Dynamic brain states during reasoning tasks: a co-activation pattern analysis

Abstract

Brain activity exhibits substantial temporal variability during cognitive processes, yet traditional fMRI analyses often fail to capture these dynamic patterns. Co-activation pattern (CAP) analysis has emerged as a promising method to study brain dynamics. CAP analysis provides a powerful framework for capturing transient brain states, however, its application to cognitive tasks remains very limited, with no prior studies specifically investigating its role in reasoning performance. This study investigated CAPs during reasoning tasks, their relationship with cognitive performance, age and other individual differences. We applied CAP analysis to fMRI data from 303 participants performing three reasoning tasks—Matrix Reasoning, Letter Sets, and Paper Folding—along with resting-state data. Using K-means clustering, we identified four distinct CAPs, each exhibiting unique spatial and temporal characteristics. These CAPs were analyzed in relation to predefined resting-state networks, revealing their functional relevance to cognitive task engagement. Key temporal metrics, including fraction occupancy, dwelling time, and transition probabilities, were assessed across reasoning tasks and resting state. The results demonstrate that CAP2 and CAP3 are predominantly engaged during reasoning tasks, with CAP2 strongly overlapping with the visual network and CAP3 exhibiting concurrent default mode and sensorimotor network activations. CAP1, primarily dominant during rest, showed prolonged engagement in older individuals, while CAP4 appeared to function as a transitional state facilitating network reorganization. Regression analyses link longer dwelling times and higher fraction occupancy of CAP2 and CAP3 to superior reasoning performance, whereas excessive transitions to CAP4 negatively impacted cognitive task outcomes. Additionally, aging was associated with reduced engagement in task-relevant CAPs and an increased tendency to transition into baseline-like states. These findings underscore the critical role of dynamic brain state reconfigurations in supporting cognition specifically reasoning and highlight CAP analysis as a powerful tool for studying transient brain function and individual cognitive differences.