Faulty Residential Circuit Breakers—A Persistent Fire Safety Problem

Abstract

Circuit breakers for residential branch circuits must trip at or below 135% of rated current. A breaker that fails that requirement is defective. Samples of two brands, purchased from retail sources, are tested for that basic calibration. Both brands were tested 4 years ago. Previous samples of one brand were 50% defective, and new samples manufactured in 2021 are 28% defective. The second brand, previously defect-free, is again defect-free. The test results, past and present, imply that some manufacturers are calibrating breakers to trip too close to the allowable upper current limit, and are checking calibration by testing at higher current. The standard calibration test at 200% of rated current is shown to be incapable of indicating whether or not a breaker will trip properly, as required by the applicable standard, at 135% of rated current. A third brand tested came on the market recently. Its thermal-magnetic breakers trip correctly, but the brand's hydraulic-magnetic breakers are erratic, with 38% of the samples malfunctioning. The malfunctions are attributed to thermal distortion that causes mechanical binding of the triggering mechanism. Some breaker brands with a high defect rate have been in the distribution chain for many years and are permanently installed in homes. The increased risk of fire and injury for the occupants of these dwellings is significant. The long-standing history of this problem and the fire safety consequences are discussed.