Resistance Training Beyond Momentary Failure: The Effects of Past-Failure Partials Versus Initial Partials on Calf Muscle Hypertrophy Among a Resistance-Trained Cohort

Abstract

This study compared calf training with initial partial repetitions versus full range-of-motion (ROM) repetitions followed by past-failure partials on gastrocnemius hypertrophy. Twenty-three participants (men: n = 16 and women: n = 7) performed four sets of unilateral Smith machine calf raises to momentary failure twice a week for 8 weeks. One leg was trained using initial partials to their individualized maximum dorsiflexion ROM. The contralateral leg was trained with a full ROM and continued with past-failure partials after failure in peak plantarflexion. Medial gastrocnemius muscle thickness was measured with ultrasonography both baseline and postintervention. A Bayesian framework was used to estimate the average treatment effect (ATE) using credible intervals and Bayes factors (BFs). The ATE posterior distribution indicated a greater increase in muscle hypertrophy for the initial partial condition (0.40 [95% CrI: −0.06 to 0.85 mm]; p (> 0) = 0.958), with a BF of 1.2 suggesting “anecdotal” evidence in favor of an effect. Within-condition analyses using standardized mean difference estimates indicated that the interventions were likely to produce medium to large improvements. These findings suggest that both initial partials and past-failure partials are viable strategies for achieving gastrocnemius hypertrophy. Although the average change favored initial partials, the estimated difference was uncertain, and the Bayes factor provided only anecdotal support for a differential effect.