Transgender and gender diverse patients' preference and comfort for having a medical chaperone present during a sensitive physical examination: a single-site study.

Abstract

Background: Medical chaperones are authorized individuals present during physical examinations involving the genitals, breasts/chest, or anal areas. The use of medical chaperones may provide an opportunity to improve transgender and gender diverse (TGD) patients' experiences with sensitive examinations.

Aim: To examine TGD adult patients' preferences and comfort for having a medical chaperone and whether TGD-specific characteristics, social anxiety symptoms, and feelings of medical mistrust are associated with preference for having a medical chaperone present during a sensitive physical examination.

Methods: This study used a cross-sectional survey that randomly sampled adult patients from a gender clinic in the Midwest region of the U.S. A total of 420 surveys were mailed. Sixty-two surveys were returned undeliverable, 358 reached recipients; 151 were returned (42.1% response rate). The survey included items related to demographics, gender-related anatomical dysphoria, social anxiety symptoms, feelings of medical mistrust, and preference and comfort towards medical chaperones.

Results: Among 149 respondents, 74 (49.7%) reported comfort for the idea of having a medical chaperone present during a sensitive physical examination, 50 (33.6%) reported neutral comfort, and 25 (16.8%) reported discomfort. Among 147 respondents, 89 (60.5%) endorsed a preference for a female medical chaperone. We found no associations between gender-related anatomical dysphoria or social anxiety symptoms and comfort for having a medical chaperone, or the gender preference for a medical chaperone. Medical mistrust was associated with lower comfort with having a medical chaperone present during a sensitive physical examination.

Clinical implications: Routinely offering medical chaperones, especially female chaperones, is like to be generally acceptable to most TGD patients. These findings may inform clinic policies on providing medical chaperones during sensitive examinations.

Strengths and limitations: This study is the first to examine TGD preferences for medical chaperones. Findings are limited by a single site, homogeneous sample, cross-sectional design, and reliance on hypothetical rather than observed examinations.

Conclusion: TGD adults report comfort with the concept of having a medical chaperone during sensitive examinations and most would prefer the chaperone to be female. Preference for having a medical chaperone present during a sensitive physical exam is not likely influenced by gender dysphoria or social anxiety.