An investigation of the effects of topical sunscreen protection products under natural weather conditions on intrinsic color stability in maxillofacial silicones.

Abstract

Aim: The relatively short lifespan of maxillofacial prostheses (ranging from 3-24 months) is mostly a result of colour instability of silicone elastomers caused by ultraviolet (UV) radiation, requiring frequent remakes. An improvement in colour preservation could result in fewer remakes, thus saving time and money for both clinician and patient. In the quest for a suitable colour protection method, sunscreen protection products were considered; the most recent study on this subject was carried out in 1994, albeit using a low protection factor. The aim of this research was to determine if there is value in using topical sun protection products on extraoral silicone prostheses to prevent colour degradation.

Settings and design: This was an in vitro quantitative study.

Materials and methods: Three commercially available sunscreen products were studied, Riemann P20, Boots Soltan, and Garnier Ambre Solaire all with a sun protection factor of 50. A total of 144 silicone elastomer samples were produced using a Caucasian (light) shade 1.2 (n = 72) and dark skin shade 3.2 (n = 72) from the Technovent Ltd. Reality Shade range. Each shade group (n = 72) was divided into three groups to be subjected to outdoor weathering (n = 24), indoor (n = 24), and dark storage (n = 24). Within each environmental group, samples were divided into groups of six samples (n = 6) to receive the three sunscreens plus a control group with no sunscreen. The CIEL* a* b* formula was used to obtain the color measurements.

Statistical analysis used: One way ANOVA test and Tukey's HSD test for multiple comparisons was used to analyse the data.

Results: The ΔE values had changed for all samples throughout the aging process.

Conclusion: Soltan showed promising results in protecting the dark-shaded samples in the outdoor environment only.