{"title":"Bridging Scales: Mesoscience as a Transformative Methodology","authors":"Raffaella Ocone","doi":"10.1002/cai2.70033","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"<p>The paper “Challenges in Immune System: Mesoscale and mesoregime complexity” by Ren et al. [<span>1</span>] represents more than an important advance in immunology; it offers a growing recognition of mesoscience as a unifying scientific framework for understanding complexity. By applying the mesoscience approach to the immune system, the authors demonstrate the power and versatility of a methodology first developed by Prof. Li and colleagues and refined over more than three decades of research [<span>2</span>]. Grounded in the principle of <i>“compromise in competition”</i>, mesoscience focuses on the mesoscale, the critical scale between microscopic and macroscopic scales, where highly relevant phenomena happen. Mesoscale has already proven its high relevance in engineering. This new contribution exemplifies its equally profound potential in the life sciences and indeed in other scientific domains.</p><p>For decades, immunology has thrived on the molecular and cellular levels, revealing fundamental mechanisms underlying receptor–ligand interactions, signal transduction, gene regulation and cell differentiation. Traditionally, in studying and modelling the immune system, a reductionist approach has been followed; such an approach, whilst foundational, captures only a fraction of the immune system's complexity. Immunity is not simply a molecular phenomenon, but it is a dynamic, multilevel system essential for maintaining organismal homoeostasis.</p><p>The immune system integrates both innate and adaptive components, offering broad-spectrum and antigen-specific defences, respectively. Beyond pathogen clearance, it contributes to tissue remodelling, wound healing, tumour surveillance and microbiota regulation, illustrating its operation across biomolecular, cellular, tissue, and organismal levels. At the heart of this complexity are mesoscale structures, namely spatiotemporally dynamic organisational frameworks that link local molecular events to global immune behaviours. These mesoscale structures are “nested” across all four levels of organisation (i.e., biomolecular, cellular, organ and organismal levels), making a meso-science perspective essential to fully reveal the system's complexity. Most immunological research remains confined to molecular and cellular layers. Omics technologies, while powerful, often produce fragmented snapshots of a system in motion. The mesoscale, by contrast, offers a conceptual and analytical bridge, one that can connect the molecular detail to the system-level function.</p><p>The immune system operates through <i>nested mesoscale structures</i>, spanning biomolecular, cellular, tissue and organismal levels. These structures govern how local interactions propagate upward, influencing processes as diverse as tissue remodelling, tumour surveillance, and host–microbiota balance.</p><p>The paper by Ren and coauthors provides an extremely timely illustration of the high potential of mesoscience in immunology. Based on the integration of techniques readily available, such as high-resolution imaging, spatial proteomics and single-cell approaches with multiscale computational modelling, it is shown that the mesoscience framework can capture how local molecular processes generate mesoscale patterns that shape immune behaviour. This not only offers new ways to interrogate the immune system but also opens a path towards predictive modelling, which is proposed as an essential step for advancing next-generation therapies. Importantly, the work also underscores the limits of reductionism. Many of the immune system's most pressing questions, from drug delivery barriers to microenvironmental resistance, are mesoscale in nature and cannot be resolved by molecular analysis alone.</p><p>The significance of this contribution, however, extends far beyond immunology. Mesoscience provides a rigorous, unifying framework for addressing complexity across disciplines, from engineering and physics to biology, environmental science and medicine. By focusing on the intermediate scale where competing forces interact and compromise, mesoscience enables researchers to reveal the organising principles that govern complex systems. In doing so, it offers not merely new tools but a new way of thinking.</p><p>This is a call to action. The integration of mesoscience into more areas of enquiry has the potential to reshape the scientific landscape. Realising this vision will require more than disciplinary excellence; it demands active, sustained collaboration among fields, involving molecular biologists, engineers, physicists, clinicians, data scientists and experimentalists. High-quality collaborations, together with the sharing of data, will be essential to converge towards a scientific framework that will solve problems and explain mesoscale patterns and phenomena.</p><p>The paper exemplifies how mesoscience can move a field forward. But it also points to something larger: the emergence of a new scientific language for complexity, one capable of transcending traditional boundaries. Embracing this framework will not only advance immunology but also provide a powerful platform for discovery across the sciences.</p><p><b>Raffaella Ocone:</b> writing and proofing.</p><p>The author has nothing to report.</p><p>The author has nothing to report.</p><p>The author declares no conflicts of interest.</p>","PeriodicalId":100212,"journal":{"name":"Cancer Innovation","volume":"4 6","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":2.0000,"publicationDate":"2025-11-09","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1002/cai2.70033","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Cancer Innovation","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/cai2.70033","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
The paper “Challenges in Immune System: Mesoscale and mesoregime complexity” by Ren et al. [1] represents more than an important advance in immunology; it offers a growing recognition of mesoscience as a unifying scientific framework for understanding complexity. By applying the mesoscience approach to the immune system, the authors demonstrate the power and versatility of a methodology first developed by Prof. Li and colleagues and refined over more than three decades of research [2]. Grounded in the principle of “compromise in competition”, mesoscience focuses on the mesoscale, the critical scale between microscopic and macroscopic scales, where highly relevant phenomena happen. Mesoscale has already proven its high relevance in engineering. This new contribution exemplifies its equally profound potential in the life sciences and indeed in other scientific domains.
