Maarit Jaakkola, K. Amakoh, Urban Larssen, M. Forsman
{"title":"Book Reviews","authors":"Maarit Jaakkola, K. Amakoh, Urban Larssen, M. Forsman","doi":"10.2478/nor-2020-0008","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"From the title of the book, one might conclude that the author portrays only a part of the world. Making this kind of conclusion is hasty and can only be dispelled after a complete and attentive read of the 217 pages of scholarly discussions. Herman Wasserman’s Media, Geopolitics, and Power: A View from the Global South does not only present over two decades of the South African media trajectory from the apartheid to post-apartheid eras, it also provides a unique and rich connection between the changes in the South African context and the shifts experienced in the global landscape (with focus on geopolitics and discussions in the media). Most especially, Wasserman makes a genuine case for why what happens in the media landscape within the Global South is of importance to the global media landscape discourse. Specifically, Wasserman notes that the developments in the Global South “can be instructive as to the directions in which global media might be moving” (p. 49). As such, the inclusion of non-Western perspectives in the global discourse must not be “superficial and patronising gestures” (p. 88) as the case has always been. Media, Geopolitics, and Power: A View from the Global South draws upon a decade of Wasserman’s scholarly contributions to the media landscape discourse. The eight-chapter book consists of the transitions witnessed in the South African media landscape from apartheid to democracy, the contestations experienced in the South African media and how it fits in the “global debates about media norms and values and the notion of a global crisis in journalism” (p. 79), and the position of South African media within the shifts in global geopolitics (with special focus on South Africa’s membership of the BRICS and its close relationship with China). In the first chapter of the book, “From Apartheid to a new democracy”, Wasserman provides a descriptive overview of four areas of shift witnessed in the South African media: ownership and editorial composition, attempts to diversify the public sphere, normative and regulatory frameworks, and conceptions of the relationship between media and political power. As captured by Wasserman, most of the transitions in media ownership happened in the print media. These transitions aimed at the racial composition of media ownership NORDICOM REVIEW","PeriodicalId":45517,"journal":{"name":"Nordicom Review","volume":"41 1","pages":"101 - 108"},"PeriodicalIF":1.7000,"publicationDate":"2020-01-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Nordicom Review","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.2478/nor-2020-0008","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q2","JCRName":"COMMUNICATION","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
From the title of the book, one might conclude that the author portrays only a part of the world. Making this kind of conclusion is hasty and can only be dispelled after a complete and attentive read of the 217 pages of scholarly discussions. Herman Wasserman’s Media, Geopolitics, and Power: A View from the Global South does not only present over two decades of the South African media trajectory from the apartheid to post-apartheid eras, it also provides a unique and rich connection between the changes in the South African context and the shifts experienced in the global landscape (with focus on geopolitics and discussions in the media). Most especially, Wasserman makes a genuine case for why what happens in the media landscape within the Global South is of importance to the global media landscape discourse. Specifically, Wasserman notes that the developments in the Global South “can be instructive as to the directions in which global media might be moving” (p. 49). As such, the inclusion of non-Western perspectives in the global discourse must not be “superficial and patronising gestures” (p. 88) as the case has always been. Media, Geopolitics, and Power: A View from the Global South draws upon a decade of Wasserman’s scholarly contributions to the media landscape discourse. The eight-chapter book consists of the transitions witnessed in the South African media landscape from apartheid to democracy, the contestations experienced in the South African media and how it fits in the “global debates about media norms and values and the notion of a global crisis in journalism” (p. 79), and the position of South African media within the shifts in global geopolitics (with special focus on South Africa’s membership of the BRICS and its close relationship with China). In the first chapter of the book, “From Apartheid to a new democracy”, Wasserman provides a descriptive overview of four areas of shift witnessed in the South African media: ownership and editorial composition, attempts to diversify the public sphere, normative and regulatory frameworks, and conceptions of the relationship between media and political power. As captured by Wasserman, most of the transitions in media ownership happened in the print media. These transitions aimed at the racial composition of media ownership NORDICOM REVIEW
从书名可以得出结论,作者只描绘了世界的一部分。得出这样的结论是草率的,只有在完整而仔细地阅读217页的学术讨论之后才能消除。赫尔曼·沃瑟曼(Herman Wasserman)的《媒体、地缘政治和权力:全球南方的观点》(Media,Geopolitics,and Power:A View from the Global South)不仅展示了20多年来南非媒体从种族隔离时代到后种族隔离时代的轨迹,它还提供了南非背景变化与全球格局变化之间独特而丰富的联系(重点关注地缘政治和媒体讨论)。尤其是,Wasserman提出了一个真实的理由,说明为什么全球南方媒体格局中发生的事情对全球媒体格局话语至关重要。具体而言,Wasserman指出,全球南方的事态发展“对全球媒体可能的发展方向具有指导意义”(第49页)。因此,将非西方观点纳入全球话语绝不能像往常一样是“肤浅和屈尊俯就的姿态”(第88页)。媒体、地缘政治和权力:来自全球南方的观点借鉴了Wasserman十年来对媒体景观话语的学术贡献。这本由八章组成的书包括南非媒体格局从种族隔离到民主的转变,南非媒体经历的争论,以及它如何融入“关于媒体规范和价值观以及全球新闻危机概念的全球辩论”(第79页),以及南非媒体在全球地缘政治变化中的地位(特别关注南非加入金砖国家及其与中国的密切关系)。在本书的第一章“从种族隔离到新民主”中,Wasserman对南非媒体的四个转变领域进行了描述性概述:所有权和编辑构成、公共领域多元化的尝试、规范和监管框架,以及媒体与政治权力之间关系的概念。正如Wasserman所捕捉到的,媒体所有权的大部分转变都发生在印刷媒体上。这些转变针对媒体所有权的种族构成