{"title":"Use Real-Time Mortality Alerts to Save Vultures","authors":"Andrea Santangeli","doi":"10.1111/con4.70031","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"<p>Poisoning is the leading threat to vultures and other scavengers worldwide, and its scale has grown alarmingly in the past decades (Plaza et al. <span>2019</span>). From January 2000, nearly 41,000 wildlife deaths from poisoning have been reported in Africa alone, almost half involving threatened vultures (The Endangered Wildlife Trust and the Peregrine Fund <span>n.d</span>.). Strikingly, more than 8000 wildlife mortalities have been reported since 2020 alone, with over 6600 vultures among them. The mass poisoning in Guinea–Bissau in 2020, which killed more than 2000 Critically Endangered hooded vultures (<i>Necrosyrtes monachus</i>; Henriques et al. <span>2020</span>), was followed by many other incidents. These include the recent loss of over 100 vultures in Kruger National Park, South Africa (May 2025; Vulture Conservation Foundation <span>2025</span>). Similar events across South America, Europe, and Asia show that few safe havens remain for these keystone species (Plaza et al. <span>2019</span>). Without urgent, innovative action, we risk losing vultures—and the essential ecosystem services they provide (Santangeli et al. <span>2024</span>). So far, we appear to be losing the battle against the perpetrators of this illicit and indiscriminate practice (Ogada et al. <span>2016</span>; Margalida et al. <span>2019</span>). While education, legislation, and community engagement are essential to addressing the root causes of vulture poisoning, these measures typically yield results only in the medium to long term. What is urgently needed are evidence-based, immediate interventions to reduce mortalities. Rapid response teams capable of decontaminating poisoning sites can save many vultures’ lives (Murn and Botha <span>2018</span>). However, their effectiveness is limited to the few events that are timely detected. Tragically, most incidents go unnoticed or are discovered far too late, as exemplified by the Guinea–Bissau massacre of 2020.</p><p>Rapid advances in biologging offer a powerful tool to combat poisoning and other wildlife crimes. This is particularly operationalized by fitting animals with GPS units and following their movement and behavior, which can eventually indicate the where and when of a specific incidence type under focus. Death detector algorithms in GPS-tracked birds can now send near-live mortality alerts via GSM and/or satellite. Moreover, the falling cost of transmission, driven by newly developed and developing systems, such as ICARUS satellite transmission (to be launched in 2026), makes large-scale deployments feasible, affordable, and reliable, especially in the near future (Kays and Wikelski <span>2023</span>). The ICARUS system will be particularly valuable in areas without GSM coverage, where poisoning events might otherwise go undetected due to phone-based transmission gaps. By enabling satellite-based data transfer, ICARUS can ensure that mortality alerts are received even from the most remote regions. A recent study in Namibia (Curk et al. <span>2025</span>) provided compelling evidence of the cost-effectiveness of using vultures as sentinels. By tagging just 5% of the local population, efficiently identify poisoning events across the landscape and save a significant proportion of vultures. Crucially, the number of birds saved depends on the speed of response. The latter relies on how quickly loggers transmit alerts, and on how fast ground teams can reach the site. With current and emerging technology, alerts can already approach near-real time. Sentinel-based systems can complement existing approaches, such as the use of trained dogs. For example, GPS-tagged sentinel vultures have recently been shown to guide dog-led ground efforts by revealing poisoning events in near real time (Rodríguez-Pérez et al. <span>2025</span>).</p><p>When vultures are poisoned, many other species, including mammals, other raptors, and even domestic animals, also die at these contaminated sites. The ecological and conservation impact of each poisoning incident is thus very wide. Because vultures are very efficient at locating carcasses and are disproportionately affected by poisoning, they have the potential to act as flagship early-warning species. Their movements can reveal poisoning events early enough to save not only other vultures, but the entire community of scavengers. Therefore, the conservation implications of using vultures as sentinels go well beyond this group, and may also allow to uncover illegal activities that would otherwise remain undetected. Moreover, while vultures are effective sentinels, the same real-time detection systems can be adapted for other species, by applying species-specific adjustments to the mortality detection algorithms. Extending this approach to other raptors, carnivores, large herbivores, or other scavengers would improve the detection of poisoning events or other wildlife crimes across ecosystems. For example, wolves, but also albatrosses, have proven effective in detecting possible infringements of environmental regulations (Weimerskirch et al. <span>2020</span>; Mateo-Tomás et al. <span>2023</span>). Jaguars have been used to uncover poisoning incidents (Csermak et al. <span>2023</span>), and herbivores in fighting poaching (de Knegt et al. <span>2021</span>).