Radiometric temperature measurement for metal additive manufacturing via temperature emissivity separation

Abstract

Emission of blackbody radiation from the meltpool and surrounding area in laser powder bed fusion (LPBF) makes this process visible to a range of optical monitoring instruments intended for online process and quality assessment. Yet, these instruments have not proven capable of reliably detecting the finest flaws that influence LPBF component mechanical performance, limiting their adoption. One hindrance lies in interpreting measurements of radiance as temperature, despite the physical link between these variables being readily understood as a combination of Planck’s Law and spectral emissivity. Uncertainty in spectral emissivity arises as it is nearly impossible to predict and can be a strong function of wavelength; in turn, this manifests uncertainty in estimated temperatures and thereby obscures the LPBF process dynamics that indicate component defects. This paper presents temperature emissivity separation (TES) as a method for accurate retrieval of optically-measured temperatures in LPBF. TES simultaneously calculates both temperature and spectral emissivity from spectrally-resolved radiance measurements and, as the latter term is effectively measured, more accurate process temperatures result. Using a bespoke imaging spectrometer integrated with an LPBF testbed to evaluate this approach, three basic TES algorithms are compared in a validation experiment that demonstrates retrieval of temperatures accurate to $\pm 28$ K over a 1000 K range. A second investigation proves industrial feasibility through fabrication of an LPBF test artifact. Temperature data are used to study the evolution of fusion process boundary conditions, including a decrease in cooling rate as layerwise printing proceeds. A provisional correlation of temperature fields to component porosity assessed by 3D computed tomography demonstrates in situ optical detection of micron-scale porous defects in LPBF.