Healthy arteries are continuously subjected to diverse mechanical stimuli and adapt in order to maintain a mechanical homeostasis which is characterized by a uniform distribution of wall stresses. However, aging may compromise the homeostatic microenvironment within arteries. Structural heterogeneity has been suggested as a potential microstructural mechanism that could lead to homogeneous stress distribution across the arterial wall. Our previous study on the unfolding and stretching of the elastic lamellae revealed the underlying microstructural mechanism for equalizing the circumferential stresses through wall; inner elastic layers are wavier and unfold more than the outer layers which helps to evenly distribute lamellar stretching (Yu et al., 2018). In this study, we investigated the effect of aging on lamellar deformation and its implications for tissue homeostasis. Common carotid arteries from aged mice were imaged under a multi-photon microscope while subjected to biaxial extension and inflation at five different pressures ranging from 0 up to 120 mmHg. Lamellar unfolding during pressurization was then determined from the reconstructed cross-sectional images of elastic lamellae. Tissue-level circumferential stretch was combined with the lamellar unfolding to calculate lamellar stretching. Our results revealed that the straightness gradient of aged elastic lamellae is similar to the young ones. However, during pressurization, the inner elastic lamella of the aged mice unfolded significantly more than the inner layer in young arteries. An important finding of our study is the uneven increase in inter-lamellar space which contributed to a nonuniform stretching of the elastic lamellae of aged mice arteries, elevated stress gradient, and a shifting of the load-bearing component to adventitia. Our results shed light into the complex microstructural mechanisms that take place in aging and adversely affect arterial mechanical behavior and homeostasis.