John C. Ayers, Gregory George, David Fry, Laura Benneyworth, Carol Wilson, Leslie Auerbach, Kushal Roy, Md. Rezaul Karim, Farjana Akter, Steven Goodbred
{"title":"Salinization and arsenic contamination of surface water in southwest Bangladesh","authors":"John C. Ayers, Gregory George, David Fry, Laura Benneyworth, Carol Wilson, Leslie Auerbach, Kushal Roy, Md. Rezaul Karim, Farjana Akter, Steven Goodbred","doi":"10.1186/s12932-017-0042-3","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"<p>To identify the causes of salinization and arsenic contamination of surface water on an embanked island (i.e., polder) in the tidal delta plain of SW Bangladesh we collected and analyzed water samples in the dry (May) and wet (October) seasons in 2012–2013. Samples were collected from rice paddies (wet season), saltwater ponds used for brine shrimp aquaculture (dry season), freshwater ponds and tidal channels (both wet and dry season), and rainwater collectors. Continuous measurements of salinity from March 2012 to February 2013 show that tidal channel water increases from ~0.15 ppt in the wet season up to ~20 ppt in the dry season. On the polder, surface water exceeds the World Health Organization drinking water guideline of 10?μg As/L in 78% of shrimp ponds and 27% of rice paddies, raising concerns that produced shrimp and rice could have unsafe levels of As. Drinking water sources also often have unsafe As levels, with 83% of tubewell and 43% of freshwater pond samples having >10?μg As/L. Water compositions and field observations are consistent with shrimp pond water being sourced from tidal channels during the dry season, rather than the locally saline groundwater from tubewells. Irrigation water for rice paddies is also obtained from the tidal channels, but during the wet season when surface waters are fresh. Salts become concentrated in irrigation water through evaporation, with average salinity increasing from 0.43 ppt in the tidal channel source to 0.91 ppt in the rice paddies. Our observations suggest that the practice of seasonally alternating rice and shrimp farming in a field has a negligible effect on rice paddy water salinity. Also, shrimp ponds do not significantly affect the salinity of adjacent surface water bodies or subjacent groundwater because impermeable shallow surface deposits of silt and clay mostly isolate surface water bodies from each other and from the shallow groundwater aquifer. Bivariate plots of conservative element concentrations show that all surface water types lie on mixing lines between dry season tidal channel water and rainwater, i.e., all are related by varying degrees of salinization. High As concentrations in dry season tidal channel water and shrimp ponds likely result from groundwater exfiltration and upstream irrigation in the dry season. Arsenic is transferred from tidal channels to rice paddies through irrigation. Including groundwater samples from the same area (Ayers et al. in Geochem Trans 17:1–22, 2016), principal components analysis and correlation analysis reveal that salinization explains most variation in surface water compositions, whereas progressive reduction of buried surface water by dissolved organic carbon is responsible for the nonconservative behavior of S, Fe, and As and changes in Eh and alkalinity of groundwater.</p>","PeriodicalId":12694,"journal":{"name":"Geochemical Transactions","volume":"18 1","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":0.9000,"publicationDate":"2017-09-11","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"https://sci-hub-pdf.com/10.1186/s12932-017-0042-3","citationCount":"34","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Geochemical Transactions","FirstCategoryId":"89","ListUrlMain":"https://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s12932-017-0042-3","RegionNum":4,"RegionCategory":"地球科学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q4","JCRName":"GEOCHEMISTRY & GEOPHYSICS","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 34
