicalIF":0.3000,"publicationDate":"2021-03-23","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"3","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Croatian Journal of Education-Hrvatski Casopis Za Odgoj I Obrazovanje","FirstCategoryId":"95","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.15516/CJE.V23I1.3994","RegionNum":4,"RegionCategory":"教育学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q4","JCRName":"EDUCATION & EDUCATIONAL RESEARCH","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 3
Abstract
The aim of this study was to examine the acquisition of the long jump skill in elementary school children using augmented feedback of varying type and frequency. Eighty-eight boys and girls aged (mean ± SD) 11 ± 0.5 years, without any prior experience in the long jump skill acquisition, were assigned to one of the four study groups: (1) the group receiving only verbal feedback on key errors, (2) the group receiving both verbal and video feedback on key errors, (3) the group receiving both verbal and video feedback on all errors, and (4) the group receiving no feedback. Before and after an 8-week training intervention, long jump distance and relevant kinematic variables were recorded. The results indicated that the group receiving both verbal and video feedback on all errors improved the most in terms of the long jump distance. Varying feedback influenced kinematic parameters differently, as there was no consistent change in the monitored kinematic variables across groups. It was concluded that, when learning a complex motor skill in a typical Physical Education setting, elementary school children are likely to benefit the most when receiving frequent feedback (both verbal and using video analysis, focusing on all errors) in comparison with the situation in which they receive feedback reduced in the type (only verbal) and the frequency (focusing only on key errors). Keywords: bandwidth feedback; kinematics; knowledge of performance; motor learning. --- Cilj ovoga rada bio je ispitati utjecaj razlicitih kolicina i vrsta povratnih informacija (PI) u procesu usvajanja tehnike skoka u dalj kod ucenika osnovne skole. Osamdeset i osam ucenika i ucenica, starosti 11 (±0,5) godina, bez prethodnoga iskustva u treningu skoka u dalj, raspodijeljeno je u jednu od cetiriju skupina ispitanika koje su dobivale PI: (1) verbalno samo na kljucne greske, (2) verbalno i vizualno samo na kljucne greske, (3) verbalno i vizualno na sve greske ili (4) nisu primale PI. Duljina skoka i relevantni kinematicki parametri skoka u dalj izmjereni su prije i nakon 8-tjednog eksperimentalnoga tretmana. Rezultati istraživanja pokazali su kako je grupa koja je primala PI, na svaku gresku verbalnim i vizualnim putem najvise napredovala u smislu duljine skoka u dalj. Razlicite kolicine i vrste PI razlicito djelovale su na promatrane kinematicke parametre te nisu uocene konzistentne promjene između grupa. Zakljuceno je kako djeca osnovnoskolske dobi prilikom usvajanja kompleksne motoricke vjestine imaju vise koristi od vecih frekvencija PI (verbalnih i vizualnih na sve greske) u usporedbi s reduciranim PI prema vrsti (samo verbalne) ili frekvenciji (samo na kljucne greske). Kljucne rijeci: kinematika; motoricko ucenje; poznavanje izvedbe; reducirane povratne informacije.
摘要本研究旨在探讨不同类型及频率的增强反馈对小学生跳远技能习得的影响。88名年龄为(mean±SD) 11±0.5岁,没有任何跳远技能习得经验的男孩和女孩被分配到四个研究小组中的一个:(1)仅接受关键错误口头反馈的小组,(2)同时接受关键错误口头和视频反馈的小组,(3)同时接受所有错误口头和视频反馈的小组,(4)不接受反馈的小组。在8周的训练干预前后,记录跳远距离和相关运动学变量。结果表明,对所有错误都接受口头和视频反馈的那组在跳远距离方面进步最大。不同的反馈对运动学参数的影响不同,因为各组监测的运动学变量没有一致的变化。结论是,在典型的体育教育环境中,当学习复杂的运动技能时,小学生在获得频繁的反馈(包括口头和使用视频分析,专注于所有错误)时,与他们收到的反馈类型(仅口头)和频率(仅关注关键错误)减少的情况相比,他们可能受益最大。关键词:带宽反馈;运动学;业绩知识;运动学习。-- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- --Osamdeset i osam ucenika i ucenica, starosti 11(±0,5)godina, bez prethodnoga iskustva u treningu skoka u dalj, raspodijeljeno je u jednu d cetiriju skupina ispitanika koje su双值PI:(1) verbalno samo na kljune greske, (2) verbalno i vizualno samo na kljune greske, (3) verbalno i vizualno na sveve greske, (4) nisu priu PI。Duljina skoka i相关运动学参数skoka u dalj izmjereni su prije i nakon 8- jednog实验研究。Rezultati istraživanja pokazali su kako je grupa koja je primala PI, na svaku gresku verbalnim i vizualnim putem najvise napredovala u smislu duljine skoka u dalj。拉丝石的临床研究,以拉丝石为例,对拉丝石的运动学参数进行了分析,确定了拉丝石的运动学参数为拉丝石između组。Zakljuceno je kako jeca osnovnoskolske dobi priilikom usvajanja kompleksne motoricke vjestine imaju vise koristi od vech frekvencija PI (verbalnih i vizualnih na sve greske),但usporeddbi is reduciranim PI prema vrsti (samo verbalne) ili frekvenciji (samo na kljune greske)。kljune rijeci:运动学;motoricko ucenje;poznavanje izvedbe;还原丙二醇。