As RP em rede e o envolvimento dialógico em plataformas feministas (“A Coletiva” e “INMUNE”) Networked PR and dialogical engagement on feminist platforms (“A Coletiva” and “INMUNE”)
{"title":"As RP em rede e o envolvimento dialógico em plataformas feministas (“A Coletiva” e “INMUNE”) Networked PR and dialogical engagement on feminist platforms (“A Coletiva” and “INMUNE”)","authors":"Sónia de Sá","doi":"10.5783/REVRRPP.V10I20.660","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Resumo Os movimentos feministas afirmam-se, na atualidade, pela capacidade de envolvimento e agregacao de ativistas e de publico identificado com a causa feminista, que tem em comum tanto a luta pelos direitos das mulheres como os espacos onde criam existencia e atribuem dimensao a essa luta: as redes sociais digitais. O proposito do presente artigo e perceber as estrategias comunicacionais que estao na base desta agregacao e partilha de sentido quando a materia e o feminismo e a sua estreita ligacao com a luta pela igualdade de genero, o fim da violencia de genero ou a erradicacao do racismo. Assim, partindo do modelo proposto por Lane e Kent (2018) – Dialogic Engagement Interaction – este estudo analisa o envolvimento dialogico nas plataformas feministas portuguesas A Coletiva e o INMUNE – Instituto da Mulher Negra de Portugal. Da analise resulta, contudo, a constatacao de um baixo nivel de envolvimento dialogico entre as organizacoes e os seus publicos e, consequentemente, uma reduzida forca coletiva para travar os clusters de odio online com protagonismo crescente e com modus operandi altamente tecnologicos e eficazes (Johnson et al. , 2019). Palavras-chave : RP em rede, envolvimento dialogico, plataformas feministas Abstract Feminist movements are currently asserting themselves by the capacity of involvement and aggregation of activists and the public identified with the feminist cause, who have in common both the struggle for women's rights and the spaces where they create existence and attribute dimension to that struggle: digital social networks. The purpose of this article is to understand the communication strategies, supported by dialogue, that underlie this aggregation and sharing of meaning when it comes to feminism and its close connection with the fight for gender equality, the end of gender violence or the eradication of racism. Based on the theoretical review on networked PR (Grunig, 2009; Kent, 2017), networked dialogue (Theunissen & Wan Noordin, 2011; Smith & Taylor, 2017; and networked feminism (Fullagar, Parry and Johnson, 2019; Keller, Mendes & Ringrose, 2018; Arauna, Willem & Tortajada, 2019; Yang, Uysal & Taylor, 2017), we applied content analysis (Bardin, 2006) to publications and digital interactions on two Portuguese feminist platforms. Thus, in an adaptation of the model proposed by Lane and Kent (2018) - Dialogic Engagement Interaction - this exploratory study analyzes the dialogical involvement of Coletiva and INMUNE - Instituto da Mulher Negra de Portugal. The analysis results, however, shows a low level of dialogical involvement between organizations and their audiences and, consequently, a reduced collective force to stop online hate clusters with increasing protagonism and with highly technological and effective modus operandi . Thus, the outcomes indicate that the two platforms analyzed do not apply communication strategies through dialogue, limiting exchanges between the organization and the public to the classic top-down communication option, summarizing the practice of dialogical involvement in social digital media to the publication unidirectional content and openness to comments and other reactions. As for the hypotheses raised, only one of them was validated, taking into account that 1) there was no significant dialogical involvement in the content analysis of the two feminist platforms, and 2) although we were unable to verify in the content analysis of the two feminist platforms, the theoretical