Accounting for recombination rate variation improves inference of barrier loci and reveals the role of both natural and sexual selection in an incipient bird radiation.

Abstract

Examining genomic patterns of differentiation across lineage pairs at different stages of the speciation continuum, in combination with recombination maps, can help disentangle the effects of linked and divergent selection and identify lineage-specific targets of selection that may act as barrier loci during speciation. Here, we apply this framework to genomic data from African and Indian Ocean bird species of the genus Zosterops (Zosteropidae) to identify candidate barrier loci between ecologically, phenotypically, and genetically distinct Reunion gray white-eye (Zosterops borbonicus) parapatric geographic forms. Using analyses that account for recombination rate variation, we show that putative targets of divergent selection are primarily located on the Z chromosome, except in comparisons between geographic forms that differ in their ecologies. Functional annotation revealed that candidate barrier loci between forms with similar environmental niches are associated with genes involved in song formation and immune function, whereas those between forms with different environmental niches are associated with adaptation to altitude, morphology, and song behavior. Our results highlight the combined roles of natural and sexual selection in the evolution of reproductive barriers in this incipient species radiation.