Trigeminal Nerve Stimulation as a Semi-Active Control Condition in TMS Clinical Trials: Evidence From Heart-Brain Coupling and Clinical Outcomes.

Abstract

The inertness of sham controls in transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) studies, particularly those involving Transcutaneous Electrical Nerve Stimulation (TENS), remains controversial. Using heart-brain coupling (HBC) as a frontal-vagal engagement measure, we analyzed pilot data and data from two placebo-controlled accelerated intermittent theta burst stimulation (aiTBS) trials (combined N=100). Active-TMS induced significantly stronger HBC compared to sham in both studies, with the effect size for TENS-sham considerably attenuated, and significantly stronger HBC for TENS-sham relative to SAINT-sham (d=0.9). HBC in the TENS-sham group was associated with clinical improvement (d=1.12), reflecting antidepressant effects of trigeminal nerve stimulation. These findings suggest TENS-sham should be seen as a semi-active control condition, also controlling for trigeminal nerve stimulation, resulting in downstream vagal and cortical engagement and thus controlling for this non-specific effect of TMS. Future studies should be aware of this semi-active effect and conduct power-analyses accordingly, modifying the expected effect size. Furthermore, HBC could be used to titrate the intensity of TENS-stimulation to minimize semi-active effects.