The Sacrifices of Youth: Historical Feature Films on South Korea’s Longue Durée
IF 0.3
4区 社会学
0 ASIAN STUDIES
Kyung Moon Hwang
{"title":"The Sacrifices of Youth: Historical Feature Films on South Korea’s Longue Durée","authors":"Kyung Moon Hwang","doi":"10.21866/ESJEAS.2016.16.2.003","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Sungkyun Journal of East Asian Studies Vol.16 No.2 © 2016 Academy of East Asian Studies. 179-196 DOI: 10.21866/esjeas.2016.16.2.003 email of the author: khwang3@gmail.com 179 Feature films set in the past seem to have hit a peak recently in South Korean cinema, if judged by the box office. The two most popular releases on record are historical films appearing in the past few years (“The Admiral” and “Ode to My Father”), and despite the consistent lament by social and cultural elders of the citizenry’s lack of historical understanding, the popularity of historical films undoubtedly reflects the appeal of national history, at least among the movie-going public. But this is not a new phenomenon, as some of the best films in the very sophisticated South Korean film industry over the past two decades not only have been set in the past, but have provided definitive commentaries on the past and its connection to the present. And while not all of these movies hit box office gold, they have offered powerful reflections and interpretations of, and perhaps even interventions in, contentious debates surrounding the country’s turbulent history, which have reflected major political and social divisions as well. In this paper I wish to demonstrate how these historical films comment on meta-narratives of South Korea’s past. I find that, on the whole, these films have featured young main characters as symbols and vehicles of major historical This paper demonstrates how some South Korean historical films over the past two decades comment on critical meta-narratives of the country’s past, and in turn reflect the powerful presence of this history in South Korea today. Due to the directors’ age as well as to the relaxing of film censorship in the 1990s, among other factors, these films have generally represented the liberal historical views that came to prevail in South Korea following democratization in the late 1980s. But the filmic expressions of this general understanding emphasize a variety of driving forces and elements in the nation’s modern history. Beginning with an analysis of the recent hit, “Ode to My Father,” this study examines approximately a dozen films as they illuminate three major historical themes: South Korea’s turbulent origins; life under the rule of Park Chung Hee; and the struggle to overcome the burdens of the past. It finds that, on the whole, these films have featured young protagonists as symbols and vehicles of crucial historical moments, which results in a somewhat unbalanced, but nevertheless diverse range of historical perspectives.","PeriodicalId":41529,"journal":{"name":"Sungkyun Journal of East Asian Studies","volume":"16 1","pages":"179-196"},"PeriodicalIF":0.3000,"publicationDate":"2016-10-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"1","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Sungkyun Journal of East Asian Studies","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.21866/ESJEAS.2016.16.2.003","RegionNum":4,"RegionCategory":"社会学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"0","JCRName":"ASIAN STUDIES","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 1
Abstract
Sungkyun Journal of East Asian Studies Vol.16 No.2 © 2016 Academy of East Asian Studies. 179-196 DOI: 10.21866/esjeas.2016.16.2.003 email of the author: khwang3@gmail.com 179 Feature films set in the past seem to have hit a peak recently in South Korean cinema, if judged by the box office. The two most popular releases on record are historical films appearing in the past few years (“The Admiral” and “Ode to My Father”), and despite the consistent lament by social and cultural elders of the citizenry’s lack of historical understanding, the popularity of historical films undoubtedly reflects the appeal of national history, at least among the movie-going public. But this is not a new phenomenon, as some of the best films in the very sophisticated South Korean film industry over the past two decades not only have been set in the past, but have provided definitive commentaries on the past and its connection to the present. And while not all of these movies hit box office gold, they have offered powerful reflections and interpretations of, and perhaps even interventions in, contentious debates surrounding the country’s turbulent history, which have reflected major political and social divisions as well. In this paper I wish to demonstrate how these historical films comment on meta-narratives of South Korea’s past. I find that, on the whole, these films have featured young main characters as symbols and vehicles of major historical This paper demonstrates how some South Korean historical films over the past two decades comment on critical meta-narratives of the country’s past, and in turn reflect the powerful presence of this history in South Korea today. Due to the directors’ age as well as to the relaxing of film censorship in the 1990s, among other factors, these films have generally represented the liberal historical views that came to prevail in South Korea following democratization in the late 1980s. But the filmic expressions of this general understanding emphasize a variety of driving forces and elements in the nation’s modern history. Beginning with an analysis of the recent hit, “Ode to My Father,” this study examines approximately a dozen films as they illuminate three major historical themes: South Korea’s turbulent origins; life under the rule of Park Chung Hee; and the struggle to overcome the burdens of the past. It finds that, on the whole, these films have featured young protagonists as symbols and vehicles of crucial historical moments, which results in a somewhat unbalanced, but nevertheless diverse range of historical perspectives.
青春的牺牲:关于韩国朗格·杜尔杰的历史故事片
Sungkyun Journal of East Asian Studies Vol.16 No.2©2016东亚研究学院。179-196 DOI: 10.21866/esjeas.2016.16.2.003作者邮箱:khwang3@gmail.com 179如果从票房来看,以过去为背景的故事片最近在韩国电影中似乎达到了顶峰。有记录以来最受欢迎的两部电影是过去几年出现的历史电影(《海军上将》和《献给父亲的颂歌》),尽管社会和文化长者一直在哀叹公民缺乏对历史的理解,但历史电影的流行无疑反映了国家历史的吸引力,至少在看电影的公众中是这样。但这并不是一个新现象,因为在过去二十年中,在非常成熟的韩国电影工业中,一些最好的电影不仅以过去为背景,而且对过去及其与现在的联系提供了明确的评论。虽然并非所有这些电影都能获得票房收入,但它们对围绕这个国家动荡历史的争议性辩论提供了有力的反思和解读,甚至可能是介入,这些争论也反映了主要的政治和社会分歧。在本文中,我希望展示这些历史电影是如何评论韩国过去的元叙事的。我发现,总的来说,这些电影以年轻的主角作为主要历史的象征和载体。本文展示了过去二十年来一些韩国历史电影是如何评论这个国家过去的批判性元叙事的,反过来又反映了这段历史在今天的韩国的强大存在。由于导演的年龄以及20世纪90年代电影审查制度的放松,以及其他因素,这些电影通常代表了20世纪80年代末民主化后在韩国盛行的自由主义历史观。但这种总体认识的电影表现强调的是国家近代史中的各种动力和因素。本研究从分析最近的热门电影《父亲颂》(Ode to My Father)开始,考察了大约12部电影,因为它们阐明了三个主要的历史主题:韩国动荡的起源;朴正熙统治下的生活;以及克服过去负担的斗争。研究发现,总体而言,这些电影将年轻主角作为关键历史时刻的象征和载体,这导致了历史视角的不平衡,但却多样化。
本文章由计算机程序翻译,如有差异,请以英文原文为准。