A Randomized Trial to Maximize Identification and Genetic Counseling Referral of Women at Risk for Hereditary Breast and Ovarian Cancer

Abstract

Purpose: The Breast Cancer Genetics Referral Screening Tool (B-RST™) has been endorsed as one of several validated screening tools to identify women appropriate for cancer genetics referral. We conducted a randomized trial to determine the most effective means of follow-up for women who screened positive on B-RST™ 3.0. Methods: Women undergoing screening mammography at one of four Emory clinics were approached to complete the B-RST™. Participants who screened positive were randomized to one of three follow-up groups: self-referral (Group 1), electronic health record (EHR) clinician messaging (Group 2), or direct contact (Group 3). We compared genetic counseling appointment scheduling and completion rates by group. Results: Of 2,422 participants, 658 (27.2%) screened positive. Genetic counseling appointments were scheduled by 9.2%, 20.1% and 9.7% of Group 1, 2 and 3 participants respectively (p=0.001). Challenges to scheduling included lack of physician response to EHR messages and unsuccessful direct contact. Among those scheduled (n=78) 70.5% completed the appointment, with no difference between the three groups. Conclusion: B-RST™ can be used effectively in mammography settings to identify high-risk women for cancer genetics referral. Follow-up via EHR appears an acceptable and efficient approach, but additional strategies are needed to facilitate completion of the genetic counseling process.