Methods of measuring radiographic patellofemoral joint alignment and morphology: A scoping review

Abstract

Objective

Conduct a scoping review to identify radiographic measures of patellofemoral joint (PFJ) alignment and bony morphology reported in literature published during a representative period (2014–2018), and describe their reported measurement properties.

Design

Eight electronic databases were searched using keywords relating to “patellofemoral” and “radiograph”. Identified records were screened for eligibility by two independent assessors. English-language studies published in the years 2014–2018 were included if they reported: (i) acquiring PFJ radiographs; (ii) method of radiograph acquisition; and (iii) descriptions of radiographic PFJ alignment and bony morphology measures. Non-human and cadaveric studies, single-case studies, and studies with mean participant age <10 years were excluded. For studies that reported measurement properties (reliability, validity, responsiveness), quality appraisal was performed by two independent assessors using the COSMIN Risk of Bias tool. Descriptive data were reported.

Results

Of 18,678 records identified, 336 articles met our criteria . Ninety-one unique radiographic alignment and morphology measures were described. Most prevalent were measures of patellar height (222, 66.1 %), patellar alignment (142, 42.3 %), and patellar inclination (121, 36 %). Reliability data were reported by 83 (24.7 %) of the studies.

Conclusions

During the selected period, 91 different radiographic measures of PFJ alignment and morphology were reported, with multiple methods used to obtain similar measures, and limited data on reliability and validity. These findings make it difficult to recommend specific measures for clinical and research use. Further studies are needed to determine the measurement properties of radiographic PFJ alignment and morphology measures, and to establish consensus-based recommendations for priority measures and acquisition methods for specific PFJ conditions.