For decades, immunology has thrived on the molecular and cellular levels, revealing fundamental mechanisms underlying receptor–ligand interactions, signal transduction, gene regulation and cell differentiation. Traditionally, in studying and modelling the immune system, a reductionist approach has been followed; such an approach, whilst foundational, captures only a fraction of the immune system's complexity. Immunity is not simply a molecular phenomenon, but it is a dynamic, multilevel system essential for maintaining organismal homoeostasis.
The immune system integrates both innate and adaptive components, offering broad-spectrum and antigen-specific defences, respectively. Beyond pathogen clearance, it contributes to tissue remodelling, wound healing, tumour surveillance and microbiota regulation, illustrating its operation across biomolecular, cellular, tissue, and organismal levels. At the heart of this complexity are mesoscale structures, namely spatiotemporally dynamic organisational frameworks that link local molecular events to global immune behaviours. These mesoscale structures are “nested” across all four levels of organisation (i.e., biomolecular, cellular, organ and organismal levels), making a meso-science perspective essential to fully reveal the system's complexity. Most immunological research remains confined to molecular and cellular layers. Omics technologies, while powerful, often produce fragmented snapshots of a system in motion. The mesoscale, by contrast, offers a conceptual and analytical bridge, one that can connect the molecular detail to the system-level function.
The immune system operates through nested mesoscale structures, spanning biomolecular, cellular, tissue and organismal levels. These structures govern how local interactions propagate upward, influencing processes as diverse as tissue remodelling, tumour surveillance, and host–microbiota balance.
The paper by Ren and coauthors provides an extremely timely illustration of the high potential of mesoscience in immunology. Based on the integration of techniques readily available, such as high-resolution imaging, spatial proteomics and single-cell approaches with multiscale computational modelling, it is shown that the mesoscience framework can capture how local molecular processes generate mesoscale patterns that shape immune behaviour. This not only offers new ways to interrogate the immune system but also opens a path towards predictive modelling, which is proposed as an essential step for advancing next-generation therapies. Importantly, the work also underscores the limits of reductionism. Many of the immune system's most pressing questions, from drug delivery barriers to microenvironmental resistance, are mesoscale in nature and cannot be resolved by molecular analysis alone.
The significance of this contribution, however, extends far beyond immunology. Mesoscience provides a rigorous, unifying framework for addressing complexity across disciplines, from engineering and physics to biology, environmental science and medicine. By focusing on the intermediate scale where competing forces interact and compromise, mesoscience enables researchers to reveal the organising principles that govern complex systems. In doing so, it offers not merely new tools but a new way of thinking.
This is a call to action. The integration of mesoscience into more areas of enquiry has the potential to reshape the scientific landscape. Realising this vision will require more than disciplinary excellence; it demands active, sustained collaboration among fields, involving molecular biologists, engineers, physicists, clinicians, data scientists and experimentalists. High-quality collaborations, together with the sharing of data, will be essential to converge towards a scientific framework that will solve problems and explain mesoscale patterns and phenomena.
