[Finite element analysis of the correlation between lateral collateral ligament injury of the ankle joint and subtalar articular cartilage injury].

Abstract

Objective: To establish foot and ankle models of different lateral collateral ligament injuries of ankle joint, and conduct finite element analysis on, and to explore the force conditions of subtalar articular cartilage during foot inversion movements under different gait stages and under different loads.

Methods: A normal ankle CT scan of a 30-year-old male healthy volunteer (heighted 175 cm and weighted 60 kg) was selected. The CT images were imported into software such as Mimics 21.0, Geomajic 2017, and Solidworks 2017 respectively, extract the normal ankle bone model. Then, the foot and ankle finite element models of different lateral collateral ligament injuries of ankle joint were constructed and divided into anterior talofibular ligament(ATFL) rupture group, ATFL and calcaneo fibular ligament (CFL) rupture group, ATFL, CFL and posterior talofibular ligament (PTFL) rupture group, and control group with intact ligament function by ANSYS 2021. Corresponding horizontal and vertical loads and torques were applied respectively on tibia and talus according to the force conditions of different phases to simulate landing phase, neutral and off-ground phase in walking gait. The changes in stress distribution area and stress peak of subtalar articular cartilage in the loading phase, neutral phase and off-ground phase gaits among four groups were observed. Simulate varus sprain action, apply different loads of 600, 1, 800, and 4, 200 N respectively, and changes in stress distribution area and the stress peak of subtalar articular cartilage among four groups of models were observed.

Results: In the gait simulation, the stress results of loading phase in ATFL fracture group, ATFL and CFL fracture groups, ATFL, CFL and PTFL fracture groups, and control group were 0.889 54, 0.960 89, 1.139 20, and 0.722 64 MPa, respectively. The neutral response force results were 1.250 60, 1.358 50, 1.363 70, 1.246 40 MPa respectively;the results of corresponding forces off-ground phase were 1.029 90, 1.138 70, 1.145 90 and 0.832 40 MPa respectively. In the inversion simulation, the stresses of ATFL fracture group, ATFL and CFL fracture groups, ATFL, CFL and PTFL fracture groups, and control group under load of 600 N were 2.191 3, 2.208 5, 2.215 7, and 2.156 6 MPa respectively. The stresses under a load of 1 800 N were 7.134 7, 9.715 2, 10.064 0, and 7.107 0 MPa respectively;the stresses under a load of 4 200 N were 17.435 0, 25.309 0, 26.119 0 and 16.010 0 MPa respectively.

Conclusion: The lateral collateral ligament of ankle joint plays an important role in the stability of the subtalar joint, especially CFL plays an important role in restricting calcaneal varus. If these ligaments are damaged, it will cause instability of the subtalar joint and further lead to lesions in the subtalar articular cartilage. Relevant exercises should be reduced or the ligament injuries should be treated in a timely manner.