Surgery for colorectal cancer in a low-volume unit: assessment of key issues in the achievement of acceptable clinical results.

Abstract

Background: The maintenance of modern therapeutic principles requires a proper case load to achieve acceptable surgical results. This may obligate administrative reorganization to overcome these problems and to provide an adequate level of cancer surgery.

Aim: To assess the surgical results of patients coming for surgery for colorectal cancer in a low-volume non-academic unit during the past 15 yr.

Methods: 458 consecutive patients referred for surgery between 1988 and 2001 in Kanta-Häme Central Hospital in Finland were analyzed regarding their disease, mode of surgery, and the immediate and long-term result. The data were collected from patient journals and from the National Centre of Statistics and analyzed in two successive periods.

Results: The number of patients with a localized disease (Dukes A + Dukes B) decreased during the followup from 49% to 45%. A curative procedure was achieved in 68% in the first half and in 73% in the second half of the observation period. The immediate mortality was 5% and 2% in the two periods, respectively. The corrected 5-year survival according to the Dukes Classification was 92% (A), 69% (B), 41% (C ), and 6% (D). In curative surgery for rectal cancer, the incidences of local recurrence decreased from 21% to 9% (NS) and the use of permanent colostomy from 59 to 42% (NS).

Conclusions: Acceptable immediate and long-term results in curative surgery for colorectal cancer can be achieved in a low-volume surgical unit. Nevertheless, owing to the low volume, the improvement of the results obligates team-based institutional specialization and careful consideration about the extensiveness of the primary procedure in case of cancer obstruction.