Using Surrogate Equilibrium Constants for Assessing the Energy of Adsorption of Synthetic Organic Substances from Aqueous Phase onto Carbonized Adsorbents
{"title":"Using Surrogate Equilibrium Constants for Assessing the Energy of Adsorption of Synthetic Organic Substances from Aqueous Phase onto Carbonized Adsorbents","authors":"S. K. Smolin, O. V. Zabneva","doi":"10.3103/S1063455X23050107","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"<p>We proposed to evaluate the performance of new adsorption materials in relation to existing commercial products by comparing the values of the standard molar adsorption energy of <span>\\(\\Delta G_{{\\text{a}}}^{^\\circ }\\)</span> of adsorbates. A typical error in the determination of <span>\\(\\Delta G_{{\\text{a}}}^{^\\circ }\\)</span> is due to the incorrect calculation of the adsorption equilibrium constant <i>K</i><sub>e</sub>. It is often calculated in isothermal regions that do not correspond to standard adsorption conditions, or the dimensional constant of the Langmuir model equation <i>K</i><sub>L</sub> is falsely used as a thermodynamic constant. The direct use of the Langmuir constant <i>K</i><sub>L</sub> as an equilibrium constant is a thermodynamically invalid approach; however, due to the simplicity of determining <i>K</i><sub>L</sub>, an estimate of the adsorption energy based on it can become an accessible and useful tool for adsorption studies. In this work, we examined two methods to transform the Langmuir constant into surrogate constants, which, according to formal features, are dimensionless quantities and reflect the conditional energy of adsorption. We selected 16 adsorption systems of activated carbon (F300, KAU, KAU/Fe, Akant) with aqueous solutions of sparingly soluble aromatic compounds of the phenol and aniline series. We compared the adsorption energy values obtained from the Langmuir constant and the thermodynamically verified constant of the partial adsorption isotherm, calculated by the procedure developed by A.M. Koganovskii (the Koganovskii method, KM). The deviations of the adsorption energy values calculated from the Langmuir constant are on average 10–15% compared to the results obtained by the Koganovskii method. To plot the adsorption isotherms of aromatic compounds, a simplified algorithm for calculating <i>K</i><sub>e</sub> according to the KM was proposed and tested (without considering the volume of the adsorption phase and the molar volume of adsorbents). Deviations in energy values were within 5% of the KM results. Thus, the considered simplified methods are easy to implement and accurate enough to estimate the standard adsorption energy; therefore, they can be recommended for the initial assessment of the effectiveness of new adsorption materials.</p>","PeriodicalId":680,"journal":{"name":"Journal of Water Chemistry and Technology","volume":"45 5","pages":"467 - 474"},"PeriodicalIF":0.5000,"publicationDate":"2023-09-21","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Journal of Water Chemistry and Technology","FirstCategoryId":"92","ListUrlMain":"https://link.springer.com/article/10.3103/S1063455X23050107","RegionNum":4,"RegionCategory":"化学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q4","JCRName":"CHEMISTRY, ANALYTICAL","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
We proposed to evaluate the performance of new adsorption materials in relation to existing commercial products by comparing the values of the standard molar adsorption energy of \(\Delta G_{{\text{a}}}^{^\circ }\) of adsorbates. A typical error in the determination of \(\Delta G_{{\text{a}}}^{^\circ }\) is due to the incorrect calculation of the adsorption equilibrium constant Ke. It is often calculated in isothermal regions that do not correspond to standard adsorption conditions, or the dimensional constant of the Langmuir model equation KL is falsely used as a thermodynamic constant. The direct use of the Langmuir constant KL as an equilibrium constant is a thermodynamically invalid approach; however, due to the simplicity of determining KL, an estimate of the adsorption energy based on it can become an accessible and useful tool for adsorption studies. In this work, we examined two methods to transform the Langmuir constant into surrogate constants, which, according to formal features, are dimensionless quantities and reflect the conditional energy of adsorption. We selected 16 adsorption systems of activated carbon (F300, KAU, KAU/Fe, Akant) with aqueous solutions of sparingly soluble aromatic compounds of the phenol and aniline series. We compared the adsorption energy values obtained from the Langmuir constant and the thermodynamically verified constant of the partial adsorption isotherm, calculated by the procedure developed by A.M. Koganovskii (the Koganovskii method, KM). The deviations of the adsorption energy values calculated from the Langmuir constant are on average 10–15% compared to the results obtained by the Koganovskii method. To plot the adsorption isotherms of aromatic compounds, a simplified algorithm for calculating Ke according to the KM was proposed and tested (without considering the volume of the adsorption phase and the molar volume of adsorbents). Deviations in energy values were within 5% of the KM results. Thus, the considered simplified methods are easy to implement and accurate enough to estimate the standard adsorption energy; therefore, they can be recommended for the initial assessment of the effectiveness of new adsorption materials.
期刊介绍:
Journal of Water Chemistry and Technology focuses on water and wastewater treatment, water pollution monitoring, water purification, and similar topics. The journal publishes original scientific theoretical and experimental articles in the following sections: new developments in the science of water; theoretical principles of water treatment and technology; physical chemistry of water treatment processes; analytical water chemistry; analysis of natural and waste waters; water treatment technology and demineralization of water; biological methods of water treatment; and also solicited critical reviews summarizing the latest findings. The journal welcomes manuscripts from all countries in the English or Ukrainian language. All manuscripts are peer-reviewed.