</p><p>A unified operational platform is urgently needed to translate animal GPS-tracking data into rapid, on-the-ground conservation action. EarthRanger (www.earthranger.com) already provides such an infrastructure, integrating data from most major tag providers and analyzing location and sensor (e.g., accelerometer) data in near real time to generate mortality alerts. These alerts can be delivered through the EarthRanger interface and shared via WhatsApp, SMS, or similar channels with all registered users near the incident, enabling rapid verification and response. Importantly, alerts can be disseminated irrespective of project ownership, allowing sentinel animals to function across their full movements, including dispersal and migration beyond study areas. This approach is already operational and continuously refined by major conservation organizations, including the Vulture Conservation Foundation in Europe and the Endangered Wildlife Trust in Africa, which together manage hundreds of sentinel vultures capable of triggering near-real-time alerts. The coordinated use of a single, interoperable system offers the greatest chance of effectively mitigating mortality events. When a poisoning incident occurs, response time is really crucial to save potentially affected wildlife, as recent evidence clearly demonstrates (Curk et al. <span>2025</span>).</p><p>I encourage ecologists, conservation scientists, and field practitioners working with GPS-tracked wildlife, particularly scavengers and carnivores exposed to poisoning, to use real-time mortality alerts. Doing so would help safeguard vultures, other scavengers, and wildlife more broadly, and enable animal GPS-tracking data to fulfill their full conservation potential. Ultimately, many animal GPS-tracking projects are funded by public (i.e., taxpayer) resources. Thus, governments, public institutions, and conservation NGOs should actively require, support, and, where relevant, use near–real-time alert systems. They should also ensure that the necessary training and operational capacity are in place. These actions would ensure that GPS-tracking technology can genuinely help save vultures and other wildlife from poisoning and other threats.</p><p>The authors declare no conflicts of interest.</p><p>The poisoning incidence data are freely available at: www.africanwildlifepoisoning.org</p>","PeriodicalId":157,"journal":{"name":"Conservation Letters","volume":"19 2","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":5.5000,"publicationDate":"2026-03-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"https://conbio.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1111/con4.70031","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Conservation Letters","FirstCategoryId":"93","ListUrlMain":"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/con4.70031","RegionNum":1,"RegionCategory":"环境科学与生态学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q1","JCRName":"BIODIVERSITY CONSERVATION","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
Poisoning is the leading threat to vultures and other scavengers worldwide, and its scale has grown alarmingly in the past decades (Plaza et al. 2019). From January 2000, nearly 41,000 wildlife deaths from poisoning have been reported in Africa alone, almost half involving threatened vultures (The Endangered Wildlife Trust and the Peregrine Fund n.d.). Strikingly, more than 8000 wildlife mortalities have been reported since 2020 alone, with over 6600 vultures among them. The mass poisoning in Guinea–Bissau in 2020, which killed more than 2000 Critically Endangered hooded vultures (Necrosyrtes monachus; Henriques et al. 2020), was followed by many other incidents. These include the recent loss of over 100 vultures in Kruger National Park, South Africa (May 2025; Vulture Conservation Foundation 2025). Similar events across South America, Europe, and Asia show that few safe havens remain for these keystone species (Plaza et al. 2019). Without urgent, innovative action, we risk losing vultures—and the essential ecosystem services they provide (Santangeli et al. 2024). So far, we appear to be losing the battle against the perpetrators of this illicit and indiscriminate practice (Ogada et al. 2016; Margalida et al. 2019). While education, legislation, and community engagement are essential to addressing the root causes of vulture poisoning, these measures typically yield results only in the medium to long term. What is urgently needed are evidence-based, immediate interventions to reduce mortalities. Rapid response teams capable of decontaminating poisoning sites can save many vultures’ lives (Murn and Botha 2018). However, their effectiveness is limited to the few events that are timely detected. Tragically, most incidents go unnoticed or are discovered far too late, as exemplified by the Guinea–Bissau massacre of 2020.