review validated the idea that online anti-feminist and hate clusters can be fought by online anti-feminist and anti-hate clusters with the same effectiveness in spreading messages as the former. And here, the networked PR must take the strategic and tactical leadership of the action. This work also proposes a model for the analysis of dialogical involvement in digital social networks based on the broader initial proposal of Lane and Kent (2018). The model we propose comprises six categories: 1) existence of comment(s), sharing(s) and / or emoji(s); 2) existence of comment(s) and answer(s); 3) existence of dialogue (with the five dialogical principles: mutuality, propinquity, empathy, risk and commitment; see in Kent, 2017).; 4) existence of freedom to choose the theme and the dialogical flow (when both parts – public and organization – are given freedom to choose the topic and flow of dialogue); 5) without agenda or manipulation (when there is no intention to put issues on the agenda, essentially, those that indicate manipulation); and 6) rhetorical (when a persuasion strategy is applied by both parts participating in the dialogue). Keywords: networked PR, dialogical involvement, feminist platforms","PeriodicalId":42959,"journal":{"name":"Revista Internacional de Relaciones Publicas","volume":"10 1","pages":"05-26"},"PeriodicalIF":0.3000,"publicationDate":"2020-12-19","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Revista Internacional de Relaciones Publicas","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.5783/REVRRPP.V10I20.660","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q4","JCRName":"COMMUNICATION","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
Resumo Os movimentos feministas afirmam-se, na atualidade, pela capacidade de envolvimento e agregacao de ativistas e de publico identificado com a causa feminista, que tem em comum tanto a luta pelos direitos das mulheres como os espacos onde criam existencia e atribuem dimensao a essa luta: as redes sociais digitais. O proposito do presente artigo e perceber as estrategias comunicacionais que estao na base desta agregacao e partilha de sentido quando a materia e o feminismo e a sua estreita ligacao com a luta pela igualdade de genero, o fim da violencia de genero ou a erradicacao do racismo. Assim, partindo do modelo proposto por Lane e Kent (2018) – Dialogic Engagement Interaction – este estudo analisa o envolvimento dialogico nas plataformas feministas portuguesas A Coletiva e o INMUNE – Instituto da Mulher Negra de Portugal. Da analise resulta, contudo, a constatacao de um baixo nivel de envolvimento dialogico entre as organizacoes e os seus publicos e, consequentemente, uma reduzida forca coletiva para travar os clusters de odio online com protagonismo crescente e com modus operandi altamente tecnologicos e eficazes (Johnson et al. , 2019). Palavras-chave : RP em rede, envolvimento dialogico, plataformas feministas Abstract Feminist movements are currently asserting themselves by the capacity of involvement and aggregation of activists and the public identified with the feminist cause, who have in common both the struggle for women's rights and the spaces where they create existence and attribute dimension to that struggle: digital social networks. The purpose of this article is to understand the communication strategies, supported by dialogue, that underlie this aggregation and sharing of meaning when it comes to feminism and its close connection with the fight for gender equality, the end of gender violence or the eradication of racism. Based on the theoretical review on networked PR (Grunig, 2009; Kent, 2017), networked dialogue (Theunissen & Wan Noordin, 2011; Smith & Taylor, 2017; and networked feminism (Fullagar, Parry and Johnson, 2019; Keller, Mendes & Ringrose, 2018; Arauna, Willem & Tortajada, 2019; Yang, Uysal & Taylor, 2017), we applied content analysis (Bardin, 2006) to publications and digital interactions on two