Differential metabolic responses to very-low calorie diets in individuals with, and without type 2 diabetes: a review.

Abstract

Introduction: Very-low calorie-diets (VLCD) are becoming increasingly popular for managing overweight, obesity and type 2 diabetes (T2D). Beta-cell dysfunction and insulin resistance (IR) is present in individuals living with overweight and obesity, with or without T2D. Results from metabolic studies investigating the effect of VLCD on beta cell function (BCF) and IR are inconsistent, despite the well-documented effects on weight and glycaemic control.

Areas covered: We undertook a narrative review of studies identified from PubMed and their associated reference lists, examining apparent discrepancies in the literature on this topic. Evidence broadly suggests a positive impact of VLCD, although the outcome being measured, and method of assessment could influence the observed effect. The VLCD duration is a critical factor, as longer-term interventions are required to consistently demonstrate improvements in BCF and peripheral IR. Hepatic IR appears to be particularly responsive to short-term caloric restriction.

Expert opinion: When interpreting metabolic results of VLCD intervention studies, particular attention must be paid to the selected method of assessing BCF and IR. Improvement in BCF exhibits significant heterogeneity, possibly related to individual participant's clinical characteristics. Beneficial effects on hepatic IR occur in the early stage of VCLD intervention, preceding changes in peripheral IR and BCF.