Divergent trends in fluvial suspended-sediment concentrations following improved land-use practices, southwest Washington State

Abstract

Improvements in logging practices since the mid-20th century are widely presumed to have reduced suspended sediment loads in streams across the Pacific Northwest. However, there have been few opportunities to directly assess this, particularly in larger rivers. We compare modern (2019–22) and historical (1960s) suspended sediment monitoring in three large, actively managed watersheds in western Washington with similar land-use histories. In the two watersheds draining the southern Olympic Mountains (Satsop and Wynoochee Rivers), modern sediment yields were around 300 t/km²/yr, two to three times lower than historical conditions. Most suspended sediment exiting these watersheds came from rolling terrain mantled by glacial deposits in the lower watersheds, not the steep headwaters. Modern sediment yields in the Chehalis River, draining the low-relief Willapa Hills, were lower (70 t/km²/yr), though this represented a 50 % increase relative to historical conditions. SSC-discharge relations in the Chehalis River were steady from 1961 to 1994, indicating this increase happened sometime after 1994. The Chehalis River headwaters were uniquely impacted by landsliding during a 2007 storm, though there is some evidence against that storm as the cause of the recent increase. Ultimately, improved land-use practices appear to have reduced suspended sediment loads in large rivers of the southern Olympic Mountains several-fold, consistent with prior findings in the western Olympic Mountains, primarily due to reduced sediment delivery from the lower watersheds. Countervailing SSC-discharge trends and lower yields in the Chehalis River underscore that background sediment delivery rates and sensitivity to land-use disturbance may vary substantially within a region.