Reactive Oxygen and Sulfur Species: Partners in Crime

Abstract

The emergence of complexity requires cooperation, yet selection typically favors defectors that do not cooperate. Such evolutionary conflict can be alleviated by a variety of mechanisms, allowing complexity to emerge. Chemiosmosis is one such mechanism. In syntrophic relationships, the chemiosmotic partner benefits simply from exporting products. Failure to do this can result in highly reduced electron carriers and detrimental amounts of reactive oxygen species. Nevertheless, the role of this mechanism in the history of life (e.g., the origin of eukaryotes from prokaryotes) seems questionable because of much lower atmospheric levels of oxygen and a largely anaerobic ocean. In this context, the role of sulfur should be considered. The last eukaryotic common ancestor (LECA) was a facultative aerobe. Under anaerobic conditions, LECA likely carried out various forms of anaerobic metabolism. For instance, malate dismutation, in which malate is both oxidized and reduced, allows re-oxidizing NADH. The terminal electron acceptor, fumarate, forms succinate when reduced. When oxygen is present, an excess of succinate can lead to reverse electron flow, forming high levels of reactive oxygen species. Under anaerobic conditions, reactive sulfur species may have formed. Eliminating end products may thus have had a selective advantage even under the low atmospheric oxygen levels of the Proterozoic eon.