Abstract
To identify the causes of salinization and arsenic contamination of surface water on an embanked island (i.e., polder) in the tidal delta plain of SW Bangladesh we collected and analyzed water samples in the dry (May) and wet (October) seasons in 2012–2013. Samples were collected from rice paddies (wet season), saltwater ponds used for brine shrimp aquaculture (dry season), freshwater ponds and tidal channels (both wet and dry season), and rainwater collectors. Continuous measurements of salinity from March 2012 to February 2013 show that tidal channel water increases from ~0.15 ppt in the wet season up to ~20 ppt in the dry season. On the polder, surface water exceeds the World Health Organization drinking water guideline of 10?μg As/L in 78% of shrimp ponds and 27% of rice paddies, raising concerns that produced shrimp and rice could have unsafe levels of As. Drinking water sources also often have unsafe As levels, with 83% of tubewell and 43% of freshwater pond samples having >10?μg As/L. Water compositions and field observations are consistent with shrimp pond water being sourced from tidal channels during the dry season, rather than the locally saline groundwater from tubewells. Irrigation water for rice paddies is also obtained from the tidal channels, but during the wet season when surface waters are fresh. Salts become concentrated in irrigation water through evaporation, with average salinity increasing from 0.43 ppt in the tidal channel source to 0.91 ppt in the rice paddies. Our observations suggest that the practice of seasonally alternating rice and shrimp farming in a field has a negligible effect on rice paddy water salinity. Also, shrimp ponds do not significantly affect the salinity of adjacent surface water bodies or subjacent groundwater because impermeable shallow surface deposits of silt and clay mostly isolate surface water bodies from each other and from the shallow groundwater aquifer. Bivariate plots of conservative element concentrations show that all surface water types lie on mixing lines between dry season tidal channel water and rainwater, i.e., all are related by varying degrees of salinization. High As concentrations in dry season tidal channel water and shrimp ponds likely result from groundwater exfiltration and upstream irrigation in the dry season. Arsenic is transferred from tidal channels to rice paddies through irrigation. Including groundwater samples from the same area (Ayers et al. in Geochem Trans 17:1–22, 2016), principal components analysis and correlation analysis reveal that salinization explains most variation in surface water compositions, whereas progressive reduction of buried surface water by dissolved organic carbon is responsible for the nonconservative behavior of S, Fe, and As and changes in Eh and alkalinity of groundwater.
为了确定孟加拉国西南部潮汐三角洲平原一个堤岸岛屿(即圩田)地表水盐碱化和砷污染的原因,我们收集并分析了2012-2013年干季节(5月)和湿季节(10月)的水样。从稻田(雨季)、用于卤虾养殖的咸水池塘(旱季)、淡水池塘和潮汐通道(干湿两季)以及雨水收集处收集样本。2012年3月至2013年2月的盐度连续测量表明,潮道水量从雨季的~0.15 ppt增加到旱季的~20 ppt。在圩田上,地表水超过了世界卫生组织饮用水标准的10?在78%的虾池和27%的稻田中检测到砷含量,这引起了人们对虾和大米砷含量可能不安全的担忧。饮用水源的砷含量也经常不安全,83%的管井和43%的淡水池塘样本的砷含量为10?μg / L。水的组成和实地观测结果表明,虾池的水是在旱季从潮汐通道中获取的,而不是从管井中获取的当地含盐地下水。稻田的灌溉用水也从潮汐通道获得,但在雨季,地表水是新鲜的。盐类通过蒸发在灌溉水中集中,平均盐度从潮道源的0.43 ppt增加到稻田的0.91 ppt。我们的观察表明,稻田和虾的季节性交替养殖对稻田水盐度的影响可以忽略不计。此外,对虾池对邻近地表水体或地下水的盐度没有显著影响,因为不透水的浅层泥沙和粘土沉积物主要将地表水体彼此隔离,并与浅层地下水含水层隔离。保守元素浓度双变量图表明,所有地表水类型均位于旱季潮道水与雨水的混合线上,即所有地表水类型都与不同程度的盐碱化有关。旱季潮道水和虾塘的高砷浓度可能是由于地下水渗漏和旱季上游灌溉造成的。砷通过灌溉从潮汐通道转移到稻田。包括来自同一地区的地下水样本(Ayers et al. in Geochem Trans 17:1-22, 2016),主成分分析和相关分析表明,盐碱化解释了地表水成分的大部分变化,而溶解有机碳逐渐减少地表水的S, Fe和As的非保守行为以及地下水Eh和碱度的变化。
期刊介绍:
Geochemical Transactions publishes high-quality research in all areas of chemistry as it relates to materials and processes occurring in terrestrial and extraterrestrial systems.