A multicenter study evaluating the gastrointestinal tolerance and acceptability of a novel high-energy, high-protein, plant-based enteral tube feed for adults
James Evans , Antonino Salvia , Rosa Maria Burgos , Fernanda Mucarzel , Sharan Saduera
{"title":"A multicenter study evaluating the gastrointestinal tolerance and acceptability of a novel high-energy, high-protein, plant-based enteral tube feed for adults","authors":"James Evans , Antonino Salvia , Rosa Maria Burgos , Fernanda Mucarzel , Sharan Saduera","doi":"10.1016/j.nutos.2025.100624","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"<div><h3>Background & Aims</h3><div>In 2023, 2.6 million Europeans were estimated to be vegan, approximately 3 % of the European population. Few plant-based products exist for patients who need tube feeding. Furthermore, the tube-fed population often have gastrointestinal intolerance to milk-based proteins due to underlying pathology. A plant-based feed may be better tolerated. This study aimed to evaluate acceptability, compliance and gastrointestinal tolerance of a novel high-energy, high-protein, plant-based enteral tube feed.</div></div><div><h3>Methods</h3><div>A single-arm, prospective study in three centers was conducted. Adults ≥16 years, established on a tube feed for disease-related malnutrition which provided ≥50 % of energy requirements were included. Patients were swapped from their usual feed to the study product Compleat® plant protein 1.6 (a plant-based, high-energy, high-protein tube feed) for seven days. Acceptability (patient satisfaction), compliance (volume of feed taken versus prescribed) and gastrointestinal tolerance (diarrhea, constipation, vomiting, nausea) were assessed by self-reported questionnaire. This included multiple-choice questions, Likert scales and free text comments.</div></div><div><h3>Results</h3><div>Twenty-one patients were recruited, of which five withdrew, two due to worsening gastrointestinal symptoms with the study product. Sixteen patients completed data collection, mean age 53.3 years, 44 % female, 56 % had cancer, 75 % had a gastrostomy. Mean daily volume of Compleat® plant protein 1.6 consumed versus prescribed was 992 mL v 1058 mL (94 % compliance). Mean calorie and protein intake was 1555 kcals and 82.6 g respectively and 69 % tolerated the study feed with no change in gastrointestinal symptoms compared to baseline, whilst 25 % reported significant improvements in their gastrointestinal symptoms. Forty four percent were satisfied with the new feed, 38 % were neither satisfied nor dissatisfied.</div></div><div><h3>Conclusions</h3><div>Compleat® plant protein 1.6 was very acceptable to patients and associated with high levels of compliance and good gastrointestinal tolerance. For patients who follow a plant-based diet Compleat® plant protein 1.6 offers an innovative enteral tube feed that does not contain added milk or soya ingredients. Clinicians could consider this feed when patients have gastrointestinal intolerance to a milk-based feed.</div></div>","PeriodicalId":36134,"journal":{"name":"Clinical Nutrition Open Science","volume":"65 ","pages":"Article 100624"},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2026-02-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Clinical Nutrition Open Science","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2667268525001512","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"2026/1/5 0:00:00","PubModel":"Epub","JCR":"Q3","JCRName":"Nursing","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
Background & Aims
In 2023, 2.6 million Europeans were estimated to be vegan, approximately 3 % of the European population. Few plant-based products exist for patients who need tube feeding. Furthermore, the tube-fed population often have gastrointestinal intolerance to milk-based proteins due to underlying pathology. A plant-based feed may be better tolerated. This study aimed to evaluate acceptability, compliance and gastrointestinal tolerance of a novel high-energy, high-protein, plant-based enteral tube feed.
Methods
A single-arm, prospective study in three centers was conducted. Adults ≥16 years, established on a tube feed for disease-related malnutrition which provided ≥50 % of energy requirements were included. Patients were swapped from their usual feed to the study product Compleat® plant protein 1.6 (a plant-based, high-energy, high-protein tube feed) for seven days. Acceptability (patient satisfaction), compliance (volume of feed taken versus prescribed) and gastrointestinal tolerance (diarrhea, constipation, vomiting, nausea) were assessed by self-reported questionnaire. This included multiple-choice questions, Likert scales and free text comments.
Results
Twenty-one patients were recruited, of which five withdrew, two due to worsening gastrointestinal symptoms with the study product. Sixteen patients completed data collection, mean age 53.3 years, 44 % female, 56 % had cancer, 75 % had a gastrostomy. Mean daily volume of Compleat® plant protein 1.6 consumed versus prescribed was 992 mL v 1058 mL (94 % compliance). Mean calorie and protein intake was 1555 kcals and 82.6 g respectively and 69 % tolerated the study feed with no change in gastrointestinal symptoms compared to baseline, whilst 25 % reported significant improvements in their gastrointestinal symptoms. Forty four percent were satisfied with the new feed, 38 % were neither satisfied nor dissatisfied.
Conclusions
Compleat® plant protein 1.6 was very acceptable to patients and associated with high levels of compliance and good gastrointestinal tolerance. For patients who follow a plant-based diet Compleat® plant protein 1.6 offers an innovative enteral tube feed that does not contain added milk or soya ingredients. Clinicians could consider this feed when patients have gastrointestinal intolerance to a milk-based feed.
2023年,估计有260万欧洲人是素食主义者,约占欧洲人口的3%。很少有植物性产品适合需要管饲的患者。此外,由于潜在的病理,管饲人群往往对乳基蛋白有胃肠道不耐受。植物性饲料的耐受性可能更好。本研究旨在评估一种新型高能量、高蛋白、植物性肠内管饲料的可接受性、依从性和胃肠道耐受性。方法在三个中心进行单臂前瞻性研究。纳入年龄≥16岁、因疾病相关营养不良而采用管饲且能提供≥50%能量需求的成年人。患者从常规饲料切换到研究产品Compleat®植物蛋白1.6(一种基于植物的高能量高蛋白管饲)7天。可接受性(患者满意度)、依从性(服用饲料量与处方量)和胃肠耐受性(腹泻、便秘、呕吐、恶心)通过自我报告问卷进行评估。这包括多项选择题、李克特量表和自由文本评论。结果共纳入21例患者,其中5例退出,2例因使用本研究产品后胃肠道症状恶化。16例患者完成资料收集,平均年龄53.3岁,44%为女性,56%为癌症,75%为胃造口术。与处方相比,Compleat®植物蛋白1.6的平均每日用量为992 mL vs 1058 mL(94%的依从性)。平均卡路里和蛋白质摄入量分别为1555千卡和82.6克,69%的人耐受研究饲料,胃肠道症状与基线相比没有变化,而25%的人报告胃肠道症状有显着改善。44%的人对新饲料感到满意,38%的人既不满意也不满意。结论compleat®植物蛋白1.6对患者非常可接受,具有较高的依从性和良好的胃肠耐受性。对于遵循植物性饮食的患者,Compleat®植物蛋白1.6提供了一种创新的肠内管饲料,不含添加牛奶或大豆成分。当患者对乳基饲料有胃肠道不耐受时,临床医生可以考虑使用这种饲料。