The paper exemplifies how mesoscience can move a field forward. But it also points to something larger: the emergence of a new scientific language for complexity, one capable of transcending traditional boundaries. Embracing this framework will not only advance immunology but also provide a powerful platform for discovery across the sciences.
Ren等人发表的论文《Challenges in Immune System: Mesoscale and mesoreme complexity》不仅代表了免疫学的重要进展;它使人们越来越认识到中科学是理解复杂性的统一科学框架。通过将中科学方法应用于免疫系统,作者展示了一种由李教授及其同事首先开发并经过30多年研究改进的方法的力量和多功能性。基于“在竞争中妥协”的原则,中观科学关注中尺度,即微观和宏观尺度之间的临界尺度,高度相关的现象发生在这里。中尺度已经证明了它在工程上的高度相关性。这一新的贡献体现了它在生命科学乃至其他科学领域同样深刻的潜力。几十年来,免疫学在分子和细胞水平上蓬勃发展,揭示了受体-配体相互作用、信号转导、基因调控和细胞分化的基本机制。传统上,在研究和模拟免疫系统时,遵循的是一种简化的方法;这种方法虽然是基础的,但只能捕捉到免疫系统复杂性的一小部分。免疫不仅仅是一种分子现象,它是一个动态的、多层次的系统,对维持机体内平衡至关重要。免疫系统整合了先天和适应性成分,分别提供广谱和抗原特异性防御。除了清除病原体外,它还有助于组织重塑、伤口愈合、肿瘤监测和微生物群调节,说明了它在生物分子、细胞、组织和有机体水平上的运作。这种复杂性的核心是中尺度结构,即将局部分子事件与全局免疫行为联系起来的时空动态组织框架。这些中尺度结构“嵌套”在所有四个组织水平(即生物分子、细胞、器官和有机体水平)上,使得中尺度科学的视角对于充分揭示系统的复杂性至关重要。大多数免疫学研究仍然局限于分子和细胞层面。组学技术虽然强大,但往往只能生成系统运动时的碎片快照。相比之下,中尺度提供了一个概念和分析的桥梁,可以将分子细节与系统级功能联系起来。免疫系统通过嵌套的中尺度结构运作,跨越生物分子、细胞、组织和有机体水平。这些结构控制着局部相互作用如何向上传播,影响着组织重塑、肿瘤监测和宿主-微生物群平衡等多种过程。Ren及其合著者的论文非常及时地说明了介科学在免疫学中的巨大潜力。基于现有技术的整合,如高分辨率成像、空间蛋白质组学和单细胞方法与多尺度计算建模,表明中观科学框架可以捕捉局部分子过程如何产生塑造免疫行为的中尺度模式。这不仅提供了询问免疫系统的新方法,而且为预测建模开辟了一条道路,这被认为是推进下一代治疗的重要一步。重要的是,这项工作也强调了还原论的局限性。许多免疫系统最紧迫的问题,从药物输送障碍到微环境抗性,本质上是中尺度的,不能仅通过分子分析来解决。然而,这一贡献的意义远远超出了免疫学。中科学提供了一个严谨、统一的框架,用于解决从工程、物理学到生物学、环境科学和医学等学科的复杂性。通过关注竞争力量相互作用和妥协的中间尺度,介科学使研究人员能够揭示支配复杂系统的组织原则。在这样做的过程中,它不仅提供了新的工具,而且提供了一种新的思维方式。这是一个行动的号召。将介科学整合到更多的研究领域有可能重塑科学景观。实现这一愿景需要的不仅仅是学科卓越;它需要分子生物学家、工程师、物理学家、临床医生、数据科学家和实验学家等领域之间积极、持续的合作。高质量的合作以及数据共享对于形成一个解决问题和解释中尺度模式和现象的科学框架至关重要。这篇论文举例说明了介科学如何推动一个领域向前发展。但它也指出了一些更大的东西:一种新的科学语言的出现,一种能够超越传统界限的复杂性。 拥抱这一框架不仅将推进免疫学,而且还将为跨科学的发现提供一个强大的平台。Raffaella Ocone:写作和校对。作者没有什么可报道的。作者没有什么可报道的。作者声明无利益冲突。