Portuguese feminist platforms. Thus, in an adaptation of the model proposed by Lane and Kent (2018) - Dialogic Engagement Interaction - this exploratory study analyzes the dialogical involvement of Coletiva and INMUNE - Instituto da Mulher Negra de Portugal. The analysis results, however, shows a low level of dialogical involvement between organizations and their audiences and, consequently, a reduced collective force to stop online hate clusters with increasing protagonism and with highly technological and effective modus operandi . Thus, the outcomes indicate that the two platforms analyzed do not apply communication strategies through dialogue, limiting exchanges between the organization and the public to the classic top-down communication option, summarizing the practice of dialogical involvement in social digital media to the publication unidirectional content and openness to comments and other reactions. As for the hypotheses raised, only one of them was validated, taking into account that 1) there was no significant dialogical involvement in the content analysis of the two feminist platforms, and 2) although we were unable to verify in the content analysis of the two feminist platforms, the theoretical review validated the idea that online anti-feminist and hate clusters can be fought by online anti-feminist and anti-hate clusters with the same effectiveness in spreading messages as the former. And here, the networked PR must take the strategic and tactical leadership of the action. This work also proposes a model for the analysis of dialogical involvement in digital social networks based on the broader initial proposal of Lane and Kent (2018). The model we propose comprises six categories: 1) existence of comment(s), sharing(s) and / or emoji(s); 2) existence of comment(s) and answer(s); 3) existence of dialogue (with the five dialogical principles: mutuality, propinquity, empathy, risk and commitment; see in Kent, 2017).; 4) existence of freedom to choose the theme and the dialogical flow (when both parts – public and organization – are given freedom to choose the topic and flow of dialogue); 5) without agenda or manipulation (when there is no intention to put issues on the agenda, essentially, those that indicate manipulation); and 6) rhetorical (when a persuasion strategy is applied by both parts participating in the dialogue). Keywords: networked PR, dialogical involvement, feminist platforms
女性运动的简历,一个有效的,环境的能力和行动的能力,以及公众对女性运动的认同,这是一个很好的例子:作为数字社会的一部分。我的提议是,让艺术家和艺术家们成为一个沟通的平台,建立一个女性材料的基础,一个普通人、普通人和种族主义者的基础。Assim,partindo do modelo proposeto por Lane e Kent(2018)–对话参与互动–este estudo analisa o envolvimento dialogico nas plataformas feministas Portugues as A Coletiva e o INMUNE–Instituto da Mulher Negra de Portugal。分析结果表明,作为公共组织的一个持续的对话中心,这是一个持续不断的环境,因此,减少了在线通信集群的工作效率(Johnson等人,2019)。Palavras chave:RP em rede,envolvimento dialogico,plataformas feministas抽象女权主义运动目前正通过积极分子和认同女权主义事业的公众的参与和聚集能力来维护自己,她们既有争取妇女权利的斗争,也有创造存在的空间,并将这场斗争的维度归因于数字社交网络。这篇文章的目的是了解在对话的支持下,在女权主义及其与争取性别平等、结束性别暴力或根除种族主义的斗争之间的密切联系时,这种意义的聚合和共享背后的沟通策略。基于网络公关的理论综述(Grunig,2009;Kent,2017)、网络对话(Theunissen&Wan Noordin,2011;Smith和Taylor,2017;以及网络女权主义(Fullagar、Parry和Johnson,2019;Keller、Mendes和Ringrose,2018;Arauna、Willem和Tortajada,2019;Yang、Uysal和Taylor,2019),我们将内容分析(Bardin,2006)应用于两个葡萄牙女权主义平台上的出版物和数字互动。因此,根据Lane和Kent(2018)提出的模型——对话参与互动——本探索性研究分析了Coletiva和INMUNE——葡萄牙黑人研究所的对话参与。然而,分析结果显示,各组织与其受众之间的对话参与程度较低,因此,阻止网络仇恨集群的集体力量减少,其对抗性越来越强,工作方式也非常技术和有效。因此,结果表明,所分析的两个平台没有通过对话应用沟通策略,将组织和公众之间的交流限制在经典的自上而下的沟通选项,将对话参与社交数字媒体的实践总结为发布单向内容和对评论和其他反应的开放。至于提出的假设,只有一个得到了验证,考虑到1)在两个女权主义平台的内容分析中没有显著的对话参与,以及2)尽管我们无法在两个女性主义平台的属性分析中进行验证,这篇理论综述证实了这样一种观点,即网络反女权主义和仇恨集群可以由网络反女权和反仇恨集群来对抗,其传播信息的效果与前者相同。在这里,网络公关必须在行动中发挥战略和战术领导作用。这项工作还基于Lane和Kent(2018)更广泛的初步建议,提出了一个分析数字社交网络中对话参与的模型。我们提出的模型包括六类:1)评论、分享和/或表情符号的存在;2) 是否存在评论和答案;3) 对话的存在(具有五个对话原则:相互性、接近性、同理心、风险和承诺;见Kent,2017)。;4) 存在选择主题和对话流的自由(当公众和组织都有选择对话主题和流的自由时);5) 没有议程或操纵(当无意将问题列入议程时,本质上是那些表明操纵的问题);以及6)修辞(当参与对话的双方都采用说服策略时)。关键词:网络公关、对话参与、女权主义平台