Rapid advances in biologging offer a powerful tool to combat poisoning and other wildlife crimes. This is particularly operationalized by fitting animals with GPS units and following their movement and behavior, which can eventually indicate the where and when of a specific incidence type under focus. Death detector algorithms in GPS-tracked birds can now send near-live mortality alerts via GSM and/or satellite. Moreover, the falling cost of transmission, driven by newly developed and developing systems, such as ICARUS satellite transmission (to be launched in 2026), makes large-scale deployments feasible, affordable, and reliable, especially in the near future (Kays and Wikelski 2023). The ICARUS system will be particularly valuable in areas without GSM coverage, where poisoning events might otherwise go undetected due to phone-based transmission gaps. By enabling satellite-based data transfer, ICARUS can ensure that mortality alerts are received even from the most remote regions. A recent study in Namibia (Curk et al. 2025) provided compelling evidence of the cost-effectiveness of using vultures as sentinels. By tagging just 5% of the local population, efficiently identify poisoning events across the landscape and save a significant proportion of vultures. Crucially, the number of birds saved depends on the speed of response. The latter relies on how quickly loggers transmit alerts, and on how fast ground teams can reach the site. With current and emerging technology, alerts can already approach near-real time. Sentinel-based systems can complement existing approaches, such as the use of trained dogs. For example, GPS-tagged sentinel vultures have recently been shown to guide dog-led ground efforts by revealing poisoning events in near real time (Rodríguez-Pérez et al. 2025).
When vultures are poisoned, many other species, including mammals, other raptors, and even domestic animals, also die at these contaminated sites. The ecological and conservation impact of each poisoning incident is thus very wide. Because vultures are very efficient at locating carcasses and are disproportionately affected by poisoning, they have the potential to act as flagship early-warning species. Their movements can reveal poisoning events early enough to save not only other vultures, but the entire community of scavengers. Therefore, the conservation implications of using vultures as sentinels go well beyond this group, and may also allow to uncover illegal activities that would otherwise remain undetected. Moreover, while vultures are effective sentinels, the same real-time detection systems can be adapted for other species, by applying species-specific adjustments to the mortality detection algorithms. Extending this approach to other raptors, carnivores, large herbivores, or other scavengers would improve the detection of poisoning events or other wildlife crimes across ecosystems. For example, wolves, but also albatrosses, have proven effective in detecting possible infringements of environmental regulations (Weimerskirch et al. 2020; Mateo-Tomás et al. 2023). Jaguars have been used to uncover poisoning incidents (Csermak et al. 2023), and herbivores in fighting poaching (de Knegt et al. 2021).
A unified operational platform is urgently needed to translate animal GPS-tracking data into rapid, on-the-ground conservation action. EarthRanger (www.earthranger.com) already provides such an infrastructure, integrating data from most major tag providers and analyzing location and sensor (e.g., accelerometer) data in near real time to generate mortality alerts. These alerts can be delivered through the EarthRanger interface and shared via WhatsApp, SMS, or similar channels with all registered users near the incident, enabling rapid verification and response. Importantly, alerts can be disseminated irrespective of project ownership, allowing sentinel animals to function across their full movements, including dispersal and migration beyond study areas. This approach is already operational and continuously refined by major conservation organizations, including the Vulture Conservation Foundation in Europe and the Endangered Wildlife Trust in Africa, which together manage hundreds of sentinel vultures capable of triggering near-real-time alerts. The coordinated use of a single, interoperable system offers the greatest chance of effectively mitigating mortality events. When a poisoning incident occurs, response time is really crucial to save potentially affected wildlife, as recent evidence clearly demonstrates (Curk et al. 2025).
I encourage ecologists, conservation scientists, and field practitioners working with GPS-tracked wildlife, particularly scavengers and carnivores exposed to poisoning, to use real-time mortality alerts. Doing so would help safeguard vultures, other scavengers, and wildlife more broadly, and enable animal GPS-tracking data to fulfill their full conservation potential. Ultimately, many animal GPS-tracking projects are funded by public (i.e., taxpayer) resources. Thus, governments, public institutions, and conservation NGOs should actively require, support, and, where relevant, use near–real-time alert systems. They should also ensure that the necessary training and operational capacity are in place. These actions would ensure that GPS-tracking technology can genuinely help save vultures and other wildlife from poisoning and other threats.
The authors declare no conflicts of interest.
The poisoning incidence data are freely available at: www.africanwildlifepoisoning.org
中毒是全球秃鹫和其他食腐动物的主要威胁,在过去的几十年里,其规模惊人地增长(Plaza et al. 2019)。从2000年1月起,仅在非洲就有近41,000只野生动物死于中毒,其中几乎一半涉及受威胁的秃鹫(濒危野生动物信托基金和游隼基金)。引人注目的是,仅自2020年以来,就报告了8000多起野生动物死亡事件,其中有6600多只秃鹫。2020年几内亚比绍的大规模中毒事件导致2000多只极度濒危的连帽秃鹰(necrosytes monachus; Henriques et al. 2020)死亡,随后发生了许多其他事件。其中包括最近在南非克鲁格国家公园损失了100多只秃鹫(2025年5月;秃鹫保护基金会2025年)。南美洲、欧洲和亚洲的类似事件表明,这些关键物种几乎没有安全的避风港(Plaza et al. 2019)。如果不采取紧急、创新的行动,我们就有可能失去秃鹫——以及它们提供的基本生态系统服务(Santangeli et al. 2024)。到目前为止,我们似乎在与这种非法和不分青红皂白的行为的肇事者的战斗中失利(Ogada et al. 2016; Margalida et al. 2019)。虽然教育、立法和社区参与对于解决秃鹫中毒的根本原因至关重要,但这些措施通常只能在中长期内产生效果。迫切需要的是以证据为基础的立即干预措施,以降低死亡率。能够净化中毒地点的快速反应小组可以挽救许多秃鹫的生命(Murn和Botha 2018)。然而,它们的有效性仅限于及时发现的少数事件。可悲的是,大多数事件没有被注意到,或者发现得太晚,例如2020年几内亚比绍大屠杀。生物学的迅速发展为打击中毒和其他野生动物犯罪提供了有力的工具。通过为动物安装GPS装置并跟踪它们的运动和行为,这可以特别操作,最终可以指示特定发病率类型的地点和时间。gps追踪鸟类的死亡探测器算法现在可以通过GSM和/或卫星发送接近活体的死亡警报。此外,在ICARUS卫星传输(将于2026年发射)等新开发和开发系统的推动下,传输成本不断下降,这使得大规模部署变得可行、负担得起和可靠,尤其是在不久的将来(Kays and Wikelski 2023)。ICARUS系统在没有GSM覆盖的地区将特别有价值,在这些地区,由于基于电话的传输差距,中毒事件可能无法被发现。通过启用基于卫星的数据传输,ICARUS可以确保即使从最偏远的地区也能收到死亡警报。最近在纳米比亚进行的一项研究(Curk et al. 2025)提供了令人信服的证据,证明使用秃鹫作为哨兵的成本效益。通过标记当地人口的5%,有效地识别了整个景观中的中毒事件,并拯救了相当大比例的秃鹫。至关重要的是,拯救的鸟类数量取决于反应的速度。后者取决于记录器发送警报的速度,以及地面团队到达现场的速度。利用当前和新兴的技术,警报已经可以接近实时。基于哨兵的系统可以补充现有的方法,例如使用训练有素的狗。例如,gps标记的哨兵秃鹫最近被证明可以通过近乎实时地揭示中毒事件来指导狗领导的地面工作(Rodríguez-Pérez et al. 2025)。当秃鹫中毒时,许多其他物种,包括哺乳动物,其他猛禽,甚至家畜,也会死在这些被污染的地方。因此,每次中毒事件对生态和保护的影响都是非常广泛的。由于秃鹫在定位尸体方面非常有效,而且受到中毒的影响不成比例,因此它们有可能成为旗舰级的早期预警物种。它们的行动可以及早发现中毒事件,不仅可以拯救其他秃鹫,还可以拯救整个食腐动物群落。因此,使用秃鹫作为哨兵的保护意义远远超出了这一群体,并且可能还允许发现原本不会被发现的非法活动。此外,虽然秃鹫是有效的哨兵,但通过对死亡率检测算法进行物种特异性调整,同样的实时检测系统也可以适用于其他物种。将这种方法扩展到其他猛禽、食肉动物、大型食草动物或其他食腐动物身上,将提高对整个生态系统中中毒事件或其他野生动物犯罪的检测。例如,狼和信天翁已被证明能有效地发现可能违反环境法规的行为(Weimerskirch et al. 2020; Mateo-Tomás et al. 2023)。
期刊介绍:
Conservation Letters is a reputable scientific journal that is devoted to the publication of both empirical and theoretical research that has important implications for the conservation of biological diversity. The journal warmly invites submissions from various disciplines within the biological and social sciences, with a particular interest in interdisciplinary work. The primary aim is to advance both pragmatic conservation objectives and scientific knowledge. Manuscripts are subject to a rapid communication schedule, therefore they should address current and relevant topics. Research articles should effectively communicate the significance of their findings in relation to conservation policy and practice.